2 ms·
If prediction markets were really the best way for a large, centralised entity to make decisions, you'd think at least a few successful corporations would have
by notahacker 12y ago
If prediction markets were really the best way for a large, centralised entity to make decisions, you'd think at least a few successful corporations would have implemented it into their corporate governance.
The irony of proposals to reform the whole stakeholders-periodically-approve-an-all-powerful-executive model, on the assumption that markets make for better decisions than individuals with great power and limited accountability, is that markets consistently don't penalise large, successful firms for being almost-invariably run by a bunch of powerful executives whose power is checked only by the occasional AGM.
- Zigurd 12y agoThere are many governance variants that should outperform conventional decision-making practice in corporations but go unadopted. Either we're living in a decision-making Golden Age, which seems unlikely, or corporate decision making is very ego-driven and resistant to systemic change.
- notahacker 12y agoCorporate decision making is very ego driven and resistant to systemic change[1]. From which we can conclude either that stock markets are not very good at promoting good governance (even with narrow, homogenous criteria like "grow shareholder value) or that concentrating power in the hand of ego-driven, change resistant groups of [mostly] old men is not as bad for shareholders as running a corporation based on prediction markets. I'd say both were true [1]though many corporations' shareholders would justifiably argue the latter part is a feature of the system rather than a bug
- baddox 12y ago> If prediction markets were really the best way for a large, centralised entity to make decisions, you'd think at least a few successful corporations would have implemented it into their corporate governance. Only if you think that every "best way" to do every thing has already been done, which I highly doubt.