36 ms·
Can you explain from first principles why "one vote per person" is a good way to efficiently produce law, given that most of us accept that it's not a good way
by baddox 12y ago
Can you explain from first principles why "one vote per person" is a good way to efficiently produce law, given that most of us accept that it's not a good way to produce many other things (like food and automobiles)?
If everyone got a single vote on what model of automobile should be produced, and only the winning model was produced, surely we all agree that the resulting automobile would be much worse than the average automobile produced by the market. In this scenario, it's obvious that there would be mass voter apathy: the amount of time it takes to research automobile designs and manufacturers isn't worth it, because your vote is extremely unlikely to effect the automobile you receive. But when each person has to pay for their own automobile, it's absolutely worth you time to research automobiles, because you get exactly the automobile you purchase.
- icushman 12y ago#1: People should have some form of influence on their own governance. #2: Any method of assigning relative degrees of influence is unacceptably vulnerable to a corruption by the advantaged party tantamount to a violation of #1. Side note: Efficiency of law production is not a metric most people will consent to prioritizing above metrics like perceived justice.
- baddox 12y agoWhat if, hypothetically, it were the case that switching from "one vote per person" to some new system would result in everyone being better off (by their own subjective notion of "better off," which can include things like how much justice they believe exists, how corrupt laws are, etc.)? Then wouldn't it make sense to argue in favor of this new system? My point is that even though there are widely accepted moral arguments for why "one vote per person" is the best way to organize society, it really boils down to an economic argument about what the actual results of such a society will be. I suspect few people would support "one vote per person" on moral grounds if they believed that another system would result in a society where everyone is better off. Likewise, I suspect few libertarians, socialists, anarchists, etc. would continue to make moral arguments if they truly believed that their proposed society would end up the way their opponents believe it would end up. > Side note: Efficiency of law production is not a metric most people will consent to prioritizing above metrics like perceived justice. Economically efficient law is pretty difficult to argue against. I suspect the vast majority of people will support it if they understand the definition of economic efficiency. From Wikipedia: "An economic system is said to be more efficient than another (in relative terms) if it can provide more goods and services for society without using more resources." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_efficiency
- dragonwriter 12y ago> > > Can you explain from first principles why "one vote per person" is a good way to efficiently produce law > > Side note: Efficiency of law production is not a metric most people will consent to prioritizing above metrics like perceived justice. > Economically efficient law is pretty difficult to argue against. "Efficiently producing law" and "producing economically efficient law" are rather dissimilar concepts, in the same way that "efficiently producing automobiles" and "producing fuel efficient automobiles" are dissimilar concepts.
- baddox 12y ago> "Efficiently producing law" and "producing economically efficient law" are rather dissimilar concepts Sorry, I didn't intend for you to infer that. I meant the same concept in both sentences. I am not talking about some more specific type of efficiency like fuel efficiency, which has nothing to do direct with the concept of economic efficiency.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Sorry, I didn't intend for you to infer that. I meant the same concept in both sentences. I am not talking about some more specific type of efficiency like fuel efficiency, which has nothing to do direct with the concept of economic efficiency. I think you misunderstand the problem; "Producing efficient X" and "Efficiently producing X" aren't the same thing. The first is about the efficiency of the process of producing something (how the inputs are used to produce the output), the other is about the qualities of the output. The problem isn't "economic efficiency" vs. "some more specific type of efficiency", its production efficiency (in whatever terms) vs. efficiency of the product (economic or otherwise.)
- baddox 12y ago> "Producing efficient X" and "Efficiently producing X" aren't the same thing. I understand your claim. I'm trying to avoid a semantic argument by making it clear what I meant. I'm not arguing about what the "true meaning" of those phrases are. Just know I was referring to economic efficiency both times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_efficiency
- idlewords 12y agoThe market is not some entity that exists outside of human society, it's a product of that society. And "one person one vote" is a foundational principle of how we organize ourselves as a society in the first place. Demanding that someone make economic or legal arguments for it is a category error. It's the bedrock that law and economic life stand upon.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baddox 12y agoI addressed that in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8209696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8209696 I don't think that "one vote per person" is so fundamental that many people would continue to advocate it if they truly believed that some other system would lead to a better life for everyone in the society.
