4 ms·
Your first sentence is inherently contradictory and betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the concept of value (or possibly, a misunderstanding of the conce
by dnautics 12y ago
Your first sentence is inherently contradictory and betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the concept of value (or possibly, a misunderstanding of the concept of infinite).
- pessimizer 12y agoOr you're not getting that he's saying that there's a discontinuity in the utility function.
- dnautics 12y agothere's no such thing as continuous utility, all value judgements are a weighted discrete graphs of relative preferences.
- pessimizer 12y agoAnd this one goes to infinity at zero. When comparing the utility of a can of tuna to a castle made out of diamonds and staffed by trained unicorns, for a starving person the utility of the can of tuna is higher.
- dnautics 12y agoClearly you are afflicted by not understanding the concept of 'infinity'.
- pessimizer 12y agoClearly you don't understand talking about infinity with approximations. Should I have added a liquid sapphire swimming pool attended by angels?
- dnautics 12y agoOK. The disconnect here is that I think there are things more valuable than my life, and you are selfish, and think there is nothing more valuable than yours.
- superuser2 12y agoYou are going to die of thirst in the next few hours. There is one merchant selling bottled water. There is no price at which you say, "fuck that, I'll live without it." You won't. You'll die. So you pay whatever they're asking, up to and including everything you have. If you had more, you would pay more. That's what I mean by infinite value.
- dnautics 12y agoActually, there are prices, where I will say "fuck that, i'll live without it". Easy example (but I would probably hold out for less): Would you trade torturing person X for water? (assuming assurances that they would be otherwise unharmed if I died of thirst)
- pdonis 12y agoOr you'll try to bargain with the merchant, explaining that you're dying of thirst. Or you'll try to take the water by force, since the merchant is obviously being unreasonable. Or... In other words, your scenario does not just assume that you are dying of thirst. It also assumes that the merchant is evil, so evil that he will take everything you own in exchange for a single bottle of water when you are dying of thirst. Most humans are not like that. Why should you just happen to run across one that is at the precise moment when you are dying of thirst and he is the only merchant around? That's way too improbable to worry about.
- superuser2 12y ago> Or you'll try to bargain with the merchant, explaining that you're dying of thirst In which case, he'll move on and sell it to the next guy. > Or you'll try to take the water by force, since the merchant is obviously being unreasonable. Okay, maybe, if you aren't outmatched. > It also assumes that the merchant is evil, so evil that he will take everything you own in exchange for a single bottle of water when you are dying of thirst This sort of proves my point. People understand that this kind of behavior is wrong, so they don't do it. I was replying to someone saying it's puzzling that people consider this behavior wrong.