4 ms·
can you explictly define "disempowered" here? Because I drive for lyft and uber and I know I can quit any time (although it's become precarious of late, I now
by dnautics 12y ago
can you explictly define "disempowered" here? Because I drive for lyft and uber and I know I can quit any time (although it's become precarious of late, I now have substantial savings and investments underneath me that can help keep me afloat if TSHTF). Moreover, the work has enabled me to launch a nonprofit research effort (details in profile).
On the other hand, I used to work in academia which came with accoutrements such as 'traditional employment benefits' but is incredibly exploitative because there's an absolute lock on the labor market. A PhD in biochemistry with years of experience can expect a ~35,000 salary in an expensive city. But you know, health benefits.
Of course, economic risk has always found a way to be foisted onto disempowered individuals. A history of corporate bailouts and crony deals that stretch back to the 19th century are examples of this; socialism is not really that much better, although the disempowerment is typically 'political' instead of 'economic'.
You'll have to explain to me how exactly does, say, uber, have 'disproportionate power' over labor? As a driver, I can log out whenever the heck I want and go to a job interview, and they'll never even know that they were competing for my unit of labor. Heck, I can even work for a direct competitor and seek rides from both simultaneously.
- physcab 12y agoI drive for Uber too, or used to anyway. I applied because I heard stories of drivers earning $2k in a weekend during a conference which seemed like the perfect side income source. After a number of drives I jokingly told my coworkers that I'd quit because the money seemed easy. But then uber dropped their rates and I went from earning $35 / hr to $20. And now all of a sudden I had to work twice as long to make the same income. It wasn't worth it for me to continue as I value my free time from my normal job more than $20 /hr. But there are many more people who don't have that luxury. There are drivers who sunk in a lot of money to become drivers - bought cars, dropped jobs, moved cities, etc. When a company has that power to cut your wage so easily with the sending of an email or text message, that's disproportionate power.
- dnautics 12y agoIt's actually the opposite of disproportionate... It's proportionate. Firstly, these aren't wage jobs, so you're not entitled to a definite hourly yield. Secondly, if they lower their prices then they lower their returns too because it's a fixed commission. Thirdly, it's possible that a lowered price results in improved profits, if the frequency of rides go up. I've seen nearly no change in hourly profits despite lowered prices. And I do think Uber is very sketchily overestimating their driver performance in their recruitment efforts. And I think the extended line of credit for car purchases was dumb, but I didn't take it. Also your analysis has this problem -- by your argument, drivers who are more willing to accept a slimmer margin are "more powerful" although those are exactly the "economically disenfranchised" drivers.
- clairity 12y agothat's awesome you were able to do that. but i think you might have been one of the lucky ones who got in when the dynamics weren't quite as unbalanced. uber, lyft, et al. needed initially to entice drivers to the platform so paid more to jumpstart the labor supply. the disproportionate power i'm talking about is the ability of these companies to unilaterally decide the terms of the contract with labor as a whole (and really, they don't have as much choice as this makes it sound). yes, you can choose to accept or not accept, but your decision has no bearing on the market dynamics because you have no power to dictate the terms for which you'll work (e.g., you couldn't demand an extra $5/hr). part of this is because the fluidity of fractional employment means that labor supply can instantaneously fill demand--there's no longer a penalty for an employee leaving.
- dnautics 12y agoso uber and lyft[0] have "disproportionate power" because they operate a marketplace of drivers, and some of these drivers have a sense of entitlement that they should be paid X, but actually there are even less fortunate individuals that these companies are empowering because they aren't as entitled and are willing to be paid X - δ. Are these X - δ drivers victims or villains? Keep in mind that uber and lyft aren't so powerful that they can force drivers to drive pro bono. [0]sidecar lets drivers effectively set their own rates, so the effects of being too entitled about what you're owed become clear pretty rapidly if you're counting on it for a steady income. you have no power to dictate the terms for which you'll work (e.g., you couldn't demand an extra $5/hr) That's right. And if there is zero market on the passenger side, you can't demand squat. Maybe Uber and Lyft should unilaterally raise their rates to $10/mile and $100/hour for the benefit of their drivers. What Uber and Lyft are doing is just price discovery. Now that may seem unfair to the driver, but the flip side is if you charge too much, people don't use the service as much, and start getting into drunk accidents.
- markvdb 12y agoFor quite a few of these "micropreneurs", the "disproportionate power" over them comes is about at least two things: * The "micropreneur" jobs outcompete traditional services with their lower labour cost. Because of this, the job interview you refer to is more out of reach than before. * They do it out of economic necessity, to survive. They don't necessarily have the possibility of quitting. They are not like most HN visitors: healthy, well educated, mostly white and male. Freelancing is a luxury when you can relatively easily get a filthily well paid consulting gig. Like probably you and I could. It's an entirely different story when you have to hustle...
- dnautics 12y agoAre you seriously trying to privilege check? I made less than "minimum wage" as a postdoc (salaried, 80 hour work weeks). After I quit my job I was at zero dollars in my bank account within a month. Have you actually met any of your Lyft or Uber drivers? They're not idiots, they are aware that things can get precarious. Your argument basically infantilizes them. Good job.
- markvdb 12y agoYes, I am seriously trying to privilege check. Mostly myself, but feel free to join if you want. No, this was not about infantilising anyone.