- 21echoes 12y agosure, but i think the reason no one has stopped advocating for it is that very few people believe that "some other system would lead to a better life for everyone in the society", especially seeing as many people count "having a voice in the structure of my society" as one of the very things that makes life good for them.
- baddox 12y agoI agree. But that also means that it's not really a moral axiom, so the moral argument is insufficient.
- tunesmith 12y agoI think "one person one vote" is a first principle. It's a moral axiom that people then derive democratic practices from. It's not necessarily something you derive from other principles or facts. It's along the lines of "every life has equal value". People can disagree with those sorts of principles, but they're not logical derivations of universally accepted principles and facts.
- baddox 12y agoI addressed that in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8209696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8209696 Basically, I think that most people will not continue to make a moral argument if they are genuinely convinced that the results of that stance would be horrible for all (or most) people. If you believed that "one vote per person" would lead to a society where every is much poorer than they would be under some other system, I suspect you would not continue to claim it is a moral axiom.
- tunesmith 12y agoYes - particular moral axioms are by definition not accepted by everyone. That is the trick; convincing people to adjust/change their values (moral axioms) and then derive different beliefs/actions from them. The reason that is a tough sell in this case is because it very quickly can come across as declaring a class of people as superior to another class of people. "One person one vote" might lead to certain negative side effects, but the side effects of an alternative can be much worse.
- baddox 12y ago> That is the trick; convincing people to adjust/change their values (moral axioms) and then derive different beliefs/actions from them. What I'm saying is that if you can make compelling economic arguments for why a different system would be better, most people will not stick to their "moral axioms" if they buy the arguments. > "One person one vote" might lead to certain negative side effects, but the side effects of an alternative can be much worse. That's an economic claim, and is precisely what I challenge.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- harshreality 12y agoThe rationale against voting on cars or food doesn't apply to all things. There is no voting system for what cars or food to produce... for good reason. Not everyone wants to eat the same food or drive the same car, and within certain limits (which are the subject of laws), what you eat and what you drive is not anyone else's business. You need some sort of broad voting for public works projects and other issues of broad public concern, like how much pollution should be allowed into the environment from steady-state industrial processes, or how much tax money to spend regulating and engineering hedges against engineering disasters like Deepwater Horizon or Fukushima. One person one vote may not be the universal best way to produce law, but it's the best way society has figured out how to run things that doesn't degenerate into dictatorships, or unjustified discrimination/disenfranchisement. It's true that certain people are better at determining proper policy, but once they get exclusive voting rights on policy, it turns into an oligarchy, a cabal, that too often seeks to increase its own wealth and power and sustain itself rather than serving the public interest.
- baddox 12y ago> There is no voting system for what cars or food to produce. I was presenting the market for cars or food as essentially a "vote with your wallet" system. You don't literally vote, of course, but by choosing where to spend your money, you determine what product you end up, and also influence the producers. > However, you need some sort of broad voting for public works projects and issues of broad public concern, like ... That is an economic claim, and I would disagree. I think there are very plausible economic arguments that other ways of organizing society could solve these problems as well or better than the what we currently have.
- harshreality 12y agoDo you have an example of such an alternative way of organizing society? An example that has been tested in a large society? It's easy to propose theoretical alternatives with no regard for psychological or sociological effects (which are complex and therefore difficult to predict in theory). Changing culture, which is the means to change the psychological and sociological effects of different forms of governance (or different conditions, generally), is difficult. You can't legislate culture. Form of government A works in society B, therefore we can import A into the U.S. and get the benefits seen in society B even while Intel continues to turn out cpus and farmers in Iowa continue to grow corn? In order to achieve what you want, you need not only a better form of government, you need a way to hack culture to get it to tolerate that form of government without significant shocks to perceived quality of life (A shock to perceived happiness in that sense is, I think, more likely to disrupt your plans for better political order than to anchor them).
- deciplex 12y agoDemocracy need not be about declaring itself the most efficient way to pass the best laws. Even its strongest advocates would hesitate to fully endorse that. What democracy is, or at any rate what it's supposed to be, ideally, is a mechanism to act as a check on those in power. It's a way to formalize the power of mobs, and (hopefully) to channel it into something useful that doesn't involve burning down half the city when the ruling class goes too far. Namely, voting in a different government, which would still serve mainly the interests of the ruling class of course, but in an effort to keep its own power will make some concessions to the rest of us.