5 ms·
>Often in the media, protesters can gain sympathy for their cause by prompting authorities to take physical action against them. "blame the victim" right from
by trhway 12y ago
>Often in the media, protesters can gain sympathy for their cause by prompting authorities to take physical action against them.
"blame the victim" right from the start (2nd paragraph). I guess that sets the tone for the army people who are normally pretty isolated from social issues and don't have very well informed opinion of their own.
>The level of violence is determined by the willingness of demonstrators to display and voice their opinions in support of their cause and the actions and reactions of the control force on scene.
"the willingness of demonstrators to display and voice their opinions in support of their cause" as a major leading factor determining level of violence - blame the witness again, these hippies/african-americans/whoever brought it upon themselves. If you think about it - a willingness to display and voice your opinions is a major existential threat to the established order and, given such level of the threat, violent response by the established order would be a reasonable (from the order's POV) thing.
Major point here seems to be as usually is to take all responsibility issues on the part of enforcers/army out of picture and just make them follow the orders with full surety that they going the right thing. Typical brainwash.
- marktangotango 12y agoNice, you totally cut and pasted out of context: >>Often in the media, protesters can gain sympathy for their cause by prompting authorities to take physical action against them. >"blame the victim" right from the start (2nd paragraph). I guess that sets the tone for the army people who are normally pretty isolated from social issues and don't have very well informed opinion of their own. Sentence immediately before this in the same paragraph "During unified action, U.S. forces should never violate basic civil or human rights. Most protesters are law-abiding citizens who intend to keep their protests nonviolent, but some protest planners insist that the event involve violence." >>The level of violence is determined by the willingness of demonstrators to display and voice their opinions in support of their cause and the actions and reactions of the control force on scene. Again, the sentence before this one: "Violence can be the result of demonstrators beginning to conduct unlawful or criminal acts and authorities (who are responsible for the safety and welfare of all) enforcing the laws of the municipality, state, or nation." You're biases are clear.
- trhway 12y agothe key items are naturally embedded in the "context" so an argument like yours can always be made, yet these key items are the ones that's getting ingrained in the minds of their target audience. Basic skill of good copywriting. to the rayiner below - there is no argument that protests are crushed much more violently in the rest of the world (may be except for a couple of countries like England and Germany). There is a reason i left Russia where just calling for a protest is a felony these days :)
- rayiner 12y agoBy your reasoning, you can take any quote out of context and use it to make up an argument. I don't know anything about your experience, but I suspect you have no idea what the hell you're talking about. The fact is that protests out in the rest of the world aren't like protests in San Francisco. I was once in Bangladesh during a "hartal" (general strike). People staying in our hotel were shuttled to the airport under armed guard. Last year, almost 100 people were killed in these sorts of protests. And Bangladesh is a very safe, stable country compared to the ones where the U.S. military usually intervenes. That's the context this manual must be read in.
- owenjones 12y agoWhat does how other countries deal with protests have anything to do with the US Army's guide to dealing with protests?
- Spooky23 12y agoI agree it was a biased statement, but the key issue is that if you roll out soldiers to address a civil disturbance, you need to figure out what they are going to do. If they are there to prevent escalation, they need to take the abuse hurled at them and suck it up. Saying "We come in peace and respect you, stand by while we crack your skull open with a truncheon" doesn't exempt your conduct. If standard operating procedure calls for escalation from skull-cracking to rifle fire into a crowd to machine gunning of the crowd, we have a problem.
- 12y ago
- owenjones 12y agoI see no blame anywhere in the article, and claiming that: > army people [...] are normally pretty isolated from social issues and don't have very well informed opinion of their own. is both untrue and offensive. EDIT, never mind I see you took the bold stance of commenting from a throwaway.
- wehadfun 12y agoClearly you are not familiar with Military culture. Military and their families live, eat, party, go to theaters, go to school, shop,... on Military bases that civilians have limited if any access to. Some are stationed in foreign countries or are on float (working on a ship) for months. They are definitely separated from the rest of us.
- chrissnell 12y agoNo, that's simply not true. I've said this on HN several times through the years but it is still and will always be true: the US military is a slice of Americana. Virtually every subculture represented in America can be found in the US military. We live in your neighborhoods, eat at the same restaurants, watch the same TV shows, and send our children to the same schools as you. We are you.
- mpyne 12y agoMilitary bases have places to go to, yes. But they certainly do not seclude or sequester themselves from civilian life. Indeed, if military servicemembers actually could be relied on to stay on base many senior officers would be inordinately pleased. But do not confuse being able to walk on base with a complete isolation with the civilian sector; servicemembers still have civilian friends, parents, relatives, spouses, children, in-laws, social acquaintances, often co-workers, and the list goes on and on. As far as being on a ship (with access to email, news, and Facebook...) for months, what do you think happens to civilian mariners, or astronauts, or offshore oil rig workers when they're gone for months? Are they necessarily isolated and socially inept too?
- anigbrowl 12y agoImpressive cherry-picking ability you have there.
- sigzero 12y ago> I guess that sets the tone for the army people who are normally pretty isolated from social issues What? That isn't true at all.