4 ms·
This would basically be a packet-inspecting firewall for USB instead of IP. I agree that this would pose a number of technical challanges as a lot of the tools
by xg15 12y ago
This would basically be a packet-inspecting firewall for USB instead of IP. I agree that this would pose a number of technical challanges as a lot of the tools and optimizations we have in IP stacks don't exist for USB, but I don't see how that would be principally impossible.
In fact, as there is a lot more standardization in USB profiles than in IP protocols, it might even be easier. I.e. if you just inspected messages of the mass storage profile and blocked everything else, you might already get pretty far. I agree that the performance problem would stay though.
- almost 12y agoI don't think you could make a IP firewall that enforced read-only either, at least not in a general case.
- btgeekboy 12y agoYou'd have to have knowledge of what protocol was being spoken. Otherwise, you don't know of if a packet going back the "wrong" direction is a control mechanism (request for data, flow control, etc) or data itself. In terms of ethernet, you could possibly do UDP, but you lose any sort of error handling or flow control.