5 ms·
Imagine this was an article about a web server provider... the customers want to stay with their current server with 99% uptime, the provider wants to switch th
by ZenoArrow 12y ago
Imagine this was an article about a web server provider... the customers want to stay with their current server with 99% uptime, the provider wants to switch them to a faster server with 90% uptime.
In a properly regulated market the customer gets to choose the option that suits them best, but as everyone knows the situation with US ISPs is bananas, far too much power in the hands of too few companies.
- javert 12y ago> In a properly regulated market We have a regulated market. Time Warner, Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon are the ones who have captured it. Slowly becoming like government bureaus. There is no such thing as a proper regulated market. That's like proper communism. If you want regulated telecom, this is what you get.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> There is no such thing as a proper regulated market. There is a distinction between the absence and presence of regulatory capture. Preventing regulatory capture is obviously a hard problem but that's hardly any reason to countenance its presence.
- Retric 12y agoWater is a fairly well regulated market in the US. It works because the actual cost of water is low and the external costs of things like water born diseases are vary high. There are many other examples where a cheap good's price is significantly increased but few people care because the regulations don't impact them and it's still cheap.
- rayiner 12y agoWater is a disaster in much of the U.S. A good example is the western states that don't have many natural resources. The government decided that water was a human right, built a ton of irrigation in the desert, and now you have populous states like Arizona, Nevada, and much of Southern California that shouldn't exist and cannot sustainably exist.
- Retric 12y agoThere is plenty of water for people in those areas, not enough for plants. For comparison the 800 mile Alasca pipeline moves 10times as much oil per day as all of the worlds declination plays put together. Or the equivent of about 1 million peoples daily water use. Scaling it up and arizona could import 100% of it's water usage for less than 1% of it's GDP. It's not free but less than the heating costs in many northern states. In the end it's just a question of how many thousandth of a cent your willing to pay per gallon and you can have water anywhere you want. Agriculture happens to need a fucktun of the stuff but food is easy to move and land in those areas is cheap. So, it actually is reasonable for people to build on cheap land out there simply because it's not useful for anything else. PS: Shure, we are rapidly draining a few aquifers but there is little point in leaving the water there in the first place.
- rayiner 12y agoLooking at the price of importing water is misleading because its not priced properly anywhere in the U.S. And training those aquifers is precisely why places like Arizona aren't sustainable.
- Zombieball 12y agoWhat does properly regulated mean? There are vast infrastructure requirements to operate as an ISP. Perhaps the government should treat fiber as a utility and rent out usage to ISPs?
- briandh 12y agoFor some definitions of "properly". Personally, I don't think regulations forcing a company to maintain outmoded infrastructure at the behest of a small portion of consumers would be proper.
- mbreese 12y agoThey are a monopoly carrier. If you want a government backed monopoly, you have to accept a certain level of regulation. This is the cost of being in that business. If they'd rather not be in that business, that's another issue.
- davmre 12y agoA better analogy would be: you shared a web server with 99 other users, splitting the cost 100 ways. Then the provider installed a new, faster server (with marginally smaller uptime -- easily worked around by buying a backup battery), to which all 99 of your fellow customers migrated. You refuse to migrate and want to stay on the old server. In a free market, the provider would say something like "that's fine, we'll keep maintaining the old server as long as you're willing to pay the costs", where said costs are now 100x of what they previously were, since you're no longer sharing the upkeep. You could then decide yourself if this were really the best use of your resources. In Verizon's case, though, prices on copper POTS service are regulated and can't be raised to reflect upkeep costs. So when most customers switch to fiber, the money coming in from the few remaining copper customers doesn't actually cover maintenance costs. That means maintenance of the copper network is being subsidized by FiOS customers. Whatever Verizon's other evils (and I agree with you that there are many), a government-mandated transfer of wealth from fiber adopters to copper-clinging Luddites is not good policy.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoThat's not a good analogy. Home phone pots is reliable and regulated. VoIP information services are not. I can choose between two bad providers here in NYC (time warner cable and Verizon dsl), both of which suffer from regular outtages, often lasting a day or longer.
- NoPiece 12y agoExcept that Verizon's phone service over fiber is priced and regulated in exactly the same way as their copper service. It is still effectively the same landline service. Forcing Verizon to maintain copper means slower rollout of fiber and slower internet. It isn't reasonable for people (Ars) to want faster better internet service, and also to complain when copper is removed.
- selectodude 12y ago>Except that Verizon's phone service over fiber is priced Yes. >and regulated in exactly the same way as their copper service Sort of. It's required to support number portability and E911, but there's no uptime requirement. >It is still effectively the same landline service. Also, no. http://www.verizon.com/support/residential/phone/homephone/general+support/fios+voice+service/fvs/121150.htm http://www.verizon.com/support/residential/phone/homephone/g... "Call Restrictions: You cannot receive Collect or third Party Calls, and you cannot place 900 calls using FiOS Digital Voice" "Battery Back Up In case of a power outage, FiOS Digital Voice will operate on battery back up for approximately 8 hours if an active battery is inserted in the Battery Backup Unit" That is not the same quality of service that I expect from my copper POTS service.