3 ms·
Here's what he said: "But there are performance issues with the scaffolding and stuff, and they recognise that, which is why the new build will be better." An
by benatkin 17y ago
Here's what he said:
"But there are performance issues with the scaffolding and stuff, and they recognise that, which is why the new build will be better."
Any rails dev could tell you that scaffolding is irrelevant to the performance of a typical rails app. Yet he mentions "scaffolding and stuff".
Also, DHH has said numerous times that scaffolding is mostly just a development tool. I think people who still trot it out as one of the problems with Rails are deliberately ignoring what he said.
- jonknee 17y agoI think it's a fair knock because it is so prevalent in the screencast (which he mentioned). If it's in the sales pitch, it's fair to knock.
- davidw 17y agoIt's a bit like saying Ford cars are crap because they don't fly well. It's knocking the wrong thing.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"The" screencast? Maybe in 2004 there was The One Rails Screencast, but their numbers are now legion. Referring to a screencast that's four or more years old so as to knock something today is dopey. It would be like complaining today about PHP3 speed and syntax. Seems pretty clear Mr. Lerdorf has very little knowledge of Rails, and likely very little interest in changing that. "But when they needed to do something real, they thought, 'Oh crap, I don't know Ruby very well!'" Pretty sure that's true for people who hear good things about any [Perl|PHP|Python] framework and decide to pick it up. Usually people then just learn the language. PHP might have a brighter future if its BDFL wasn't so myopic about other languages.
- jonknee 17y ago> "The" screencast? Maybe in 2004 there was The One Rails Screencast, but their numbers are now legion. Referring to a screencast that's four or more years old so as to knock something today is dopey. It would be like complaining today about PHP3 speed and syntax. Visit Ruby On Rails' homepage (http://rubyonrails.org/ http://rubyonrails.org/) and click "Screencasts" on the top menu bar. Click the first one, "Creating a weblog in 15 minutes with Rails 2". Watch. That's what I'm referring to, but it's not much different than the original screencast you're referring to.
- jamesbritt 17y ago" That's what I'm referring to, but it's not much different than the original screencast you're referring to." If that is as far as someone gets in trying to get an understanding of Rails, then they aren't even trying. What's disappointing is not that Mr. Lerdorf doesn't like Rails (though his reasoning could be better), but that he doesn't even seem interested in it or why people get so excited about it.