3 ms·
Now people will optimize for whatever this meassure, at the cost of driving safely. Don't take the route that has slow driving traffic, take the one with fast m
by tomjen3 12y ago
Now people will optimize for whatever this meassure, at the cost of driving safely. Don't take the route that has slow driving traffic, take the one with fast moving traffic even though you are going to cause far more damage. Don't stop for a red light, it will cost breaking points.
You are an insurance company your job is to pay when people cause accidents - if people don't cause accidents there is no reason to have it.
- maxerickson 12y agoIsn't the whole point of an insurance company figuring out how to measure things that are hard to measure? Presumably they can stop offering the discounts if they don't actually reduce accidents.
- BrainInAJar 12y ago> You are an insurance company your job is to pay when people cause accidents No, their job is to collect as much money as they can from the best drivers possible while avoiding having to pay anything at all. That's how health insurance works, that's how auto insurance works, that's the nature of insurance. "Avoid paying out unless legally required to, and then pay out as little as you can legally get away with." and the best way to do that is to have a customer base comprised of people who you're unlikely to have to pay out for (good drivers, healthy people)
- tomjen3 12y agoTo a point - if I don't ever get into accidents that are my fault, why have insurance in the first place?
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> Now people will optimize for whatever this meassure, at the cost of driving safely. The point is, insurance company has a strong financial incentive make the measure be as much an accurate proxy for driving safely as possible. If people start ignoring red lights to avoid braking points, insurance companies will try to get to that data (by offering you discounts for providing it). This is a good scheme; the best way to "outsmart" insurance is to drive safely. This can be a textbook example of http://xkcd.com/810/ http://xkcd.com/810/. Thinking about it, I'm starting to believe that speeding tickets should be sent to insurance companies directly. I.e. keep driving like a moron, and soon you won't be able to afford to drive. (also, it would be helpful to replace point&click speeding cameras with average-speed computing ALPRs) > You are an insurance company your job is to pay when people cause accidents - if people don't cause accidents there is no reason to have it. No, if people don't cause accidents then insurance company gets free money.
- tomjen3 12y agoIf I don't cause accidents, why should I have insurance in the first place?
- lutusp 12y agoFor many people, having insurance is required, either by the state (for a car) or a bank (for a house). Those who don't fall into these categories often choose to self-insure, and self-insurance has the advantage that you derive the benefit of the invested money, rather than the insurance company's stockholders.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThere's always a chance that you will. Thinking otherwise is very naive. No human is a perfect driver, everyone can get distracted, or have health problems, or somehow end up in a situation where only superhuman reflexes could help. The only way to be sure you don't cause accident is for you to never drive, at which point you don't need car insurance, and rightly so. As you can see, the system works well - if you can't cause a car accident, you don't need a car insurance.