3 ms·
"Are you absolutely sure that there is a chemical process to convert extrnal heat into mass that is not neglible in comparison to how much mass is saved by the
by dllthomas 12y ago
"Are you absolutely sure that there is a chemical process to convert extrnal heat into mass that is not neglible in comparison to how much mass is saved by the body when it does not have to heat itself at that temperature?"
I'm not absolutely sure of much of anything, and that's my point. And I said it "might be a good enough approximation" to ignore it.
"As for your second point, we have a lot of experience with people starving themselves, even to death. And we pretty much know that fat is one of the thing that goes first. You can also look at people after gut surgery. Nothing special changes for them. They just can no longer eat vastly more than they need. And they loose weight."
And for the fifth fucking time I agree that there is evidence that eating fewer calories helps one lose weight - but to draw conclusions you need that evidence, not "simple thermodynamics", which is my entire point.
- scotty79 12y agoI still fail to get your point. It's exactly because of thermodynamics. People who trip, fall, because gravity. People who eat less than they burn loose weight, because thermodynamics. Both processes are more complex but laws of physics draw the boundaries of how that complexity might influence outcome.
- dllthomas 12y agoIf you seriously still fail to get my point, I think I'm done with you here.
- scotty79 12y agoYup. I feel that you also miss mine. Let's just silently think about each others points for some extended period of time.
- dllthomas 12y agoNope, I understand your point, you're just still wrong for a pile of reasons that either I've been unable to express sufficiently clearly, you've been ignoring, or some combination thereof. No one is suggesting that there's no thermodynamics involved. The objection is to using "thermodynamics, duh" as an argument. I generally encounter this in the stronger form of "the only thing that matters for weight loss is consuming fewer calories than you burn, because thermodynamics." That's obviously puerile. However, I think even in your more constrained (and better supported) usage here ("if you burn more energy than you eat, you will lose weight") it is still the case that you need to know other things about human biology; further, you need to know many more things to determine whether losing weight that way is advisable (even before incorporating the many physiological or psychological things that might mediate difficulty), which is the bit that actually matters. These "many more things", we do have quite a bit of evidence regarding. But that evidence needs to be incorporated into the arguments to make the arguments meaningful.
- scotty79 12y agoOk. I think I get your point now. I just don't agree. > it is still the case that you need to know other things about human biology; further, you need to know many more things to determine whether losing weight that way is advisable I believe that there are times when you need to be pragmatic and act before you know more. You might not be sure that losing weight (or that most obvious way to loose weight) is best for any given person but it's still an adivce they should take if they are overweight. Just like it's a still good advice to excercise even if you are not perfectly sure that excersising won't kill you. You can take position of "I'm not sure. I better stay on my couch till the data comes in, indicating that it's healthy for me to run a bit." but that's not wise. You can't put yourself into stasis before you are sure if it's a good thing to eat less than you burn. Your life goes on and you need to act on incomplete knowledge you have so far. TL;DR I just don't agree that acting on "Do what physics tell you, ought to lower your weight." is worse than acting on "We need to learn more about our biology before we can do anything successful about our weight."
- dllthomas 12y agoWe knew plenty more than "thermodynamics" about losing weight before we knew about thermodynamics. I'm not saying "we need more study before anyone should make any changes to eating habits" - of course we need to operate off the best understanding we have (we certainly can't refrain from eating until we know everything :-P). My point is that reducing things to "thermodynamics, duh" is not doing that.