2 ms·
Whether or not you like that philosophy in general, and despite your father's tragedy, it is extremely appropriate for spinal surgery. Spinal surgery costs a l
by btilly 17y ago
Whether or not you like that philosophy in general, and despite your father's tragedy, it is extremely appropriate for spinal surgery. Spinal surgery costs a lot of money, frequently goes very badly, and even "successes" tend to be temporary and are followed in a few years by being worse off.
This is why in the mid-90s the Agency for Health Care Policy Research (AHCPR) looked at the subject and concluded that back surgery was inadvisable if any other options were available. Unfortunately for the AHCPR back surgeons are a fairly well off group, got the AMA on their side, and the result was that Congress nearly destroyed the AHCPR. The remnants have learned not to issue politically controversial opinions, no matter how well-founded in fact they may be. Thus a well-meaning attempt to actually evaluate expensive medical treatments for effectiveness ended.
Incidentally experts claim that the vast majority of the gains in life expectancy over the last 150 years have been due to improvements in public health, not medicine. Each of vaccination, sanitation and clean water supplies has done more to contribute to longevity than any medical advance you care to name, including antibiotics. Yet people are unaware of the contribution of public health. I find this odd.
- Retric 17y agoYou just swapped your argument from the majority of modern medicine to a specific case. Spinal surgery is also a moving target, the risk / reward line keeps shifting as better treatments shows up. Still in a wide range of cases it's a bad idea, for now.
- btilly 17y agoI just swapped whose argument? Look at the names of the posters in this thread... In any case the original article was about a woman who went through a nightmare to get a hospital to not perform unwanted, unneeded and dangerous spinal surgery. So to my eyes I was bringing the discussion back to the example under discussion. And pointing out that it has been well known for over a decade that spinal surgery is a generally bad idea to me underscores the horror of what happened to her.
- Retric 17y agoOps, sorry.