2 ms·
This makes zero sense. Why would they brick phones, costing each user (and likely themselves when the users sue) hundreds of dollars in damage when they can eas
by lern_too_spel 12y ago
This makes zero sense. Why would they brick phones, costing each user (and likely themselves when the users sue) hundreds of dollars in damage when they can easily disrupt phone service in an area for a controlled period of time or block specific subscribers at the telco?
Note that the kill switch operates at a per phone level, so they would have to identify every user at the protest they want to brick, at which point there are better ways to handle the situation.
- bgentry 12y agoWhy would they brick phones, costing each user (and likely themselves when the users sue) hundreds of dollars in damage when they can easily disrupt phone service in an area for a controlled period of time or block specific subscribers at the telco? Because it's not their money?
- DSMan195276 12y agoYou don't understand what he was getting at. It's much more complicated to go through this process to brick each phone individually (Which requires figuring out who owns what phone) then just disrupt phone service for a while in the area.
- talmand 12y agoNah, build it so that it responds to distance to tower. Send out an alert to the whole system. If the phone is within communications distance of the tower, switch off.
- lern_too_spel 12y agoThat's not how it works. You're arguing against a system that nobody is planning to build.
- talmand 12y agoI didn't say anyone was planning to build such a system nor argued against such a thing. I was suggesting another way it could be done.
- coldtea 12y ago>Why would they brick phones, costing each user (and likely themselves when the users sue) hundreds of dollars in damage when they can easily disrupt phone service in an area for a controlled period of time or block specific subscribers at the telco? Because they can demand that power and have it offered to them?
- lern_too_spel 12y agoRead the second half of the sentence you quoted.
- coldtea 12y agoWhat makes you think I didn't read it? That was exactly my point in answering it: the fact that there is another, already existing, way to effect the same thing, doesn't negate the fact that police often demands whatever they can get away with, even if its superfluous. It's just another capability to block phones that they can have, and if they can have it without needing to even ask a telco to do it for them, even the better.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>costing each user (and likely themselves when the users sue) hundreds of dollars in damage Qualified immunity.