5 ms·
This is the problem as I see it from TFA: >> More than a dozen theories have now been proposed for the so-called global warming hiatus, ranging from air pollu
by phkahler 12y ago
This is the problem as I see it from TFA:
>> More than a dozen theories have now been proposed for the so-called global warming hiatus, ranging from air pollution to volcanoes to sunspots.
>> “Every week there’s a new explanation of the hiatus,” said corresponding author Ka-Kit Tung
First of all, a hypothesis is NOT a theory. Secondly, they have a goal indicative of an agenda - they're looking for a plausible explanation and publishing speculation as "theory". If you don't have data you're just speculating, and by data I don't mean "yeah, volcanoes erupt and emit stuff". You need data that supports your hypothesis, and if you really want to claim a theory, IMHO you need some kind of mathematical model. If all these weekly explanations had data and models to back them, I don't think there would be nearly so many.
To me this resembles the folks who blame every weather event on climate change. Even if I accept the premise, they look like fools trying to tie warm, cold, erratic, extreme, and calm, all to the the same cause with nothing but simple high level hand waving.
Never mind my views on certain topics, doesn't all that speculation out in the public view damage the perception of science as a whole? That bothers me.
- aethertap 12y agoI agree with your points here. The thing that struck me as more interesting about this case is that it seems like it should lead to a more concrete testable prediction, with a deadline. If this is right, we should see a rapid increase in temperatures when the cycle that's currently pumping heat to the bottom of the ocean starts to pump it back up to the top. If it's as they say, then it seems to me like the next oscillation should be much more dramatic (for some measurable definition of dramatic) than the historic ones because most of that "stored warming" will come up in a rush. On the other hand, if we get to the time when the cycle reverses and it's no big deal (after giving it time to get into full swing), perhaps we should reconsider our premises.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThis also makes it much more of an interesting bet as in survival terms it has actual teeth, especially since the cooling period hasn't really cooled but has stayed pretty flat instead. I suggest at least hedging that it might in fact rise, given the loss if it does. Nothing wrong with making some hedge funds after all, honest foundation of the economy and all that. Besides, other than saying that the climate is just too complex to make these predictions, I haven't ever heard a plausible argument against extending the simple observation that a volume of air enclosing an absorbing and emitting solid when exposed to a wideband source of light (the sun being a good example) will trap heat in different amounts dependent on the concentration of the gases in the volume and that CO2 is one of the gases that increases this effect if you start with a mix the same as our atmosphere.
- gd1 12y agoYes, that's all true. But I've also never heard a plausible argument against the simple observation that if I kick a football it will accelerate away from me. F=ma and all that... Unless I'm standing at the bottom of a hill, in which case it will roll straight back to my feet. See, the wider system may be more complex, and have negative feedbacks that overwhelm any perturbation you introduce. The onus is on the climate scientists to show that the system as a whole will behave as they've predicted, which is a great deal trickier than your simple observation... since it's just about the most complex system imaginable. I model for a living, and I'd dead-set rather model the human brain than the climate of our entire planet. At least you've got 6 billion of those to gather data on. Or experiment on. They've got one.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIf you kick a football it will accelerate away from you, but only while you are kicking it and it does that in both cases. And if you have got as far as F=ma then you will presumably be bright enough to apply it to gravity and the shape and material of any hill as well as the action of your foot. Besides, the people who are saying that the system is too complex to make a prediction are not saying that there will be no effect. There is an increase in the energy going into this system and saying that things are so complex that we should bet on there being no effect is not saying that there is no global effect, but that there is a global effect that more or less exactly counterbalances the initial effect and that to me sounds like wishful thinking from the viewpoint that nature is somehow magically in balance.
- tbrownaw 12y agoI haven't ever heard a plausible argument against extending the simple observation that a volume of air enclosing an absorbing and emitting solid when exposed to a wideband source of light (the sun being a good example) will trap heat in different amounts dependent on the concentration of the gases in the volume and that CO2 is one of the gases that increases this effect if you start with a mix the same as our atmosphere. Things that come to mind immediately: 1. The solid can change colors (amount of vegetation, amount of snow/ice cover). 2. Cloud cover at various altitudes. (I think I heard this one tends to annoy the model-makers, since they don't have a good way to predict it yet.) 3. How much of the wavelengths that CO2 absorbs, is already at 100%? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absorption_band https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absorption_band has a picture that seems to imply "most of it". Item #1 I've heard should make the effect stronger than your simple model, #3 would probably make it weaker, and #2 I doubt anyone knows.
- thanatropism 12y ago"Hypothesis" and "theory" are scientific jargon for different degrees of confidence and integration into extant theoretical frameworks. But hey, Bayes, Popper, Lakatos. I mean, get off it. "Theory" means something in "critical theory", something else in formal logic, etc. etc. There's nothing to say that applied scientist's uneasiness with tentative conclusions should dictate natural language. You don't want to be misinterpreted, you don't leak to the press before it's been in a few peer-reviewed journals.
- Clanan 12y agoDoesn't this tie into the idea of falsifiability? All these "theories" cannot really be disproven, only re-modeled. They're so focused on tying everything to human-caused climate change that they're leaving behind scientific rigor. As you said, bring on the accurate models and data!
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI guessed I missed that part. How does modeling oceanic current become partisan? Which measurements are falsified if any?
- bprieto 12y agoMeasures are not falsified. Hypothesis are (or should be). When you have a hypothesis, or a theory, that can't be deemed false by new data or new experiments, you don't have science. And this is the problem with those "a posteriori" explanations of the hiatus. They are saying that the models that predict a global warming catastrophe can't be wrong, instead of recognizing that the models lack predictive power and they must be adjusted. But if the models can't be wrong they are not science.
- anon1385 12y ago>They are saying that the models that predict a global warming catastrophe can't be wrong Who said that? The incompleteness of climate models isn't something that has just come up recently - they have always been incomplete (they can't be anything but - 'all models are wrong') and that is well understood by anybody who develops or uses them. There are large sub-systems that global circulation models don't even really attempt to model at this stage. Others where they are widely recognised to do a very bad job (e.g. ice sheets). Others that are just modelled stochastically because we don't know how to predict those processes on a year to year basis (e.g. ENSO). Finding inconsistencies between the models and reality is one of the ways that they are improved. I don't know where you are getting these ideas about how climate modellers think, but they don't bare any relation to how climate models are actually developed.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI guess the drastic reshaping of our planet has some people worried. Maybe its unscientific to blame it on human activity. But that at least has the possibility that we can fix what's clearly, pervasively broken in our weather. How do you explain folks who pick at the science but ignore the melting of every ice pack on the planet in a few dozen years? What principle are they exhibiting, to ignore overwhelming data for the sake of scoring some points on a web blog?
- todd8 12y agoWhat overwhelming data? The arctic ice cover is nowhere near record lows [1] and the antarctic ice cover is very well above historical averages [2]. This could be because other factors affect ice cover, but in that case we shouldn't be using it as a proxy for global warming. I feel the science is complex and not yet understood and we shouldn't treat questions about climate science as having nefarious motives. Ironically, my comment here is the kind of science nit-picking that think JoeAltmaier is commenting on and I think he makes a good point. Something is bound to be happening to our climate and it would be remarkable if it wasn't at least affected to some degree by human activity. [1] http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/N_stddev_timeseries.png http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/N_std... [2] http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/S_stddev_timeseries.png http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/S_std...
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYeah. Siberia melted. All glaciers are in retreat. Antarctic ice shelf is irretrievable melting as fresh water infiltrates the borders and seeps underneath. Whatever we've done, there's no stopping it now - the oceans WILL rise and we'll have to deal with that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]