5 ms·
How Verizon lets its copper network decay to force phone customers onto fiber
- dsr_ 12y agoNear the bottom of page 1: > A fiber line that carries POTS traffic is still subject to utility regulations. A person at Public Knowledge told me that VZ is supposed to offer a POTS (well, TDMA) fully-tariffed-and-regulated voice service over FIOS. That doesn't appear on their web pages, so I called to see if I could order it. Nobody in their call centers knows of such a product. Then I used a web-chat, and, surprise, the existence of such a thing was flatly denied. I'm in VZ FIOS territory, but I'm not interested in being their customer.
- rhino369 12y agohttp://www.verizon.com/home/phone/#callingplans http://www.verizon.com/home/phone/#callingplans They don't call it Fios, but it'll work over their fiber if you don't have copper connection.
- dsr_ 12y agoNo. If you live in a FIOS-served neighborhood and do not have existing copper, this product is unavailable. Instead you'll be offered an unregulated FIOS voice product.
- nostromo 12y agoThis is a problem I'd love to have. It makes me sad that the FCC may put the brakes on fiber rollout because a few people are upset that their phones won't work during long blackouts. It must be a small population; I can't even name a single person under 50 that has a landline. At some point telcos stopped supporting the telegraph too.
- ams6110 12y agoI'm closing in on 50 and I dropped my landline years ago. I had a VOIP service at home for a while because cellular signals is very poor at my house, but dropped that when I switched to Republic Wireless. Now my phone uses WiFi at home and Sprint's network when I'm mobile. Yes, I'm now subject to failures of my home internet service (Comcast), my cable modem, and my wireless router, and if I lose power it all goes offline. But so far it hasn't been enough of a problem that I want to go back to the expense of a separate POTS service.
- chimeracoder 12y agoNote that what you think of as a landline and what is counted (for regulation purposes) as a landline are two entirely different things. It's entire possible that you didnt have a regulated landline service, even though it appeared to be one. Verizon cares only about ensuring that their phone service doesn't fall under the regulations of phone service
- doctorshady 12y agoAs someone in their twenties with a landline, I have to ask if you went around to every person you conceivably could and asked if they had a home phone. Utilities aren't exactly a source of frequent conversation. That being said though, regardless of your preference, the point of the article is that there's advantages to copper that nobody is trying to replicate with fiber-based last mile delivery; all people are asking for is that there be no significant drawbacks for them if they're to be given something seen as an upgrade. Think of it this way - what would you say if the gigabit fiber offerings we're seeing only gave 750 kbps of upload bandwidth?
- javert 12y agoI'm 27. I'd like to have a landline, but the telcos are so abusive that I do everything to minimize interaction with them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cbhl 12y agoI'm under the impression that the extra redundancy that Bell and co have to maintain power on phone lines during an outage is precisely what makes it so expensive relative to VoIP products. Would it not make more sense to demand the utilities provide more reliable power in the face of an emergency (even at increased cost)?
- ams6110 12y agoI think that depends on the increased cost. Do I want to pay more to avoid a couple of hours without power during a storm? proably not, it's not really a big deal. Do I want to avoid multi-day power outages? Sure, but those are rare and a system that is fully resistant to e.g. major hurricane damage might cost be more than people want to or can afford to pay for.
- morganw 12y agoIn Los Gatos http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_codes_408_and_669#Los_Gatos http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_codes_408_and_669#Los_Gato..., the copper network is all there is. I can get DSL with up to 3Mbps. I have a cell phone and cable modem.
- chimeracoder 12y agoIt's not just Verizon - Comcast and AT&T are also trying to kill copper, because that would allow them the same unregulated control over phone service that they already enjoy over the Internet. http://www.timmins.net/2013/12/11/how-att-verizon-and-comcast-are-working-together-to-screw-you-by-discontinuing-landline-service/ http://www.timmins.net/2013/12/11/how-att-verizon-and-comcas...
- ams6110 12y agoOf course, the natural response to regulation is to find a way around it. That's why so many of our regulations simply result in non-value-added overhead and higher costs for everyone.
- erikig 12y agoI hate to say it but this article reeks of Neo-Luddism. Fiber is the future and it it here to stay. In trying to hold on to the old tech, these Verizon customers are forcing Verizon to stagger their support between two technologies for much longer than they would otherwise - leading to diminished customer service and perceived reliability for both.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoImagine this was an article about a web server provider... the customers want to stay with their current server with 99% uptime, the provider wants to switch them to a faster server with 90% uptime. In a properly regulated market the customer gets to choose the option that suits them best, but as everyone knows the situation with US ISPs is bananas, far too much power in the hands of too few companies.
- javert 12y ago> In a properly regulated market We have a regulated market. Time Warner, Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon are the ones who have captured it. Slowly becoming like government bureaus. There is no such thing as a proper regulated market. That's like proper communism. If you want regulated telecom, this is what you get.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> There is no such thing as a proper regulated market. There is a distinction between the absence and presence of regulatory capture. Preventing regulatory capture is obviously a hard problem but that's hardly any reason to countenance its presence.
