5 ms·
Japanese parents will happily let six year olds navigate to their school across town. Middle schoolers and high schoolers routinely go to schools in other citi
by patio11 17y ago
Japanese parents will happily let six year olds navigate to their school across town. Middle schoolers and high schoolers routinely go to schools in other cities, via trains.
Nobody believes me when I say middle class Americans would call that child abuse.
- akirk 17y agoI think the Pedibus (or walking bus, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walking_bus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walking_bus ) is a good idea for having children walk to school. It's a group of children walking to school accompanied by two adults along predefined routes. There are bus stops where children wait for the Pedibus to arrive and then they walk along with the group.
- nkassis 17y agoPiedibus ;p Pedibus isn't exactly a name parents would like ;p Pied is foot in french.
- akirk 17y agoHm, it's called Pedibus in German http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedibus http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedibus and Pédibus in French http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pédibus http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pédibus pes, pedis: foot in latin.
- fburnaby 17y agoHe's pointing out that it souds like "pedobus". Exactly what the parents are trying to avoid.
- lsb 17y agoPedibus is Latin for "by feet".
- tokenadult 17y agoOne word from Greek: http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pedophile http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pedophile Another word from Latin: http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pedestrian http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pedestrian
- dazmax 17y agoThat doesn't help give kids a sense of responsibility and independence, though.
- hughprime 17y agoIt might be okay for very young children. Even I don't think that five-year-olds should be walking to school alone -- preferably their parents should walk with them, but if that's not an option due to work schedules then a walking bus isn't a terrible idea. At eight or so, though, sensible children start to have their first rebellious streak and realise how stupid the idea of a "walking bus" is. I figure that when they're smart enough to figure that out, they're old enough to walk alone.
- anatoly 17y ago... yeah, I can't see that name catching on in the US.
- tokenadult 17y agoNobody believes me when I say middle class Americans would call that child abuse. I don't believe that either, because I am a middle class American (who used to live in east Asia). When we lived in Taiwan, as soon as Taipei's MRT system was extended to our neighborhood, our then eight-year-old oldest son rapidly learned how to take the mass transit trains all over Taipei by himself. Here in the United States, my four children (youngest age six) walk or bike to the public library (about a mile away) or to shopping (same distance, different direction) almost every day. We are homeschoolers, so our children are out and about a lot during school hours. It is unremarkable here and as safe as can be. By far the greatest risk to walkers in most parts of the United States are drivers who don't pay attention to how they endanger pedestrians. We live in a very safe neighborhood with a good city trail system, and we take advantage of that to get exercise and avoid burning gasoline.
- anatoly 17y agoHey tokenadult, are you homeschoolers for primarily religious reasons, or primarily non-religious reasons? If the latter, please consider writing up a blogpost or a comment here about your experiences, what works/what doesn't, what's your view on the "but won't they lack social interaction", any regrets etc. (I don't mean to offend you if your reason is religious by the way; it's just that I suspect not many people here will share it). I'm a fresh parent, living in a country where homeschooling is lawful, but very difficult to arrange, and viewing with dismay some of my options a few years down the line.
- tokenadult 17y agoMy reasons for homeschooling are mostly for better academic challenge. (One example: my oldest is now able to be dual-enrolled at our state university at the age of a twelfth grader, taking the upper division abstract algebra course and the algorithms and data structures course for his "high school" program.) I have changed in religious point of view over the years, and my personal website reflects a point of view that is not my current view. By working from my name (ascertainable from my HN profile) to my personal website via Google you'll find my large website on homeschooling, Learn in Freedom (oh, well, I just told you the name), which is NOT current but is nonetheless informative. My oldest son would like to bring the web technology on that site into the twenty-first century, as I would like to bring some of its facts and figures a decade more up to date, but it will do for a start.
- forinti 17y agoThe Japanese also make their children clean up their classroom, which I think is great. In my country, Brazil, parents have fits if someone suggests something like that. It is likened to slave labour.