3 ms·
I come away from this article with the singular thought: *The justice system is broken.* The patent troll problem would simply evaporate if the justice sys
by javajosh 12y ago
I come away from this article with the singular thought:
*The justice system is broken.*
The patent troll problem would simply evaporate if the justice system worked properly - if, for example, the vast majority of the trial was conducted online with the aid of computers. If all of the mechanical work could be automated, motions filed in real time, the mechanics of the trial enforced perfectly and without delay...
(Fixing the justice system would also fix two other problematic areas: the criminal justice system that relies on prosecutorial over-reach, and improved consumer protection.)
- prawn 12y ago(Upvoted. Seems like something worth further discussion amongst people that know the field.) Other than tradition/inertia, are there reasons that trials are held in particular rooms and the ways they are? Could there be an electronic equivalent involving securely identified participants? Could someone tackle this as a startup?
- javajosh 12y agoThis is something I would love (lurve!) to tackle, because justice is a vitally important part of any society, and it's a place where "productivity improvements" could be vast (perhaps 100x faster trials?). The way I'd move into this would be to get some experience with real trials and/or private arbitration. It would be ideal to get a JD and actually practice law, but that's probably not necessary. Arbitration is a good place to start because it's relatively unregulated and easy to introduce new models of interaction and judgement, and there's a strong cost minimization incentive anyway. I'd work on it but I've got other fish to fry at the moment. Maybe next year!
- prawn 12y agoI have time or expertise in that field either but your comment resonated and I'd be happy to see someone sort it out.
- vidarh 12y ago> if, for example, the vast majority of the trial was conducted online with the aid of computers. If all of the mechanical work could be automated, motions filed in real time, the mechanics of the trial enforced perfectly and without delay... What problem do you think this would solve? It seems like you think that "mechanical work" is what is holding up motions, the conduct of the trial and enforcement. But from what I can gather, what takes time is the human effort to make the arguments.
- javajosh 12y agoThe vast majority of time and effort is spent, essentially, building an ad hoc model of the world, filtering the past through 'discovery'; but you end up going back and forth to this ponderously slow phase, each time the court loses context and spends time to regain it. It's slow, messy, and error prone. With better tools, you could get an OOM (or two) better, I'd guess. After all, a trial is just a program that outputs a single bit. (Yes, I'm aware that damages take more than a bit, but to a first-order the output is a bit.)