3 ms·
What you say is true if mastery of the foreign language is required or the aim of the exercise. However, if you just want to order breakfast abroad without look
by claudius 12y ago
What you say is true if mastery of the foreign language is required or the aim of the exercise. However, if you just want to order breakfast abroad without looking like an uncultured insensitive dick, translating sentences formed in your native language works just fine. Nobody expects people to master five-or-so languages, but putting at least some effort into learning the local language is usually greatly appreciated. Furthermore, depending on the degree of similarity between your native language and the “target“ language, forming sentences first and then translating them will actually get you pretty far – surely it will be useless if you speak, say, Finnish natively and want to learn some East Asian language, but I imagine it to work decently between, say, English and Dutch or Spanish and Italian. Even English and German share enough history that most sentences can be translated one-to-one.
- hasenj 12y agoIf you want to order breakfast, you can memorize things from a phrase book, or you can just carry the phrase book with you. And yes, of course, what I said was with "mastery of the language" as the goal in mind. You might have a point for "similar" languages, but even then you will be setting yourself to learning bad habits. My native language is Arabic. I learned English when I was in high school, and now I'm learning Japanese. All very different languages.