4 ms·
Doesn't "a great green dragon" have a different meaning than "a great green dragon" though? The former implies "green dragon" is the name/species of dragon, whi
by Swizec 12y ago
Doesn't "a great green dragon" have a different meaning than "a great green dragon" though? The former implies "green dragon" is the name/species of dragon, which happens to be big/great. Whereas the latter just means a big/great dragon, which is green.
- dfxm12 12y agoI don't think the language itself implies any of that. That's just our brains inferring something about the blanks for us when there is a lack of context. I mean, if you were reading a book, a good author might go into detail about how "great dragons" or "green dragons" are a different species from "dragons" before using both in long chains of adjectives. Maybe it is left ambiguous on purpose, just to exercise the reader's imagination.
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo. There's a breed of dog called a Great Dane (which is actually German), so it would be appropriate to say 'a black Great Dane.' Obviously if you had a fantasy novel with dragons where they were classified by color or there were Greater and Lesser Dragon breeds, you could set your own rules of usage, but in the abstract dragons have to be treated like any other noun.
- vacri 12y agoIt seems to me that you agree with Swizec. 'Great Dragon' sounds just like 'Great Dane' when you put other adjectives. Certainly to my mind it sounds like it's a particular species of dragon. Given that the only place green-coloured dragons live is in fantasy (the komodo isn't green), there's pretty free reign to interpret it. And in the context of animals, it's particularly unusual to use the adjective 'great' by itself, without it being part of the breed name. 'Great big' maybe, but rarely just 'great'. If you saw a large bulldog, it would sound strange to call it a 'great bulldog' instead of a 'great big bulldog' or other adjective. This being said, because of their most prominent colour, we can talk about "gray great white sharks", and get the colour in on both sides :)
- cecilpl 12y agoI have a bulldog, and not only does he fetch, he can fetch me beer! He's way better than other bulldogs - I'd say he's pretty great. He's a great bulldog.
- vacri 12y agoYou're quite correct - I realised about five minutes after posting that what I wrote is really about when you want to use 'great' to mean 'larger in size'. If someone says "I have a great bulldog", it generally means a bulldog that's excellent in some way. If someone says "I have a great brown bulldog", it's more likely that they're now using 'great' to talk about size.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWell, I wasn't too sure because he accidentally typed the same phrase for both examples and the context ended up being a bit ambiguous.
- ricree 12y agoOnly because of adjective ordering. The fact that great usually comes before green means that when the usual word order is reversed, it is because "great" is binding closer than normal for some other reason besides normal adjective precedence. So yes, it does imply something, but only because "green great" is considered wrong.
- kansface 12y agoBoth quotes are the same ("a great green dragon").
- antimagic 12y agoYes. Mathematically, it looks more like this: (great (green dragon)). Or to add to the list of adjectives: (roaring (great (green dragon))) using BNF, you might say something like [noun] := [adjective] [noun] But this is not what the original post is getting at. For some reason, if you want to describe a house as being big and red, you must(1) use "big red house", and not "red big house". 1) Whereby "must" I actually mean in the vast majority of cases. There are always twisted counter examples, like: "Aaron: Wow, look at all of those big houses - aren't they so much prettier than the little houses! Betty: Well, mostly, but if you look at the red big house, it's actually much uglier than even the little houses" This counter example (mostly) works because Aaron first identifies "big houses" as being a noun group, so Betty can adjust the noun group with the red adjective.