3 ms·
Intellectual property is an arbitrary construct and there is nothing to stop a law that makes business records the personal property of customers, to be relinqu
by Zigurd 12y ago
Intellectual property is an arbitrary construct and there is nothing to stop a law that makes business records the personal property of customers, to be relinquished to those customers once transactions are complete.
- tptacek 12y agoYou don't just see how you invoked "intellectual property" to serve your own policy goal here? My point is that the rubric of intellectual property is unhelpful in defending privacy. To the extent that society demands privacy, privacy must be an intrinsic goal, orthogonal to IP. And yet right now it isn't; significant privacy rights seem to fall out of happenstances about who "owns" what data. Which is my critique of this article about Wyden.
- Zigurd 12y agoThe hypothetical law I described is no less "helpful" or workable than the legal and technical tools for copyright enforcement in digital media. For example, why shouldn't customers be able to reach into every government's and vendor's IT systems and control how their data is used? Vendors reach into our PCs and phones to control their supposed property that we bought. Property is property, and my data should be my property. Right?
- tedunangst 12y agoYou are suggesting that I have to build some mechanism to allow everyone who visits my blog to review their entries in my log files? No, thank you.
- Zigurd 12y agoWhy not? Intellectual property theft is a serious issue. If I can't impose an enforcement mechanism on your computing systems, that property is in danger of theft or misuse.