3 ms·
I strongly agree with part of this, and am reservedly skeptical about the rest. What I agree with is disputing "calories make us fat because thermodynamics".
by dllthomas 12y ago
I strongly agree with part of this, and am reservedly skeptical about the rest. What I agree with is disputing "calories make us fat because thermodynamics". Yes, of course the laws of physics still apply, and energy in minus energy out has to equal stored energy... but there are all kinds of ways energy is entering and leaving the system.
I do think that calories eaten and expended are an important part of the equation - having seen some people lose weight through simply restricting portion size - but I am unconvinced that it is (or is not) typically the most important piece. I am convinced that "... because thermodynamics" is a poor argument for it being the only thing that matters.
- scotty79 12y agoIf you eat less calories than you burn it is absolutely sure way to lose weight ... because thermodynamics. It might not be a good way for a lots of people because they just can't stand being hungry.
- dllthomas 12y agoThis is the kind of inanity I'm talking about. (Calories eaten, calories burned, calories stored in fat cells) is not a closed system, so thermodynamics doesn't have a lot to simplistically say about it. There's also chemical energy stored in other forms, there's calories excreted, there's thermal energy in and out. Yes, there is clearly an extreme at which thermodynamics will force fat to be burned, but thermodynamics alone does not tell us whether that is meaningful when the goal is promoting long-term health (of which losing weight is, for most people, a meaningful piece).
- scotty79 12y agoI get that calories leave body in various forms but they get inside just in one. And if you eat less calories than you loose then you are bound to loose weight. No matter what crap you eat. It might not be pleasent. It might not be healthy but I think that it's almost surely more healthy than gut surgery and by transitivity than staying obese.
- dllthomas 12y ago"I get that calories leave body in various forms but they get inside just in one." That's not strictly true, though it might be a good enough approximation. Calorie is a measure of energy. If you're heated, energy is entering the thermodynamic system. Of course, thermodynamics tells us that converting heat into chemical energy is harder than the other way 'round, so it's unlikely our body is doing a lot of that efficiently. "And if you eat less calories than you loose then you are bound to loose weight. No matter what crap you eat. It might not be pleasent. It might not be healthy but I think that it's almost surely more healthy than gut surgery and by transitivity than staying obese." You're bound to lose weight, but the following is perfectly consistent thermodynamically: "all your muscle wastes away before your fat, then you die, then you can't keep up burning more than you eat". I'm not saying this is the case! I'm saying we need things other than thermodynamics to get any reasonable conclusion here.
- scotty79 12y agoAre you absolutely sure that there is a chemical process to convert extrnal heat into mass that is not neglible in comparison to how much mass is saved by the body when it does not have to heat itself at that temperature? Because for me it looks like mentioning air pressure when we are trying to solve the problem of how some colliding masses of lead will behave. Strictly speaking air pressure could influence outcome but you won't see that in result with the accurancy you can humanly achieve. As for your second point, we have a lot of experience with people starving themselves, even to death. And we pretty much know that fat is one of the thing that goes first. You can also look at people after gut surgery. Nothing special changes for them. They just can no longer eat vastly more than they need. And they loose weight. I'm sure there are better more pleasant ways to loose weight and they will be eventually discovered, but there are sure relatively safe ways now.
- dllthomas 12y ago"Are you absolutely sure that there is a chemical process to convert extrnal heat into mass that is not neglible in comparison to how much mass is saved by the body when it does not have to heat itself at that temperature?" I'm not absolutely sure of much of anything, and that's my point. And I said it "might be a good enough approximation" to ignore it. "As for your second point, we have a lot of experience with people starving themselves, even to death. And we pretty much know that fat is one of the thing that goes first. You can also look at people after gut surgery. Nothing special changes for them. They just can no longer eat vastly more than they need. And they loose weight." And for the fifth fucking time I agree that there is evidence that eating fewer calories helps one lose weight - but to draw conclusions you need that evidence, not "simple thermodynamics", which is my entire point.