3 ms·
There's also friendly fire. "Dark money" (using your term) isn't allowed to coordinate with the candidate's campaign. But voters don't make the distinction bet
by specialist 12y ago
There's also friendly fire.
"Dark money" (using your term) isn't allowed to coordinate with the candidate's campaign. But voters don't make the distinction between candidates and their supporters.
I've spoken with campaigns who were hurt by independent expenditures by their own supporters, with messaging that reflected poorly on the candidate.
The lack of accountability creates the opportunity to sabotage a campaign. If we can imagine it, I'm sure it's been done.
- smsm42 12y agoThis is not connected with disclosure - you can always have somebody pretend to support you but speak in a way that actually harms you. It's one of the oldest tricks in a political book to have some despised group to publicly support your opponent and thus harm him. Lack of privacy would not help with this - you can always find a frontman or a barter scheme or a PR agency that would agree to channel the money, unless you get rid of the privacy completely, so that no private transactions at all are possible.
- specialist 12y agoYou defend legalized bribery under the guise of free speech and privacy. Nice. This is governance, not commerce. Big difference. You realize the elected persons are representatives? Of the people? Right? Democracy is impractical without accountability and transparency. So might makes right?
- smsm42 12y agoIn my dictionary, bribery is: The offering, giving, receiving, or soliciting of something of value for the purpose of influencing the action of an official in the discharge of his or her public or legal duties. How somebody using his own money to speak in support or opposition of a political candidate is "bribery" is a mystery to me. Do you have some other definition of bribery? >>> You realize the elected persons are representatives? Of the people? Right? Democracy is impractical without accountability and transparency. That's correct, but we're not talking about spending public money, in which spending accountability and transparency is crucial. We're talking about spending private money - in which case the accountability should be only to the people who own the money. You do not owe me any account of how you spend your own money, and I do not owe any to you. >>> So might makes right? Without privacy, yes, that would be the case - whoever possesses control of the government enforcement machine, would be able to suppress and intimidate anybody who dares to support their opponents.