5 ms·
I don't buy it, right off. Seems just as likely as people that read more recall less. Especially at the levels that people read more when they get an ebook.
by taeric 12y ago
I don't buy it, right off. Seems just as likely as people that read more recall less. Especially at the levels that people read more when they get an ebook.
More likely, actually, is people that are used to reading paper books don't read as well in a new format. Also consider, many more people are reading "mystery" novels than did in the past. I know I would likely have never picked up a mystery myself, yet I have picked up a few on digital sales.
- MattBearman 12y agoThis seems likely, since getting a kindle I probably read at least 10 time more books than the analogue days.
- gretful 12y agoditto for me too. I read multiple books a week now, versus only what I could carry home from the library, or buy at the bookstore.
- DanBC 12y ago> Also consider, many more people are reading "mystery" novels than did in the past. How are you defining "many more people" here? Raw numbers? Or the proportion of mystery book buying readers?
- taeric 12y agoSadly, I don't have hard numbers here. Just going with sources such as this[1]. Basically, the fiction market is growing by about 40% currently. To my (admittedly layman) eyes, that is pretty impressive growth. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/15/business/media/e-book-sales-a-boon-to-publishers-in-2012.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/15/business/media/e-book-sale...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thevardanian 12y agoWhile that may be a true factor, it's still undoubted that the tactile feedback is much more vibrant, and engrossing than digital. Physical books are cognitively superior in that they allow a reader to firmly establish the progress of narrative through physical feedback. The very act of turning a page, and accumulating each page as physical entities allows a user to see the accumulative progress of a story continuously. In that you can physically see the beginning, and the end, the only obstacle is familiarizing one's self with the contents of the book. Digital reading however is totally abstract. Chronology, and pagination, beginning, and ending, don't really exist, but are completely an abstract object established by some magical forming of pixels. Every time you "turn a page" there's nothing actually happening, save for the movement of pixels, there's no visual, or physical feedback, no interactive feedback, at least not as in depth of a feedback as physical books provide. And as encoding only enhances with increased sensory input, I would say that digital does comparatively have a decreased sensory input, and therefore decreased ability to encode. So perhaps the missing link is the vast array of cognitive feedback that one receives when physically turning pages, that is sacrificed in digital reading. Another possibility is that a reader is more distracted when reading digital books, due to the multiplicity of tasks one can actively partake using computers. Since there are many tasks, a reader could actively seek out, or remember other tasks that are more enticing, or urgent. In comparison there's only one thing you can do with a book. That does not take into to account the physical surrounding of a reader, as that also may have a profound effect. This is only conjecture.
- taeric 12y agoSee, this is where I think you have over thought it. I think it is just as likely that people read their ebooks in more places and more "on the run" than they do physical books. In large part because you can. Now, I fully agree with the "more distracted" portion. Especially if we are considering such reading devices as iPads or phones. Reading from my paperwhite, though, I would be surprised if this is much different than reading a paperback. Other than that I am now reading more than I used to. (Seriously, I got how many books from the humble bundle?) Also... just because I "don't buy it" doesn't mean I'm right. :) More research will show more data that should help actually answer these questions. I'm just saying I don't expect more research to necessarily confirm this one.
- dsg42 12y ago"...with equivalent reading habits and experience with tablets..."
- taeric 12y agoRight. I am not saying that these folks did bad research. I just don't expect the findings to stand a long test of time. And, just because I don't think so, doesn't mean I'm right. :)