3 ms·
For most people in Western countries, most of the time, the market more or less succeeds in ensuring that food's available at a reasonable price (generally with
by makomk 12y ago
For most people in Western countries, most of the time, the market more or less succeeds in ensuring that food's available at a reasonable price (generally with quite a bit of help from the government). If there's not enough food being grown or retailers are charging too much, new farmers and new retailers eventually drive the price down through competition. This works because demand for food is predictable, fungible, and relatively constant.
Now imagine a natural disaster is expected and suddenly everyone needs to stock up on water and food. Retailers can basically inflate prices to whatever they like and people will pay, because they desperately need that water and food and it's not like a new retailer is going to set up shop and dramatically undercut them before the disaster hits. There are certain business practices that cannot be solved by the market, and price gouging during disasters is one of them.
- viscanti 12y agoYou need food and water to survive. Transportation is probably not in that same category.
- pdonis 12y ago> the market more or less succeeds in ensuring that food's available at a reasonable price (generally with quite a bit of help from the government) The government doesn't help; it hinders, by subsidies, protective tariffs, and other distortions of the market. These policies help certain politically connected groups (mainly large agribusinesses), but they hurt consumers overall. > imagine a natural disaster is expected and suddenly everyone needs to stock up on water and food How long will the natural disaster last? How much can people economize on food and water during that time by simply eating less? How much can people economize by eating cheaper foods that provide nutrition but might not taste as good as what they normally eat? And so on. Retailers can't inflate prices as much as they want because sane people will be asking themselves all the above questions, and will simply refuse to buy food and water at a price point that isn't worth it to them, all things considered. People need food, but the need is not infinite.
- cpwright 12y ago> The government doesn't help; it hinders, by subsidies, protective tariffs, and other distortions of the market. These policies help certain politically connected groups (mainly large agribusinesses), but they hurt consumers overall. This is so true. In the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy there were plenty of gasoline shortages around NY; but the price did not significantly go up. If the stations were able to charge $9 or $10 a gallon, and the government didn't interfere, you can bet that companies/drivers would have been more than willing to import gasoline from other states. Why sell it in Ohio for $4, when you can sell it in NY for $10. Within a day or two, rather than the close to a week it took for normalcy to be restored; there would have been plentiful gasoline if you wanted it enough to pay. Instead we had stupidity like even and odd days in some counties, and long lines when a station happened to have gas.