5 ms·
Why education is about more than jobs
- akl 17y ago... from a teacher at open university, apparently. I'm sure I'm biased as a college drop out myself, but I've never been impressed by abstract ('learn how to help society!', etc) type reasons to go to college.
- pavel_lishin 17y agoUnderstanding what you read on the news, being able to communicate clearly and effectively, and being able to spot bullshit and faulty arguments when you see it - great reasons to go to college. But 90% of people won't be using what they learn to "improve their community" and whatnot, not unless they're specifically going to school to learn that.
- hughprime 17y agoUnderstanding what you read on the news, being able to communicate clearly and effectively, and being able to spot bullshit and faulty arguments when you see it - great reasons to go to college. It's a pity, then, that these skills aren't very well taught in university (at least on the humanities side). Indeed, if you do a course on, say, Foucault or Derrida then you'll need to unlearn how to spot bullshit and faulty arguments if you want to pass the course since a final essay which says "Derrida in this book says a whole bunch of vague bullshit that doesn't make any real sense" will get low marks. Interestingly, I don't think spotting bullshit or faulty arguments is that difficult a skill -- relatively uneducated people can easily spot a BS argument when it's used to argue for something they don't want to believe. The really hard part is developing the discipline to be able to spot a BS argument even when it's arguing for something you do want to believe. I don't think this skill is very well taught, either.
- chasingsparks 17y agoI have no experience with university education over the pond, but I have to personal observations about the US system: 1) far too many people go to college and 2) the wrong people go to college. Political pressures have created a huge demand for colleges while supply remains comparatively inelastic. Consequently, the student population has become dominated by people whose parents can afford to send them to college, but whose intellectual credentials and academic interest are far from stellar. College revolves around teaching the mean -- and I don't like it. I hope graduate school is different.
- chasingsparks 17y agoI should follow this up by correcting myself: obviously, the pressures are not only political. If a college education offers the perception of competence, then market pressures increase the demand that the universities are more than willing to accommodate. I think -- somehow in a way that I do not see -- universities have to just start being more selective.
- mattj 17y agoI think this attests more to the dangers of early tracking in European societies (didn't take the right tests in high school? You're never going to college) than the benefits of education as access to knowledge. In the us, taking classes like this COULD lead to a job, if you were willing to fight really hard for it.
- gaius 17y agoIf there are intangible benefits, then by all means, have all the intangible support you want. We can't afford to put 50% of the population through university, it's as simple as that.
- fhars 17y agoA modern industrialized society can't afford not to put about 50% of the population through an education that gives them at least something like a bachelors degree.
- kaa2102 17y agoAre we trying to make University trustees rich or have a well-educated and civil society? I don't think 4 years of college are required to teach someone to think critically, be rational, and right/speak well.
- gloob 17y agoI don't want my open heart surgery to be performed by a dropout, no matter how passionate and relentlessly resourceful they might be.
- jerf 17y agoThat's a total strawman. It's not even worth expanding on this reply further.
- gloob 17y agoThat's a total strawman. Not really. It's probably not a terribly popular sentiment on a site for web-based hacker startups, but there are plenty of jobs that actually require some sort of meaningful education. Most of the medical system is composed of such jobs, as are large chunks of the legal system. Government bureaucracy (while the benefits of having a degree in such a job may be questionable) commonly requires them, at least in Canada. The government is not a small employer. 50% may well be excessive, but there are a huge number of jobs out there that demand a degree.
- jrwoodruff 17y agoI might just be imagining it, but I seem to be getting an 'anti-college' vibe, or at least 'anti-traditional education' vibe from HN these past few weeks. Sure, we probably can't afford to send 50% of the country to college. But why not try to send as many as possible, at least of those who want to go? Dominated by those whose parents can afford to send kids to college? Hasn't it always been that way? After all, if you can't afford it, no matter how bad you want to go, you won't. Not without assistance. I'm not sure I understand this negative bent on college education - or am I just reading things wrong?
- cschneid 17y agoLike everything else in politics, there is a nice gray area in education. The internet is very bad at gray areas, and tends toward extremism. The gray area here is between "pursuit of knowledge, become better citizens" and "career school, what is history for anyway". Universities used to be #1, and have shifted toward #2 over the years. Now people see it more as the default to be the career school, and laugh at people who are in favor of learning for the sake of learning. Then the problem is that while both approaches are relatively valid, they lead to different conclusions to the answer of "who should go to college".
- jrwoodruff 17y agoThat makes sense, actually, since I definitely reside solidly in the middle of the two. Prior to college, I was definitely in the 'what is history for' crowd, but college broadened my horizons so much, and I enjoy learning to the extent that I could easily argue the 'pursuit of knowledge' reasoning these days. I went to a liberal arts college for an applied degree, so I guess that's a little of both worlds.