5 ms·
Autistics in the Silicon Valley
- dyadic 12y agoIn the ideal world there'd be no companies explicitly seeking or denying the autistic, just jobs available and anyone applying and then viewed as more than autistic or not autistic. Secondly, but perhaps more important, I see companies that solely hire the autistic more as taking advantage than as providing assistance.
- chimeracoder 12y ago> In the ideal world there'd be no companies explicitly seeking or denying the autistic, just jobs available and anyone applying and then viewed as more than autistic or not autistic. Perhaps, but this only works in a world in which our evaluation criteria and processes are sophisticated and mature enough to be fair to all applicants. The article illustrates a few reasons this is not the case (such as expecting candidates to look you in the eye when talking to you). Interviewers (and systems/processes) have biases - the first step to eliminating those subtle (or sometimes not-so-subtle) biases is to be aware of them and actively work to eliminating those biases, not pretending that being {race,gender,disability,etc.}-'blind' is the same as being 'neutral' and therefore unbiased. > Secondly, but perhaps more important, I see companies that solely hire the autistic more as taking advantage than as providing assistance. This may be true; I'm not familiar enough with programs such as the one mentioned in the article.
- baddox 12y ago> Perhaps, but this only works in a world in which our evaluation criteria and processes are sophisticated and mature enough to be fair to all applicants. That problem is that "fair" is a subjective notion. Most people value being fair, but they will disagree on which decisions are fair.
- mamcx 12y agoDo you understand that autistic not mean "Like Sheldon Cooper?". Autism is use too broadly now, so spread that include mildly issues. A serious autistic persons is unemployable (or need constant supervision). Even the most sympathetic employer would have a great problem trying to employ somebody that can't communicate, can't control itself, can't take commands, can't adapt to the situation, maybe will attack with ferocity for (apparent) no reason, or try to injure itself, and so on.
- Liesmith 12y agoIt's not used 'too broadly.' Autism is a disorder on a spectrum. Some people have mild autism, some people have moderate and some people have severe autism. These are technical terms. Also calling people 'autistic' and later calling people with autism 'it' as in 'try to injure itself' is a really shitty way to talk about human beings. Check yourself.
- sdrothrock 12y ago> Also calling people 'autistic' and later calling people with autism 'it' as in 'try to injure itself' is a really shitty way to talk about human beings. Check yourself. mamcx is not a native English speaker and was perhaps trying to use "it" as a gender-inspecific pronoun rather than intentionally portraying people on the autistic spectrum as "objects" or "inhuman."
- mamcx 12y agoyep, sorry for the bad choice of words.
- sdrothrock 12y agoNo problem. I think most people will tend to use a plural (they, them) in this kind of situation. People who are pickier about grammar will probably say "he or she" or "him or her."
- dubfan 12y ago
- VLM 12y agoNot sure how this fits in with the competing "brogrammer" model of hiring where applicants must be racially, gender-ly and culturally a clone in order to get hired.
- CmonDev 12y ago...or the one where hiring is done to reach set diversity percentages rather than merit-based.
- amaks 12y agoDeeply respect SAP (and others) for doing that. Hopefully this will catch up in other regions as well.
- angersock 12y ago"There are HR employees, executives, janitors, schedulers, technical writers, consultants, graphics artists, designers, and myriad other jobs at SAP that require a totally different skill set than the one SAP’s Autism programs searches for. And all of those jobs are able to be fulfilled well by Autistics." Erm, wouldn't having communication difficulties and trouble identifying emotional state in others be somewhat of a barrier in all but the most by-the-book soul-sucking HR positions?
- mamcx 12y agoSeriously dismissing how crippling autism is for a lot of people, and how wildy different are the effects. My brother is one of them, and despite is "better" than most certainly can't have a job. In fact, is too smart to be in the repetive kind-of-jobs and too crippled to havce a chance elsewhere. A very small subset of autistic people have won the "lottery", so can complain about stuff and have a more-or-less independent live. To think: Is like have a(several?) thin sword passing in to your brain, and you don't know what exactly it damage. That is autism.
- a7291 12y agoI won that lottery and even from my own experience the dismissal of the disability aspect bothers me. I'm happy with who I am and with my life, but having significant difficulty with everyday things isn't just a personality quirk to be celebrated.
- mpyne 12y agoI don't think that's quite the right analogy. The way I explain it to people regarding my son is that you have the brain, the brain's modules are all there, but all the interconnecting stuff that helps the different parts of the brain work together, self-regulate, etc., are all much weaker than in a typical brain. Thus you get people who are very impulsive, or are great problem solvers but have trouble with language (which requires the cooperation of many different parts of the brain), or much prefer visual inputs, etc. Even that is only an approximation of what must be going on, but certainly most of the gear works; it just doesn't work together concurrently as it should.
