4 ms·
> The economics just don't work. Given that you don't know how much this will cost to operate, you can't possibly know that, right? At some point, i think i r
by twic 12y ago
> The economics just don't work.
Given that you don't know how much this will cost to operate, you can't possibly know that, right?
At some point, i think i read a claim that an airliner based on this technology would be able to supply Europe - Australasia trips for about the same price as a business class ticket on a conventional airliner on that route. Passengers currently buy a fair few of those tickets; some might choose to do the trip in two hours instead of twenty-four in exchange for a smaller seat and the loss of a couple of meals.
- idlewords 12y agoWe know how much the Concorde cost to operate: a zillion shittons (metric) [http://www.concordesst.com/retire/faq_r.html http://www.concordesst.com/retire/faq_r.html] . And that was with proven technology and all the sunk costs behind them. I think that makes a sensible floor for this project, unless you are willing to argue that researching and deploying this completely new technology would somehow cost less.
- jvm 12y agoIs there really a tremendous amount of demand on the Australia / Europe segment? If London/NYC wasn't viable for the Concorde (probably the most popular international airline segment), I can't imagine the demand being higher on routes to Sydney. If the fixed costs of a flight are high, it will likely be even more expensive than the Concorde on trans-Atlantic routes.
- kjjw 12y agoAs far as I remember, stopping Concorde had more to do with poor sales after the Air France crash rather than anything inherent in cost efficency.
- timthorn 12y agoConcorde reportedly made BA about £750M. I'm not sure whether that figure takes into account the development costs - but the reason that it was retired was due to Airbus withdrawing support. http://www.concordesst.com/retire/faq_r.html http://www.concordesst.com/retire/faq_r.html
- idlewords 12y agoThe CEO of Airbus said in the Financial Times that "The costs of operating Concorde, and in particular maintenance and support, have become such that operations are unrealistic for any operator." The reason BA booked a profit is because of massive de facto government subsidies for Concorde, for reasons of national prestige.
- maxcan 12y agoparasitic drag increases with the square of velocity. these engines wont change that.
- m_mueller 12y agoThey do. Because they can operate in much thinner air.
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoSpaceX is predicting $2000/kg to low earth orbit.[1] Reaction Engines are predicting an order of magnitude cheaper than current tech[2], so let's be charitable and say that this is $200/kg. (Although the Wikipedia article mentions $650/kg). Consider that a Skylon launch is for a non pressurised satellite and capable of lifting 15,000 kg, which supposedly could be for 30 passengers in a passenger module [3]. That would meant $100,000/passenger to anywhere on earth. Cheap if you want to go to orbit, less so for a trip to Japan maybe. [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy#Pricing_and_development_funding http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy#Pricing_and_deve... [2] http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/space_skylon.html http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/space_skylon.html [3] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft)#Specifications_.28Skylon_C2.29 http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft)#Specifica...
- m_mueller 12y agoWhy do you assume intercontinental flight will use the same configuration as the orbiter? First of all, the orbiter still needs lots of oxygen on board, even though they can save around half of it with their hybrid jet/rocket engine. Furthermore it needs heavy heatshields. Both things that are not needed (or to a much lesser extent) in an intercontinental craft. The saved weight for oxygen alone should allow you to go from 30 to 200 passengers, giving you another order of magnitude - and suddenly you're at first class ticket prices.
- idlewords 12y agoYou need some way to keep the passengers from being roasted alive, and you need to engineer it to commercial air safety standards (redundant systems, emergency exits, little sign that says 'no smoking'). By the end of the process you'll be pining for the days of having to just lug around a little oxygen.