4 ms·
> journals that jealously guard knowledge from the people who (often) paid for it via their taxes in the first place The only reason the journals can do this i
by pdonis 12y ago
> journals that jealously guard knowledge from the people who (often) paid for it via their taxes in the first place
The only reason the journals can do this is that the governments that fund the research allow them to. A simple change in the rules for government funded research would fix that.
- JadeNB 12y ago> The only reason the journals can do this is that the governments that fund the research allow them to. A simple change in the rules for government funded research would fix that. I think that this excellent point is what's missing from most of these discussions: a realisation that most academics, who are under intense pressures to publish, simply don't have the freedom to "vote with their feet" ("vote with their papers", I suppose), and that the change must come from an institutional body. That's why I love open-access policies like the NIH's (http://publicaccess.nih.gov/policy.htm http://publicaccess.nih.gov/policy.htm): > The Director of the National Institutes of Health ("NIH") shall require in the current fiscal year and thereafter that all investigators funded by the NIH submit or have submitted for them to the National Library of Medicine's PubMed Central an electronic version of their final, peer-reviewed manuscripts upon acceptance for publication, to be made publicly available no later than 12 months after the official date of publication: Provided, that the NIH shall implement the public access policy in a manner consistent with copyright law. (Actually, this seems to be weaker than what I remember; is there another law that says that NIH-funded works must appear in some open-access forum, or am I misremembering the import of the law?)
- jonathaneisen 12y agoThe NIH open access policy is not enough. First, it only applies to NIH funded work. Work funded by other agencies does not fall under these rules. Also - I don't think posting papers to Pubmed Central 1 year after publication is quick enough to advance science. And furthermore, the papers are only made freely available in Pubmed Central. The NIH policy does not require papers to be "open" (as in, free to use and reuse in any way one wants). Oh - and Science is one of, if the the, only journal that does not do deposition to Pubmed Central for the authors. The authors have to do it themselves and many do not.
- JadeNB 12y ago> The NIH open access policy is not enough. To be sure!—I agree with all of your points. However, we have to start somewhere, and it is something—I'd rather have an imperfect solution, as long as it stimulates a search for the perfect one, than no solution. For example, as far as I know, no common grants in mathematics carry this stipulation. (I am thinking here of the situation where it is (relatively) easy now to obtain non-DRM'd music; the initial solutions were far from perfect, but they showed that the world didn't end when they were implemented.)
- jonathaneisen 12y agoYes, agreed. I support the NIH policy. I just want more openness than it provides.
- gioele 12y agoThe change is already there in UK: «All articles published by DS/CN are published under a Creative Commons 3.0 CC-BY licence (required for compatibilty with the RCUK mandate, but not offered by many journals in the Humanities and Social Sciences). This means that authors and institutions may also freely republish their work in their own institutional repositories or personal webpages ("Green Open Access").» http://www.digitalstudies.org/ojs/index.php/digital_studies http://www.digitalstudies.org/ojs/index.php/digital_studies
- michaelhoffman 12y agoRCUK allows a six-month delay before results are made available to the public. This is too long. http://www.rcuk.ac.uk/research/openaccess/policy/ http://www.rcuk.ac.uk/research/openaccess/policy/
- nileshtrivedi 12y agoIndian government is considering Open Access policy for all publicly funded research: www.medianama.com/2014/07/223-government-open-access-policy/
- coriny 12y agoA second key step that is frequently ignored is that funding has to be provided for publishing in open access (normally it isn't). Publishing budgets are normally very small (if any money is given at all). This often puts quality open access (e.g. PLOS) out of reach. The last team I was in always wanted to publish open access, but only the Wellcome Trust funded person had a specific budget to pay for it. So we either crammed him on the author list and pretended he contributed significantly (unethical all round) or went non-OA (not what we wanted either). And this is before we get into whose government paid for what. I was US-funded and working at a British university alongside EU & charity funded researchers. Who has the right to see what? And what if the work was partially funded by a company? Or do you argue that all Europeans have the right to read US-funded work and vice versa? I personally would, but I think many people would disagree if I'd written China instead of the EU. Also, though I think many people will disagree with this, I'm not sure open access - while ideologically preferable - is a panacea for much at all. I've been publishing OA for >10 years, but in practice it makes virtually no difference to accessibility for professional western researchers. Research papers are perhaps best understood and used as professional communications on method rather than descriptions of truth or the state of the art (as a side note I believe this conflict is where many of the arguments over the quality of the literature arise)*. Professional researchers have access to all the papers they need. OA really really helps researchers in poor countries. And this is the strongest argument for it, where the impact can really be felt and measured, but this is almost never the argument I see put forward by the tech/gadget communities.
- jonathaneisen 12y agoA few comments. 1. I worked at a small research institute for 8 years. The place was called TIGR. It was one of the world leaders in genome sequencing. But we had only 200 people. We did not have subscriptions to most journals. I think this is common - sure - researchers at big universities have access to most papers. But researchers at small ones, or start ups, or reporters, etc do not. 2. Open access is NOT just about getting papers for free. It is also about the license for reuse of materials. When papers are truly open access they can be reused and reshared in diverse ways. This allows for new types of research (e.g., full text cluster analysis) and for better sharing and reuse (e.g., online textbooks). 3. I disagree about research papers being best seen as only professional communications among researchers. I think a good paper should also be readible and understandable (at least in parts) by people outside of the professional research community. The more we engage the public with REAL science the better.