- cbhl 12y agoI really have a lot of trouble with this article. It seems that it's premised around the idea that there is a wide variety of Autistics, each with unique talents and skillsets, and that programs like those at SAP should hire and accommodate Autistics in additional roles, such as technical writing, communications and PR. But then the author also starts off with wide, sweeping statements about Autistics without citations or evidence: > Autism Speaks, an organization despised by most Autistics and many of their parents > many Autistics, myself included, liken [listing ASD in the DSM V] to homosexuality and transsexuality being listed in previous DSMs As I continue to read it, I start to wonder whether the author is just upset because they heard about SAP hiring Autistics and was disappointed that his/her skill set wasn't a good match for the role: > I would be a disaster in the coding and software testing departments, but would be more successful in a technical writing, communications and PR role I hope this isn't the case, but it's hard to say. I also imagine that it is a much easier sell for someone at SAP to say "we should hire Autistic developers" -- even though SAP would have to spend extra to train the people interacting with Autistic developers, that amount is dwarfed by the profitability of software developers in general. (The financially-relevant but non-tangible goodwill of hiring Autistics is just icing on the cake.) On the other hand, I feel like it'd be harder to convince higher-ups that hiring Autistics in other roles is at all worthwhile if they can't get through a neurotypical (unaccommodating) hiring process.
- phaus 12y ago>As I continue to read it, I start to wonder whether the author is just upset because they heard about SAP hiring Autistics and was disappointed that his/her skill set wasn't a good match for the role. When OP said "I would be a disaster in the coding and software testing departments, but would be more successful in a technical writing, communications and PR role", I interpreted it as a concern about autistic people being typecast as techies. People are really excited to help autistic people join the work force, but most of the efforts I see are directed at technical jobs. To be fair, quite a few autistic people are well-suited for technical roles. I myself happen to fit the stereotype.
- cbhl 12y ago
- gaze 12y agoIt's rude to call someone "an autistic." They are people with autism.
- cbhl 12y agoI actually was pretty fond of the term "Aspie" until "Asperger Disorder" was deprecated in the DSM V. The author appears to prefer the term Autistic, and has specific reasons for disliking Autism Speaks (and the term "people with autism", with the author claims is promoted by Autism Speaks), as described in [0] and [1]. [0] http://www.stanforddaily.com/2014/05/27/autism-allyship-and-autism-speaks/ http://www.stanforddaily.com/2014/05/27/autism-allyship-and-... [1] http://apoststructuralautistic.wordpress.com/2014/06/19/my-autism-does-in-part-define-me-and-thats-how-i-like-it/ http://apoststructuralautistic.wordpress.com/2014/06/19/my-a...
- mpyne 12y agoAspie only ever applied to a subset of autistics though. It does roll off the tongue better, I'll admit.
- GregorStocks 12y agoFrom the article, just below the fold: > You might have noticed several unusual things about how I discuss Autism. I’ve capitalized Autism, and I have not once used the word “disorder” or “syndrome” in tandem with it. I also say Autistic, rather than “person with autism” -- the term Autism Speaks, an organization despised by most Autistics and many of their parents, would prefer you to use.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- byuu 12y agoBefore I laud SAP's efforts to hire those with autism, I'd like to hear what their compensation model is like. I understand that, based on the extent of the disability they are willing to accept, that they will incur increased managerial costs. And possibly decreased output. But I can't help but have this nagging feeling that SAP might be using them as a very cheap labor force for certain tasks that other higher-paid developers don't want to do (eg extensive bug-testing.) It might be too easy to say, "well they wouldn't be working without us, so what's wrong with minimum wage?" Perhaps I'm too cynical. On the whole, the term "autism" has always bugged me. I know that it's always painted as a spectrum, but said spectrum is so wide as to render the definition alone almost completely meaningless. A person who can't live without constant, 24/7 supervision and is unable to communicate is in an entirely different category than a person who just has trouble maintaining eye contact in a conversation and is maybe a bit too passionate about some niche interest. Increasingly, I've seen it being used as a pejorative against software developers (as this profession does indeed require extreme dedication), usually by the types of people who have zero ambition of their own. Most likely as self-validation that their apathy is normal, and it's others who have the problem. I think this really does a disservice to the people who are genuinely suffering from an actual disorder. And it also pushes people toward the lighter end of the spectrum to play up how autism is really just a different mindset and not a disorder at all. In my personal opinion, (I don't publish any manuals on mental disorders,) if you are living on your own, earn a decent salary, have friends, and otherwise appear completely normal to others in person; then I don't care if you have a bit of trouble with social cues: you're not autistic. And it's insulting if you or others refer to yourself as such. Even worse is when I see them being used as excuses. I had some issues with social graces as a teenager, so I practiced and do pretty well now. It's disgusting for someone to play off issues that they could easily address with some effort on their part. Even if it's legitimately a problem, a disorder is not an excuse to give up on trying, and just expect everyone else to tolerate you. Yes, it sucks that you have to try harder than others. Welcome to life, it's not fair. I see this same situation with regards to the obsessive-compulsive label. People who simply have a perfectly sane desire to want an organized work desk, or to wash their hands before eating, or to double-check that they locked their door often identify or are identified as having OCD. That's a joke compared to the people who live in a constant state of intense anxiety, who can get stuck for hours turning a light switch on and off hundreds of times until it "feels right", or who end up driving around the neighborhood dozens of times, terrified that they ran someone over and need to go and make sure they didn't. Let's leave the "disorder" label for people who really are disabled in a significant, life-impairing way.