4 ms·
I've had mixed thoughts about this over the years. Sadly you only get to raise your kids once, you can't try other scenarios and see of there is a better path.
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I've had mixed thoughts about this over the years. Sadly you only get to raise your kids once, you can't try other scenarios and see of there is a better path.
Highly verbal kids, and that is generally kids who read a lot, will be told they are smart whether you do it or not. And if you're child's teachers are telling you how smart they are, and they ask you "Dad, my teacher said I'm really smart, do you think I'm really smart?" You'll have to decide what the narrative is.
That said, it's great to reward struggle rather than success and to emphasize that it is through failure that we value succeeding. Everyone I know who shielded their children from failure has struggled later with teaching them how to cope with failure. That isn't scientific of course, just parents swapping horror stories, but it has been highly correlated in my experience. Putting those struggles into the proper light is very important.
A less obvious but also challenging aspect of this though is that you must teach your children that natural skillsets don't determine their worth. You are good at maths but lousy at sports? Makes you no better or worse than someone with the opposite levels of skill. That is much harder as kids are always looking for ways to evaluate themselves relative to their peers. If you endorse that you can find yourself inculcating in them an unhealthy externally generated view of self worth.
- j2kun 12y agoSince there isn't a real definition of what "smart" means and what "intelligence" is, we could also redefine the words to mean what the author is espousing. It would be an interesting thought experiment: if you give your child a non-standard definition, would there be any impact or dissonance in their interactions with the world? I've thought about this with colors (what if my whole life I've thought "green" is something different than what everyone else thinks of as green?), but this seems like it could actually have some benefits if one tried it.
- dfabulich 12y ago> "do you think I'm really smart?" Before the age of understanding: "In our house, instead of saying, 'you're really smart,' we say, 'you practiced a lot.'" After the age of understanding: "We try not to say 'you're smart.' Let me show you why." Then you do a web search for [praise hard work not intelligence]; the first link is Mueller and Dweck's meta study, which has a very accessible abstract. BTW, the rule is reversed when it comes to moral traits. "You're so honest" works better than "you behaved honestly," and specifically "don't be a cheater" works better than "don't cheat." http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/12/opinion/sunday/raising-a-moral-child.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/12/opinion/sunday/raising-a-m...
- CMCDragonkai 12y agoWe are what we do right?
- ivanca 12y agoNo, it just works better as a reinforcement saying it that way. You want them to keep an attitude by making it a part of who they are (e.g. _you are_ honest), but with intelligence is different, you always want them to become smarter than they already are.
- CMCDragonkai 12y agoI'm sure there are degrees of honesty as there are degrees in intelligence.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoClose. We will have been what we will have done. But that is slightly different. We are not passive components. Intent and frame of mind matters because it impacts future actions.
- mkempe 12y agoHere is what Aristotle had to say on virtue: "the virtue of a man [is] the state of character which makes a man good and which makes him do his own work well." [1] Hence we should praise the state of character, not just the ability to reach and maintain that state. [1] Nicomachean Ethics, book 2, chapter 6 (http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/nicomachaen.2.ii.html http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/nicomachaen.2.ii.html)
- kaoD 12y ago> Before the age of understanding: "In our house, instead of saying, 'you're really smart,' we say, 'you practiced a lot.'" Why not "you are smart because you practiced a lot"? Wouldn't that encourage practicing? I would follow with how you aren't just smart, but smart in some areas, and the more you practice in those (and other areas) the more smart you'll become.
- blazespin 12y agoMaybe you should try reading the article rather than the title.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt is perfectly ok to respond to the contents of the article, the title in case it prompts a relevant thought or both. If someone comments on the article title then it is not ok to automatically assume they did not read the article. Chucks' comments are one of the reasons I still come here, if you're going to drive him out with stupid attacks like this then the site will be a lot worse than it is today. Have some patience and lighten up.
- bostonvaulter2 12y ago> And if you're child's teachers are telling you how smart they are, and they ask you "Dad, my teacher said I'm really smart, do you think I'm really smart?" You'll have to decide what the narrative is. Couldn't you just say something like: "Yes I think you're really smart, but it is much more important that you are hard-working".
- steven2012 12y agoChuck I don't know you, but I always look forward to your posts whenever I read the comments on a HN post. This was another excellently written one, and timely for me because I will be going through these scenarios very soon. Thank you.
- clamprecht 12y ago> Sadly you only get to raise your kids once, You're not A/B testing?
- SiVal 12y agoI learned of Dweck's findings before I had kids, and I faced that challenge, too: Others tell my kids that they're smart, but they want reassurance that Daddy thinks they are, too. When they were younger, I told them that they were obviously smart enough to be successful, but beyond that it was hard to tell just how smart, because the harder they worked on something, the smarter they looked, to me and everyone else. As they've gotten older, though, I've shared Dweck's research with them and told them that the details were a little more subtle than just growth mindset vs fixed mindset. Instead, I've told them that cognitive skills were like athletic skills: some things do come more easily to some people--different things to different people. You might not learn a certain thing as easily as your friend does, but if you work harder, you'll still learn faster. The real success will come not from being born "smart" but from being born "smart enough" and then combining hard work with strategy. Find a few things that are hard for everybody but seem to come a little more easily to you than to most people, then work like crazy on those things, and you won't just look smart, you'll look like a genius.
- Ma8ee 12y ago> they ask you "Dad, my teacher said I'm really smart, do you think I'm really smart?" You'll have to decide what the narrative is. You tell them that the way they got that smart is by doing a lot of challenging things and working hard.