4 ms·
Why should some people get to tell other people what they can or can't do with their own bodies? Personally I think prostitution should be legal. But to play
by michaelt 12y ago
Why should some people get to tell other people
what they can or can't do with their own bodies?
Personally I think prostitution should be legal. But to play devil's advocate, here are some arguments:
The reasons to oppose trafficking, under age prostitution and violence against prostitutes are obvious. And it's obvious why home owners wouldn't want street walkers outside their front doors. Let's set those aside and consider indoor prostitution without slavery or violence.
1. In many places, to collect unemployment benefits you have to be searching for work, and if you're offered work you must accept it. Would you like to see your daughter or mother denied benefits because she turned down a job offer from a brothel?
2. There are a bunch of things we can't consent to. Even if I sign a contract agreeing to be sold into slavery, or agreeing a loan shark can break my legs, or agreeing to work for less than the minimum wage, that part of the contract is invalid. There's precedent for us making it impossible for people to consent to things.
3. If there's someone I wouldn't otherwise have sex with, but I have sex with them to avoid being stabbed, that's obviously rape. If I do the same thing to avoid being starved, is that so different? Oh, admittedly it's more of a grey area, but surely punters could hold themselves to higher standards and avoid things that are even a grey area?
4. Trafficking and violence are giant problems. About 90% of prostitution is one or the other, and legalising prostitution will increase demand leading to more of both. Isn't it better to sacrifice that small fraction of nonviolent prostitution to help clamp down on the much larger amount of violent prostitution? Oh, sure, the 90%/10% ratio might be a bit off, but slavery and violence are really serious, their impact should be given greater weight.
Not saying I agree with all of them, but I can understand why a politician might decide they have other changes to the law they'd like to see first.
- pinkyand 12y agoIf we consider using the services of a prostitute as emotional violence - which is a reasonable case considering the mental health risks of the profession - and as violence towards weaker people - we should disallow it on a similar basis to minimum wage laws.
- EliRivers 12y agoWould you like to see your daughter or mother denied benefits because she turned down a job offer from a brothel? Or father, or son. Given that it tends to be mostly male customers, we would presumably see straight men having welfare withdrawn because they refuse to let other men have sex with them for money.
- michaelt 12y agoYes; I considered going for "daughter, sister, mother, wife, son, brother, father, or husband" but that's a bit of a mouthful. And I considered going for "loved ones" but I didn't think that had the same sentimental appeal.
- joshfraser 12y agoThose are all great points and things to consider. For me, it's simply a matter of principle. Fundamentally, I don't believe it's the governments job to stop people from engaging in risky behavior or even hurting themselves. The role of government is to protect us from being hurt by other people. When you look at US laws that attempt to regulate carnal living, they're all over the place. Cigarettes are legal, but not marijuana. Alcohol is okay, but not shromes. We make people wear seat-belts, but don't limit their McDonalds intake. Our age restrictions are crazy too. You can die for your country, but you're too young to have a beer. Our laws are a mess because they are written based on money, popular opinion & emotion instead of figuring out how to protect without depriving others of their personal liberty. Just like freedom of speech, I might not agree with what you say/do, but I'll fight for your right to say/do it, as long as it doesn't deprive others of their rights. Much like I support Westboro Baptist Church's right to free speech, I support the legalization of prostitution out of principle, even if it's not something I approve of personally. The strength of your principles are usually measured at the extremes.