3 ms·
It may be more useful to talk about "what the government is allowed to know about you," rather than strictly where or what your data is. In the case of call re
by a3n 12y ago
It may be more useful to talk about "what the government is allowed to know about you," rather than strictly where or what your data is.
In the case of call records (well, any records regarding an individual), this could be a 4th Amendment issue, but it's also a 1st Amendment freedom of association issue. If the government is perusing call records, that puts pressure on your sense of whether you are free to associate with someone. If you know the government is looking at call records, then you may be reluctant to call your brother, or a journalist, or someone in Ferguson MO.
- tptacek 12y agoI agree, except that I'd ask that we be more careful about "ownership". The issue can't be "where" "your" data is if what we're discussing is the location of someone else's data, which is what (for instance) call records actually are. So I agree, we need to be diligent about cabining the surveillance powers of the state as an intrinsic policy goal, and not as a side-effect of who generated what bits and where they put them.
- a3n 12y agoYes, it's someone else's data, but it says something about you that the government shouldn't know. We already have a type of data that's treated like that, medical information, protected historically by patient/doctor confidentiality and formalized in HIPPA in the US. A lot of the medical data about you is essentially the doctor's or industry's data, not yours. It can be difficult to impossible to get everything about you disclosed to you; it is for all intents and purposes data about you but not owned by you. And yet, doctors and the industry are prohibited from sharing that data beyond business and medical purposes, and (I think) the government has laws prohibiting itself from having access to that data. It's a good start.
- angersock 12y agoSadly, "business and medical purposes" covers a great deal, and in the day-to-day that is where the impact really is felt, not from some mustachioed government thug (much as I'd like to claim otherwise). The best reform we could probably see is to say that your health and medical data belongs to you, full stop, and consider it a work-for-hire. Then, a national regulation on how to represent that data (normalizing what is pulled in) and interoperability specs, as well as a public option for warehousing your data if you choose not to go free-market. There are a lot of issues even with the simple data-representation part...terminology and whatnot, for example--and getting that straightened out is exactly the sort of boring work that, in the long-run, yields extravagant dividends.
- chimeracoder 12y agoI'm the founder of a health-tech startup, so HIPAA is something I spend a lot of time thinking about. (Disclaimer: IANAL) > A lot of the medical data about you is essentially the doctor's or industry's data, not yours. It can be difficult to impossible to get everything about you disclosed to you; it is for all intents and purposes data about you but not owned by you. Quite the opposite - a large portion of HIPAA is about the rights of the patient to access their medical data. Actually going through this formal process has a number of steps, but some of the first lawsuits regarding HIPAA were actually about this, not about the safeguards on sharing or security. In fact, under HIPAA, doctors and insurance companies are allowed to share your data with other entities ('associates') without consulting you first, as long as they sign another agreement with that entity promising that they'll abide by certain rules. Those associates are allowed to share it with other associates, and so on, etc. - all of it is legal as long as there's a trail of these agreements going all the way back to the doctor, hospital, or insurance company. Anytime that you sign a document authorizing release of your information to a third party, that's generally referring to releasing data that they can't legally share under HIPAA via the above means. There are some caveats, but this is more or less what is already happening to your medical data - you just don't know about it.
- a3n 12y agoThanks for the correction. It does still sound like they're free to hand off your data, so it does seem like it's not entirely "yours," you just have some rights to see it.
- chasb 12y agoGreat explanation. (I am a lawyer, but this is not legal advice!) I would just add that HIPAA does limit what constitutes a permissible disclosure. Without a written authorization, PHI sharing is usually limited to disclosures necessary to provide treatment, seek payment, or operate the healthcare business.
- rhino369 12y ago"What the government is allowed to know about you," isn't useful either since the government is allowed to know anything about you. The issue is how the government learns it. The 4th amendment only protects against information within a reasonable expectation of privacy. The Supreme Court has found that information turned over to a third party (like the phone company) no longer has a reasonable expectation of privacy. The general idea is that if you turning over data for a third party to read it is not private data. Things like email and text messages are private because they are kept private from even the business. However, there will be major issues in the future because of some of the practices that tech companies have engaged in. Google, facebook, etc. do not keep your private email and messages actually private. They data mine the shit out of it. There will eventually be a case that argues Gmail falls under the third doctrine. The tech community will be outraged at the government overstep. But the real problem is the tech corporate communities total disrespect of the their users privacy.