3 ms·
This is how I understand the stakes at the point immediately preceding the grid hiccup: DC Energy Trading Firm: Out a sizable chunk of money. Incentive to stir
by jjoonathan 12y ago
This is how I understand the stakes at the point immediately preceding the grid hiccup:
DC Energy Trading Firm: Out a sizable chunk of money. Incentive to stir trouble in the energy grid. No evidence that they did.
Power company: Has extra money from selling the contract and double incentive to spend that money in a manner that would prevent price differences between Northport and Port Jefferson.
----------------------------
CMV, but it sounds like the market is doing exactly what it is supposed to be doing. DC Energy placed a bet that others were underestimating the probability of trouble between Northport and Port Jefferson. They created an incentive for other market players (especially power companies) to take action against this possibility and install backup capacity, perform preventative maintenance, or generally to do whatever a power company can do to prevent problems like the one that happened. Since these measures weren't taken DC energy now gets their payout for having "told them so." At least, that's how I understand it. If my understanding is correct it seems like everything is on the up-and-up. Consumers were victims of power companies that not only failed to anticipate the problem but didn't take the hint when trading firms offered to bet that there would be a problem.
The thing that would make this a scandal would be if it were discovered that DC Energy had, say, payed someone at the power company to "pull an Enron" and sabotage maintenance. The danger of this kind of scheme is obviously real (see: the audio clips of Enron traders giggling like kids stealing cookies (yes, really) as they ordered power plants offline in California, driving up prices by creating an artificial shortage that eventually became known as the infamous rolling blackouts). However, it doesn't look like there is any evidence that the same conflict of interest is happening here.
Is the article arguing that these markets shouldn't exist because this kind of behavior would be nearly impossible to detect, making for tremendous moral hazard? That's the only "point" I can extrapolate from its discussion. It's not an unreasonable question. I could forgive its clickbaity title if only the article itself had been clearer about its own purpose.
- disjointrevelry 12y ago> Consumers were victims of power companies that ignored market signals, not a crafty scheme to leverage them out of their money. DC Energy didn't exactly go to the power companies and say, "Hey guys, when I bet against your power capacity, it means put more money in it so I can lose my investment!" That's just completely absurd. From the article: > The contracts were intended to protect the electricity producers, utilities and industries that need to buy power. The thinking was that the contracts would help them hedge against sharp price swings caused by competition as well as the weather, plant failures or equipment problems. Those lower costs could reduce consumers’ bills. > But Wall Street banks and other investors have stepped in, siphoning off much of the money. In New York, DC Energy accounted for more than a quarter of the total $639 million in profits in the congestion markets between 2003 and 2013, The Times found. Some of DC Energy’s biggest paydays involved Port Jefferson, a village 60 miles east of Manhattan. Because of the geography of the grid, moving power from one point to another means demand often briefly outstrips supply here. It's exploitation by DC Energy pure and simple. Exploitation is a foundation of Capitalism. What occurred is inadequate protections, whether intentional or not. The lack of a working strategy to protect electric producers is the true 'signal' that DC Energy conveyed.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> DC Energy didn't exactly go to the power companies and say, "Hey guys, when I bet against your power capacity, it means put more money in it so I can lose my investment!" That's just completely absurd. That's exactly what they did, although they used money instead of words to send the message. If you bet your buddy that he can't handle 10 shots of Tequila without throwing up, you have provided him with incentive to handle 10 shots of Tequila without throwing up. If DC Energy bets PowerCo lots of money that price differences are small, DC Energy has provided PowerCo with incentive to keep differences small (e.g. by performing preemptive maintenance). > It's exploitation by DC Energy pure and simple. Exploitation is a foundation of Capitalism. Yes. The method to the madness of capitalism is the idea of giving up compensatory justice in exchange for having correct marginal incentives. If you could sum up the capitalist hypothesis in a sentence it would be "correct marginal incentives are more important than compensatory justice." It's a sad hypothesis but IMO probably a true one. > What occurred is inadequate protections You say it with hindsight. DC $aid the same thing but with foresight. > The lack of a working strategy to protect electric producers is the true 'signal' that DC Energy conveyed. You make it sound like a trivial observation. Remember that someone else was willing to bet against them. This transaction did three things: 1. It punished that party that incorrectly believed the grid would be functional when it wasn't. 2. It provided a market signal predicting a problem before the problem happened, while there was still time to fix it. 3. Assuming the power company was on the other side of the transaction, it provided incentive for the power company to fix the problem (again, before the problem happened).
- disjointrevelry 12y agoQuote again from the article, did you read it? > What no one here knew that day, May 30, 2013, was that the investment company, DC Energy, was reaping rewards from the swelter Price offset gained was greater 1.5 million (* this is on one occurence of a grid overburden. The wholesale price jump was 550%, which is somewhat of a hint to the initial investment). > Those profits are a small fraction of the fortune that traders at DC Energy and elsewhere have pocketed because of maneuvers involving the nation’s congested grid. Key term here is 'maneuvers'. They don't plot down a one big bet scheme. How sophisticated? Here, let's look at the article: > Across the nation, investment funds and major banks are wagering billions on similar trades using computer algorithms and teams of Ph.D.s, as they chase profits in an arcane arena that rarely attracts attention. Their _intent is to ensure they are not signalling_. (editted: *)
- skybrian 12y agoI agree that the article is unclear. Perhaps this is a dubious analogy, but this sounds sort of like Twitter making a bet that their site won't go down in order to fund improvements to the system so that the site won't go down. This would seem to increase the consequences of failure, which is the opposite of what a reasonable engineer should do. So I understand why financial firms might want to buy these contracts. I don't understand why anyone is selling them. It seems like a big distraction from the energy company's actual business. Don't they have enough incentive to keep the system running already? Shouldn't they be building their own monitoring and models to predict energy supply and demand? It seems like that would provide more useful information than a market, which is noisy and opaque even when it's working properly.