- Retric 12y agoWater is a fairly well regulated market in the US. It works because the actual cost of water is low and the external costs of things like water born diseases are vary high. There are many other examples where a cheap good's price is significantly increased but few people care because the regulations don't impact them and it's still cheap.
- doctorshady 12y agoNot only is this incredibly sleazy, it's a sign of things to come; it's incredibly clear that Verizon has ceased to give anything reminiscent of a fuck about their networks. How do you think that bodes for the longevity of LTE? Or FiOS for that matter? Regardless of either, the PSTN is a great tool, and an incredible, self sustaining network. The fact that Verizon would shrug it off in favor of running off with the money Netflix gave them to resolve their peering dispute or what have you instead of trying to innovate illustrates their future in telecommunications. Though I think by now, it's incredibly obvious it isn't a bright one for consumers. With any luck, a company like Frontier who gives something beyond a negative fuck in regards to the wireline network will end up buying it up and smashing Verizon with it.
- rhino369 12y agoWhy should Verizon be forced to support an incredibly aging network that people are abandoning left and right? 50% of Americans don't use a landline. Verizon offers phone service on fiber.
- doctorshady 12y agoSource? As far as I was aware, it was around 40% that didn't, and the decline has slowed pretty drastically in recent years. Not to mention it's hardly a rarity in businesses. In any event though, you're really missing the point here; the problem isn't abandoning copper. It's not providing an equivalent grade of service to one we've had for decades now. Verizon has long supported regulated POTS service over FiOS. They're now trying to push people towards a form of phone service that's no longer regulated for quality or price, among other things such as the requirement to share the outside plant with competitive carriers. You know how the push for net neutrality is gearing towards Title II classification for internet? That's precisely what they're trying to steer clear of; they still want to offer phone service, but offer it as an unregulated Title I service - much like the internet is classified right now. As for the issue of local instead of common battery, the POTS standard requires 50 milliamps of power. I'd be absolutely shocked if there was no way to reliably deliver that over fiber. tl;dr, this is really more a regulatory issue then a technology one. It's actually very similar to the debate going on about the internet right now. Technology is just the excuse being given to getting around Verizon's obligations as a common carrier.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but it looks like LLU (Local Loop Unbundling) is legally possible in the US: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling Every article I've read about Verizon suggests they're run by dickheads, I'm sure there would be plenty of people willing to switch to an alternative provider, why is LLU not popular in the US? To make it clear, LLU means you can lease the same copper or fibre lines to run your own ISP as long as you install your own routing gear in the exchange. I know it's very popular in the UK.
- raverbashing 12y agoBecause the big players sabotaged LLU and other vendors that would use it.
- mseebach 12y agoLLU has a much clearer remit in places like Europe where all the copper was laid by government owned telecoms - thus, the copper is clearly public property. As part of privatizing these telcos, LLU was introduced to avoid creating a private monopoly on telecommunication. In the US, the situation might charitably be described as a bit more complicated - the copper was laid by private actors, although under protection from the state. It is, at least, a lot less obvious that the copper isn't some sort of private property.
- toast0 12y agoUnder the current regulatory guidance from the FCC, LLU is only viable in the US for customers connected directly to a Central Office. For customers connected to a remote terminal, there is insufficient space to install 3rd party gear, and the incumbent carrier gets to be a monopoly on data services.
- mindslight 12y agoIt was popular. IMHO cable company advertising, webcrapps, and needlessly-streaming video tricked people into thinking they need super high bandwidth, which can only be provided over coax. Since cable TV has traditionally been seen as a luxury service, its lobbyists had a much easier time avoiding being seen as a monopoly.
- crazy1van 12y agoPerhaps I'm too sensitive but I feel the current Ars runs a lot of techno-sensationalist stories that often are inconsistent from one week to the next. Next week I expect to see Ars run a story chastising the US for its remaining high percentage of users still on slow copper internet whereas Europe and Korea have much faster internet speeds.
- sheetjs 12y agotechno-sensationalism = page views = ad impressions = $$
- eglover 12y agoSo they don't want to deal with the hassle of supporting two kinds of networks at once. Big deal. Either find an alternative, deal with their decision which is driven by other customers (not some sort of imaginary corporate sociopathy), or start your own. Whining helps no one.
- jwatte 12y agoIf VoIP actually used the capability to deliver higher call quality, that would be one thing. But these services almost universally sound like vocoder compressed noise in an echo tunnel. They're as bad as cell phones, and have as much latency, which makes conversations very hard. "Could you repeat that" and people talking over each other is much more common now than 20 years ago.
- voltagex_ 12y agoI'm struggling with a couple of VoIP services vs the occasional Skype call. As much as I dislike Skype, the call quality is much higher, especially when I'm using HSPA or similar.
- shmerl 12y agoFiber? More like to their capped and useless mobile networks. Verizon stopped expanding their fiber optic network long ago except in a few areas where they are bound by contracts, and even there they cheat and don't finish the work. I wish Verizon would offer fiber instead of copper lines. No dice.