3 ms·
>First of all Science and Religion are not competing for adherents. In practice, how are they not? There are at least 3 major classes of popular religions that
by wyager 12y ago
>First of all Science and Religion are not competing for adherents.
In practice, how are they not? There are at least 3 major classes of popular religions that claim that the earth is only 6000 years old, among a smattering of other objectively false claims. One cannot correctly claim these facts are or might be true and also observe the scientific method.
Yes, a hypothetical religion that posits nothing more than "there is a god" would not technically directly contradict the known body of scientific knowledge, but it would still contravene the scientific method.
- vacri 12y agoMost Christians don't claim the earth is only 6000 years old - that's only a particular brand of fundamentalist. There are plenty of religious people in science, even prominent in science - they are just mostly moderates, and learn to not publicise their religion to avoid conflict. The thing is that while the root of Christianity and science aren't compatible, the everyday practice of Christianity has little to do with that root. It's just some initial justificiation that doesn't really touch the everyday. The congregation are generally not so interested in the philosophical underpinnings than the daily practice. Praying to a saint that can't be proven, lighting a votive candle, or dropping money in the poor box does not compete with investigating atoms.
- wyager 12y ago>Praying to a saint that can't be proven [...] does not compete with investigating atoms. Yes, it absolutely does, because believing in the truthfulness of that person's sainthood (i.e. the existence of miracles) or the efficacy of prayer as a method of communicating with dead people requires the devotee to ignore scientific evidence to the contrary and/or believe something that has not been empirically deducted or otherwise formally proven. This is essentially the opposite of the scientific mindset.