7 ms·
Anonymous speech means the speakers compete on message. Banning anonymous speech means if you lose on message, and you have power, you can attack your opponent
by smsm42 12y ago
Anonymous speech means the speakers compete on message. Banning anonymous speech means if you lose on message, and you have power, you can attack your opponent on other aspects - threaten their livelihood by attacking their employer, harass their relatives, alienate their friends and peers, in short - make their life a living hell without even bothering to actually address their message. This is especially an option when an independent citizen tries to take on a corrupt and well-entrenched opponent, possessing the use of a vast governmental machine. Of course, you can not run in elections anonymously - but you can support a courageous individual who does, without fear of retaliation for the entrenched power, if your privacy is respected. If it is not, it is very easy to cut down an upstart candidate by an entrenched incumbent by just attacking their supporters and intimidating them before the challenger even becomes a threat.
Now, tell me please, how that would be a good thing?
US has a long standing tradition of anonymous political speech, starting with the Federalist Papers. The consequences of getting rid of this tradition may be much worse than the rosy picture the proponents paint.
- pessimizer 12y agoAnonymous funding isn't the same as anonymous speech (although SCOTUS disagrees with me.) Everyone has the same number of voices, but a vastly different number of dollars. If one party spends $100M on their message, and the other just says it loudly at city council meetings, to his/her friends, passes out $100 worth of fliers, writes letters to the editors of every major newspaper, and puts up a webpage they designed themselves - there's no competition on message here. It's a slaughter on resources. >Banning anonymous speech means if you lose on message, and you have power, you can attack your opponent on other aspects Money is far more akin to power than speech. Money is generally a proxy for power.
- smsm42 12y agoIt is essentially the same. Money is needed to effect the speech, especially in the era of professional marketing and electronic media. Of course, you can just stand on top of a soapbox and shout, but how effective would that be? To deliver your speech to the masses, you need money and usually a professional help. I bet the guy jumping from the plane and filming it wasn't working for free in that ad, right? And the plane didn't fly without fuel and pilot, which needed to be paid for, too? This is all necessary components of effective political speech, and by restricting it, you are restricting speech and reducing it to a whisper to be heard only by ones in your immediate vicinity. >>> If one party spends $100M on their message, and the other just says it loudly at city council meetings In fact, nothing like this happens. Usually, for any idea worth talking about, there is a lot of money on both sides, because a lot of people in the US have money and would gladly spend it to support the cause they consider right. Much less would be willing to do so if they would face harassment, retaliation and possibly ruin of their life's work for it. I do not think this should be a consequence of you supporting your favorite cause. Do you? If your worst and most corrupt opponents would control the state enforcement machine, would you prefer to be able to work anonymously to dislodge them or not be able to do this without risking your whole life be ruined immediately? >>> Money is generally a proxy for power. This is true. But you can not (usually) exercise the power directly against the message - the First Amendment guards against that quite successfully. With privacy destroyed, you can, however, successfully use the power against the messenger or people that allow them to deliver this message - thus effectively killing the message without running afoul of the letter of the First Amendment, but entirely destroying its purpose.
- pessimizer 12y ago>It is essentially the same. To say the least, this is disputed by intelligent and well-respected people on both sides, and neither sides' arguments can be dismissed with a wave. >Usually, for any idea worth talking about, there is a lot of money on both side This is the law of averages, and is not a law. If your philosophy depends on it being true, then it will fail.
- smsm42 12y agoI'm not dismissing it, I'm explaining, quite verbosely, why it is wrong. >>> This is the law of averages, and is not a law. Look at the data for any hot issue, from presidential election to gay marriage to gun control. >>> If your philosophy depends on it being true, then it will fail. It's not philosophy, it's what actually happens. If the reverse would happen, we would have to consider why there's no people having money that support certain point, and if this is a problem. But for any real point under discussion right now, it is not the case, so if you want to say it would be the case, you need to account for the fact it didn't happen and explain why it would be different in your case.
- pessimizer 12y ago> I'm not dismissing it, I'm explaining, quite verbosely, why it is wrong. Not clearly enough for me to understand. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_averages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_averages
- smsm42 12y agoI'm not sure how law of averages fits here. I'm not saying donations will even out because it is random event that must regress to its mean within a short time. I'm saying donations already are pretty even for most hot topics, and that's not because of some probabilistic law, but because hot issues are hot because there are a lot of people interested in them, and a lot of them disagree (if they didn't, it would simply be a matter of consensus and there would be no need to spend money on convincing people). It has nothing to do with probability and everything to do with human behavior.
- Strang 12y agoI definitely do not have as much of a voice as, say, Arthur Sulzberger, publisher of the New York Times. And I never will. My most realistic option for making my voice heard would be to contribute money to a person, campaign, corporation, whatever, that accepts money from other like-minded people and uses that money to advance our shared position. However, I would be quite hesitant to do that if I couldn't do it anonymously. Aside from the chilling effects of the Brandon Eich debacle, there is also the practical consideration that volunteering contact information in this day and age is an invitation to incessant harassment from entities that operate under loopholes in do-no-call legislation. I believe my voice is diminished by any political funding legislation that disallows anonymous donation.
- ianstallings 12y agoYou equate free speech with "fair". If I have a bullhorn and you don't, does that make my speech any less protected than yours, simply because you don't have a bullhorn?
- HarryHirsch 12y agoI think there are good reasons against protection of bullhorns.
- Afforess 12y agoMoney is not free speech, regardless of what the Supreme Court says.
