3 ms·
He wasn't sued because the seeds blew into his yard. He was sued because he collected the seeds and grew nothing but those seeds, even knowing what they were.
by freehunter 12y ago
He wasn't sued because the seeds blew into his yard. He was sued because he collected the seeds and grew nothing but those seeds, even knowing what they were.
>Schmeiser didn't do anything I didn't describe
Yes he did. He didn't develop his own Roundup resistant seeds, he grabbed them from Mansanto plants.
>the magic of selection
It doesn't work like that. What you would end up with is years of nothing but dead plants until you get bored and forget about it.
I don't want to defend Mansanto, but you're being ridiculous. This argument is repeated over and over and it's just not true.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoSorry? That is precisely how selection works. Ever heard of herbicide-resistant weeds? Desirable crops can develop resistance the same way weeds do (that is, by coincidence). The additional "action" you ascribe to Schmeiser is purely metaphysical. In the thought experiment where I grow wheat as a hobby, I do the following: 1. Purchase, and grow, wheat seeds, not from Monsanto. 2. Spray my wheat with freely-available Roundup. 3. Harvest and replant whatever happens to survive. There's also an expected step 4. Purchase additional non-Monsanto wheat in the case where I don't get any seeds in step (3). Step (4) is just a repeat of step (1). There are two things we can say about Schmeiser: 1. Schmeiser took steps 1-3 above. 2. Schmeiser didn't do anything other than steps 1-3 above. There was reason to believe that they'd work for him faster than they would work for me. But all of his actions were unquestionably above-board. What produced the ruling against him wasn't anything he did -- it was something his neighbor did. Consider a different scenario. Schmeiser, the eccentric farmer, decides to devote a patch of his land to independently developing Roundup-resistant wheat. He does exactly what I described, seeing little success. Three years later, his neighbor starts purchasing and planting Roundup-ready wheat. Schmeiser continues to do the same thing he's been doing for three years. Is it now illegal?
- CHY872 12y agoHad he been doing that, he'd probably have had a more defendable case. In reality, it's patently clear that he sprayed them with roundup to find the roundup resistant wheat that he strongly suspected was present in his field to avoid having to purchase the product.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoSo...... He had Roundup-ready wheat in his field legally. He legally sprayed it with Roundup. He legally collected seeds from his own wheat. He legally planted seeds that he owned legitimately. But it all works out to be illegal because he's a bad person? Why would whether it's OK to do something depend on whether you've done it before?
- lotharbot 12y agoPrevious discussion on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5378008 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5378008 from kevinpet: "The Monsanto patents are for the method of using a particular herbicide in combination with the modified plant seeds.... Has Monsanto ever sued anyone who was not trying to use the combination of the GMO crops and the herbicide they are tolerant to?" from tptacek: "the behavior Monsanto pursues is planting unlicensed Roundup-Ready seeds and then spraying them with glyphosphate-based ("Roundup") herbicides. You can spray Roundup without a patent license. You can probably plant RR crops without a license. But if you do both (commercially, at least), Monsanto sues. The point of RR seeds is that they resist Roundup, which is a broad-spectrum herbicide that will kill non-RR crops. In the commercial suits, it becomes tricky to argue that you planted RR crops unwittingly when you are later shown to have sprayed them with an herbicide that would have certainly ruined your harvest but for inbred RR resistance." There are a lot of actions that, if we described the component behaviors, would sound legitimate -- but taken in aggregate are clearly wrong. It's legal to be in the forest and it's legal to discharge a firearm, but it becomes illegal if you knowingly target a person in the forest with that firearm. It's legal to change your clothes and wear a fake beard, and normally legal to go into a grocery store, but it becomes illegal if you disguise yourself to circumvent a store ban. And it's legal to have RR seeds in your field and it's legal to spray roundup, but it becomes illegal if you intentionally try to circumvent Monsanto's patents by using roundup to isolate their seeds and then intentionally replant those so that you'll be able to use roundup on your crops without destroying your crops and without paying the standard fee.
- thaumasiotes 12y ago
- freehunter 12y ago>That is precisely how selection works. Ever heard of herbicide-resistant weeds? And if you want to bet your farm on you being the one to magically find Roundup resistant wheat, you go right ahead. But no farmer is going to do that. and Schmeiser certainly didn't. You want to argue, go argue with the judge who heard all of the facts. But please, don't spread false information like "Monsanto sues farmers for accidents". It's not true.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoYou seem to have reworded "Monsanto will sue you for your neighbor's pollen blowing into your field" into "Monsanto will sue you for accidents". We know they didn't sue him for using Roundup, because Roundup isn't controlled (rather, it's controlled in the normal way, by charging money for it). We know they didn't sue him for harvesting and replanting his own wheat, because, again, that's legal.