3 ms·

What, no React/Flux? How can this be a serious comparison without React?

by andrewvc 12y ago

quangv 12y ago
Yes, agreed ? I prefer it over Angular/Ember/Backbone
- cnp 12y ago
  Far superior, far simpler, but it's not exactly a framework :/
  - kaonashi 12y ago
    Which is exactly why you should choose it.
    - swah 12y ago
      How could I do something like http://ichord.github.com/At.js http://ichord.github.com/At.js in React?
      - kaonashi 12y ago
        React would handle the DOM; you would have to have some data model that handles the autocomplete list/cursor position and then feeds the results back into the react component.
    - cnp 12y ago
      Exactly :)
capkutay 12y ago
Flux might still be in the early adopter phase. Version 0.11 might be nice for side projects, but I'd feel uncomfortable trying to deploy a commercial app using a project that has been available to the public for less than 6 months.
megaman821 12y ago
React + what? Is there a standard router/controller and model that get's used with React? I think they just could have added the line "As an alternative to using underscore templates in Backbone, you can use React instead."
- nacs 12y ago
  There are a couple React-only routers but a lot of React.js people (including myself) use Backbone for the router/controller.
  - andrewvc 12y ago
    I'm actually using 'director' which works great, much simpler.
- andrewvc 12y ago
  Well, react/flux completely replaces backbone except for the router. The models go away completely, as do the views.
- compedit 12y ago
  There's no standards, but at this point I'd say Flux + React-router are quickly becoming it. react-router is made in the spirit of Ember's which is pretty well liked. - Flux Architecture Pattern [0] - React Router [1] Note that there isn't really a prescribed model in Angular aside from $scope either. [0] - http://facebook.github.io/flux/ http://facebook.github.io/flux/ [1] - https://github.com/rackt/react-router https://github.com/rackt/react-router
  - megaman821 12y ago
    I like react-router that looks quite nice. Flux looks like a description of an idea rather a JavaScript library. Is there a flux store that persists to a REST backend? A model really isn't part of Angular core since it was split out but something like angular-resource is what I am talking about.

What, no React/Flux? How can this be a serious comparison without React?

quangv 12y ago

Yes, agreed ? I prefer it over Angular/Ember/Backbone

cnp 12y ago
Far superior, far simpler, but it's not exactly a framework :/
- kaonashi 12y ago
  Which is exactly why you should choose it.
  - swah 12y ago
    How could I do something like http://ichord.github.com/At.js http://ichord.github.com/At.js in React?
    - kaonashi 12y ago
      React would handle the DOM; you would have to have some data model that handles the autocomplete list/cursor position and then feeds the results back into the react component.
  - cnp 12y ago
    Exactly :)

capkutay 12y ago

Flux might still be in the early adopter phase. Version 0.11 might be nice for side projects, but I'd feel uncomfortable trying to deploy a commercial app using a project that has been available to the public for less than 6 months.

megaman821 12y ago

React + what? Is there a standard router/controller and model that get's used with React? I think they just could have added the line "As an alternative to using underscore templates in Backbone, you can use React instead."

nacs 12y ago
There are a couple React-only routers but a lot of React.js people (including myself) use Backbone for the router/controller.
- andrewvc 12y ago
  I'm actually using 'director' which works great, much simpler.
andrewvc 12y ago
Well, react/flux completely replaces backbone except for the router. The models go away completely, as do the views.
compedit 12y ago
There's no standards, but at this point I'd say Flux + React-router are quickly becoming it. react-router is made in the spirit of Ember's which is pretty well liked. - Flux Architecture Pattern [0] - React Router [1] Note that there isn't really a prescribed model in Angular aside from $scope either. [0] - http://facebook.github.io/flux/ http://facebook.github.io/flux/ [1] - https://github.com/rackt/react-router https://github.com/rackt/react-router
- megaman821 12y ago
  I like react-router that looks quite nice. Flux looks like a description of an idea rather a JavaScript library. Is there a flux store that persists to a REST backend? A model really isn't part of Angular core since it was split out but something like angular-resource is what I am talking about.