5 ms·
> essentially dirty bombs without detonators and must be protected as such. No, it's completely wrong. That's not how a nuclear plant works. And as you can see
by ekianjo 12y ago
> essentially dirty bombs without detonators and must be protected as such.
No, it's completely wrong. That's not how a nuclear plant works. And as you can see, a nuclear plant does not "explode" when it goes amok. The chain reaction is very tightly controlled and there are multiples redundancies in case things don't work as expected.
- rdl 12y ago"dirty bomb" is a radiological weapon, not a fission/fusion weapon, and is exactly what detonating explosives (or H gas, or whatever) inside a commercial power reactor or RTG would be.
- jjoonathan 12y agoExcept that a dirty bomb is designed to maximize the hazardous effects of such an event while a reactor is designed to minimize the hazardous effects of such an event.
- justincormack 12y agoNo, a dirty bomb is mainly designed to maximize fear, not hazard. Once its gone off, telling people it was safe is probably not going to work very well.
- damian2000 12y agoExcept you just have to look at Fukushima to see that things can still go badly wrong, resulting in a meltdown of 3 reactors. And this happened in arguably one of the most tightly regulated and technologically advanced countries in the world.
- Turing_Machine 12y ago1) Massive earthquake, followed by 2) Tsunami, followed by, 3) Complete loss of power to all control systems, followed by, 4) Gas explosions and core meltdown. Pretty much the worst possible scenario, and yet no member of the general public was killed from radiation exposure. Just how safe do you want something to be?
- ekianjo 12y agoIf it still survives 5) terrorist plane crash on the core, 6) Meteor impact, maybe people will feel a little less paranoid about nuclear energy :) I agree with your comment, I'm constantly baffled by people who claim Nuclear Power is not safe.
- ekianjo 12y agoI live in Japan and I don't consider that the outcome was as catastrophic as the media said it was (they are always ready to jump on the apocalyptic trigger). Everything went wrong (even the backup generators as they were blown away by the tsunami) and it was still reasonably contained and the levels of ambient contamination are nowhere as high as they initially predicted. EDIT: > most tightly regulated and technologically advanced countries in the world. Let's drop this kind of argument here, there are many things which are not technologically advanced at all in Japan. Like the fact you can't even use a credit card to pay in most places. This is really old.
- XorNot 12y agoAlso if there's any lesson here, it's that government intransigence is the real threat here. They don't want to build new reactors, they don't want to shut down old ones, but they still need electricity too. And of course consider the scale - something like 8,000 people died from that tsunami. Oil refineries burned for hours (how much heavy metal got dumped into the ocean and soil?)...how many people did Fukushima actually kill?
- ekianjo 12y ago> how many people did Fukushima actually kill? Hey, we already know the answer. No-one. Not even the guys who went and exposed themselves to high doses of radiation to keep the reactor under control. And people who may have been contaminated are being strictly followed for potential leukemia and other cancers. Following the events, I'd say the risks regarding the nuclear power were relatively well managed.
- justincormack 12y agoNo, there are other lessons too. Read the official report.[1] "For all the extensive detail it provides, what this report cannot fully convey – especially to a global audience – is the mindset that supported the negligence behind this disaster. What must be admitted – very painfully – is that this was a disaster “Made in Japan.” Its fundamental causes are to be found in the ingrained conventions of Japanese culture: our reflexive obedience; our reluctance to question authority; our devotion to ‘sticking with the program’; our groupism; and our insularity. [1] https://www.nirs.org/fukushima/naiic_report.pdf https://www.nirs.org/fukushima/naiic_report.pdf
- prestadige 12y agoWrong, perhaps, but 'badly' wrong? Despite the accident, building Fukushima saved lives and reduced atmospheric pollution relative to other power sources. Part of the reason we haven't improved reactor designs as rapidly as we should is due to irrational fears surrounding nuclear power. In other words, such fears have to some extent been a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- idlewords 12y agoThe fears aren't so irrational. They reflect the fact that we don't know how to assess and manage risk over the kinds of timescales required to safely handle nuclear waste.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoAfter a couple of hundred years the waste is no more radioactive than the ore from which it came. Although the fear-mongers never mention this,"long half-life" means "less radioactive". By definition.
- rurounijones 12y agoExcept you just have to look at Onagawa to see that things can still go exactly right. http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-didn%E2%80%99t-melt-down-311 http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-... The cause of Fukushima was complete and utter corporate (at TEPCO) and regulatory failure. I would argue against "tightly regulated"; on paper it may be, but in practice it obviously was not or we wouldn't have been in this situation in the first place.
- idlewords 12y agoNuclear plants certainly do "explode" when things when wrong. I assume you used scare quotes because you were thinking of a nuclear detonation, but there was plenty of damage done by the non-nuclear explosions at Chernobyl and Fukushima, to cite the most famous examples.
- donttrustatoms 12y agoYou are right that there are explosions, but it isn't an explosion like an atomic bomb. You understand the difference, but unfortunately there is a fundamental misunderstanding for the general public that a reactor could function like a bomb. There just isn't the energy density to do that. There was physical damage to structures at Fukushima but that didn't cause any real damage outside the plant or releases. The releases were leaks elsewhere (which were still not huge compared to natural radiation levels). Chernobyl was due to a reactor literally geared for instability (search rbmk void fraction for details) in the Soviet union. It had no containment around the reactor. So a basic structure around the reactor would crumble with an explosion. But it wouldn't contain that much regardless since it wasn't designed to, and they frankly were arrogant and didn't care much about safety precautions. As to the plenty of damage from Chernobyl, here's the facts: it has been highly studied over almost 30 years, it is a nature preserve, people who refused to evacuate still live there healthily, and they still operate a reactor on that site. Here's an article which examined and summarized the largest and most reputable medical studies on the Chernobyl aftermath. I was genuinely surprised myself. http://www.thingsworsethannuclearpower.com/2012/05/things-worse-than-chernobyl.html?m=1 http://www.thingsworsethannuclearpower.com/2012/05/things-wo...
- beefman 12y agoActually Chernobyl was (partially) a nuclear explosion. Lots of misunderstanding about this, even among nuclear engineers.
- rurounijones 12y agoGo on, my understanding is that the "explosion" was basically a steam pressure explosion which blew the top off of the reactor, if that is incorrect do you have a reasonably easy to understand source?