- smsm42 12y agoYes, it is. See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8213792 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8213792
- specialist 12y agoSelf cite. Nice. Very authoritative. >> If one party spends $100M on their message, and the >> other just says it loudly at city council meetings > > In fact, nothing like this happens. That is precisely what happens. You should lobby. Or at least watch your local equivalent to C-SPAN. See how the game is played before you comment.
- smsm42 12y agoIt was not supposed to make it "authoritative". It was supposed to keep the discussion in one branch. Of course, it failed, because following links is too hard. >>> That is precisely what happens. Supported by what data? Here's mine: http://www.cnbc.com/id/49550998/ http://www.cnbc.com/id/49550998/ Care to show yours? >>> You should lobby No thanks, I prefer to make my living in different ways. >>> Or at least watch your local equivalent to C-SPAN Which would show me the financial patterns how exactly? >>> See how the game is played before you comment Thank you for your concern about my education, however offbase it is. I am well aware how the game is played. That's exactly why I see the variety of vulnerabilities ripe for exploitation and dangers that destroying privacy in political speech would produce.
- specialist 12y agoData? Non-sequiturs are not data. Sorry, but I can't even figure out what point you're arguing. Have a nice day.
- infinotize 12y agoMoney can be used to drown out competing messages. This can take many forms, such as overwhelming media appearance in political campaigns/attack ads, large companies using litigation against smaller entities that can't afford to fight regardless of their message, to "laundering" money through super PACs or funding think tanks and research groups whose sole purpose is to publish findings to the funding entities' benefit. I also think it's hazardous to assume valid messages would always have competative supporting dollar figures. What people want and what businesses want are often very different things, and from a wealth standpoint you need many times more people in a lower income bracket to equal the "message" of a 1%er. It can be difficult if not impossible to figure out the sources of funding in a lot of these cases. Particularly in elections, that run on money, and presumably whose candidates are paying a lot of attention to the needs of their doners (perhaps more then their voters), the source of this money matters. I think this is a great idea aimed at increasing the transparancy in the shady world of campaigning.
- smsm42 12y ago>>> Money can be used to drown out competing messages "Drown out" is just another way of saying "speech". Unless drowning down is done by non-speech ways - like getting the speaker beaten up or jailed or sued into bankruptcy. >>> large companies using litigation against smaller entities that can't afford to fight regardless of their message And removal of privacy would fix that how exactly? >>> groups whose sole purpose is to publish findings to the funding entities' benefit. If those entities do that, they are PR companies. It is a completely legal business, nothing wrong with that. >>> It can be difficult if not impossible to figure out the sources of funding in a lot of these cases. Which would lead to more and more restrictive policies, and more and more instances of abuse, where incumbents, unable to compete on message, would instigate "campaign finance" investigation against challengers and destroy their campaign, only for the investigation to peter out immediately after electoral threat is gone. More power you put into this system, the more abuse it would generate. >>> increasing the transparancy in the shady world of campaigning. There's nothing shady in anonymous speech. You do not have the right to violate other's privacy, and somebody's refusal to disclose their private matters does not make them "shady". "Honest man has nothing to hide" is a lie.
- smsm42 12y agoAs a side note, this is why we have bad security. Most software developers and entrepreneurs always think of the best case scenario - how good could it be if it all works out. Rarely people think about what happens if it all works out, gets huge and then people with huge motivation, lots of money and no scruples whatsoever come and try to exploit your idea for their own benefit. If you don't consider the worst case, you don't understand the real consequences of your proposal. And then we have something like email that is abused by spammers, or XSS problems because we did not design a way to separate code from data, and we have to backpatch it and invent ways to fix the breakage because nobody considered the worst case when designing it in the first place.
- jim-greer 12y agoYou seem to think we're trying to stop people from anonymously posting their opinions. We are not. We are trying to stop people from spending millions of dollars on paid ads advocating the defeat of a candidate they don't like (over 90% of independent expenditures go to negative ads). That's a little different than the federalist papers, I think. If someone has a powerful message, they can make a YouTube video and it will spread. If someone has a message that requires millions of dollars to be powerful, then it's not unreasonable to know who is spending those millions. > it is very easy to cut down an upstart candidate by an entrenched incumbent by just attacking their supporters and intimidating them before the challenger even becomes a threat Can you cite any examples of this happening? Typically the attack is on the upstart candidate, not their supporters.
- 001sky 12y agoTypically the attack is on the upstart candidate, not their supporters. This is silly at best and naive most likely. The NY Times goes after "supporters" all the time, of views they don't agree with. The examples are too obvious to cite.
- ianstallings 12y agoSomeone's anonymous speech is being unmasked. I agree with the OP. Being rich doesn't exclude them from the freedom to speak without fear. An advertisement is part of that speech IMHO.
- smsm42 12y ago>>> You seem to think we're trying to stop people from anonymously posting their opinions. We are not. Of course not. You're trying to stop people from anonymously supporting people that publicly post their opinion. That's not much better, in my eye, since in our day and age, you can not effect change alone. >>> We are trying to stop people from spending millions of dollars on paid ads advocating the defeat of a candidate they don't like This is an essence of politics - convincing people to adopt your point of view by explaining it to them. Including when your point of view is the candidate is bad. Imagine the worst guy you can think of - truly Hitler incarnate - is running for your city council. Would you want to be able to donate to his opponent's campaign? What if this bad guy is truly vindictive and sworn than anybody who donates to his opponent would regret that very soon? Would you want to be able to do it anonymously? >>> Can you cite any examples of this happening? I can cite a lot of instances where people were attacked and suffered for their speech expressed in donations, Brandon Eich being easily the most recent and prominent. However I'm pretty sure once privacy is gone, attacking the supporters would be as prominent, simply because it would be an effective tactics and there's absolutely nothing preventing its use.