3 ms·
>>> You seem to think we're trying to stop people from anonymously posting their opinions. We are not. Of course not. You're trying to stop people from anonymo
by smsm42 12y ago
>>> You seem to think we're trying to stop people from anonymously posting their opinions. We are not.
Of course not. You're trying to stop people from anonymously supporting people that publicly post their opinion. That's not much better, in my eye, since in our day and age, you can not effect change alone.
>>> We are trying to stop people from spending millions of dollars on paid ads advocating the defeat of a candidate they don't like
This is an essence of politics - convincing people to adopt your point of view by explaining it to them. Including when your point of view is the candidate is bad. Imagine the worst guy you can think of - truly Hitler incarnate - is running for your city council. Would you want to be able to donate to his opponent's campaign? What if this bad guy is truly vindictive and sworn than anybody who donates to his opponent would regret that very soon? Would you want to be able to do it anonymously?
>>> Can you cite any examples of this happening?
I can cite a lot of instances where people were attacked and suffered for their speech expressed in donations, Brandon Eich being easily the most recent and prominent. However I'm pretty sure once privacy is gone, attacking the supporters would be as prominent, simply because it would be an effective tactics and there's absolutely nothing preventing its use.
- jim-greer 12y ago> However I'm pretty sure once privacy is gone, attacking the supporters would be as prominent Our country doesn't have a tradition of unlimited anonymous election spending. That only started happening with Citizens United in 2010. So we're not about to unleash some new torrent of attacks on previously anonymous donors. You value privacy over transparency. I do in some areas, but not in political spending. Seems like we'll have to agree to disagree.
- nickff 12y ago>"Our country doesn't have a tradition of unlimited anonymous election spending. That only started happening with Citizens United in 2010. So we're not about to unleash some new torrent of attacks on previously anonymous donors." To be clear, Citizens United was engaged in either campaign spending, candidate advocacy, or issue advocacy, depending on how you look at their actions; it is difficult to describe what they did as 'election spending' because the money was not going towards an election. This is a meaningful distinction, and not merely semantic for a number of reasons, of which I am sure we are all aware. There is a history of anonymous political speech in the USA, beginning with the federalist and anti-federalist papers. If one agrees that media corporations should be allowed to spend on anonymous campaign speech, then it follows that everyone else should have the same right. It is illogical to limit anonymous speech to broadcasters, publishers, as well as their friends and allies.
- smsm42 12y ago>>> Our country doesn't have a tradition of unlimited anonymous election spending. I'm pretty sure it does - people always donated to causes, and before the current "money in politics" panic campaign, they were anonymous for the most part. All the statutes requiring donor disclosure that I could find were pretty new. Could you bring an example of donor disclosure requirements that would qualify as "tradition"? >>> That only started happening with Citizens United in 2010 Citizens United decision changed very little on establishing privacy or disclosure. The decision was that the government can not ban a group of people, organized as a company, labor union or any other association. It actually upheld the disclosure requirements of BRCA. Of course, since the group has no obligation to disclose its membership or revenue sources, it can be used as a vehicle for anonymous speech. But that venue always existed, it was just that BRCA unconstitutionally banned companies from political speech. <i>You value privacy over transparency. I do in some areas, but not in political spending.</i> It's not the question of my values. I won't be the one who would abuse disclosure requirements. It's not the question of my preferences, it's a question of consequences which would happen regardless of what you and I prefer. Ignoring this consequences because they don't align with your values won't make them go away, they still will happen. Powerful people would still abuse disclosure requirements to suppress their opponents and ruin their supporter base, regardless of what you think about it. It's like Myspace saying "we value user experience, so we won't implement restrictive XSS filters". Then a guy named Samy comes and writes some JS code and pretty soon he owns their user experience lock, stock and barrel. Did their values help them prevent it? Not really. Now, in this case the effect is a bunch of wrong bits on the internet and a couple of mildly bruised egos. But with political campaign abuse the result would be bad laws passed, bad people elected and lives of people ruined when they opposed some bad candidate.
- jim-greer 12y ago> All the statutes requiring donor disclosure that I could find were pretty new They date back to Watergate. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_reform_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_reform_in_the_... Since then, monied interests have found various ways around them, like soft money (fixed by McCain-Feingold), and now 501c4s. The SCOTUS majority in Citizens United actually assumed that there would be full disclosure of the outside spending, since super PACs have to file with the FEC. That's been evaded by having 501c4s and other anonymous organizations listed as the donor.