7 ms·
The question I want to ask is, are generic CPUs now fast enough that people no longer need faster CPUs? I have an i7-4771 on my desktop (bought instead of 4770K
by DiabloD3 12y ago
The question I want to ask is, are generic CPUs now fast enough that people no longer need faster CPUs? I have an i7-4771 on my desktop (bought instead of 4770K because I wanted TSX... thanks Intel ;), and I can't really imagine much use for an even faster CPU unless I'm gaming or doing heavy compute work.
- userbinator 12y agoNo, I don't think the things most people do with computers should require any faster hardware; the problem is that software is often being written to require increasingly more resources under the false assumption that processing speed and memory are "infinite" or close to it. The exponential growth that started many decades ago has promoted a culture of extreme waste. From the earliest notions of "premature optimisation", and the rise of structured programming and OOP with its many-layered abstractions, to the latest trend of ultra-high-level frameworks and the web-application movement, there is this constantly present notion that "abstractions and computing power is free, but programmer time is expensive". Although opposition to this seems to have increased in the recent years, it's still a prevalent attitude and being taught currently in many schools. People are being forced to frequently upgrade their hardware (with the associated waste and manufacturing costs) just so they can run the latest versions of software - often to do the same things at the same speeds they were doing them before. It's likely not too far of a stretch to say that software on average is now a few orders of magnitude larger and slower than it should be. This trajectory follows similarly to the early part of what happened to the car industry - fuel was initially cheap so manufacturers (and consumers) concentrated little on fuel efficiency, but starting in the 70s oil shortages made for some pretty rapid changes as people became aware that what they were doing was not sustainable. There has been much growth in interest in efficient hardware recently, which is good, but the other part of the equation, software, is also very important. Thus I think anyone who still believes in that mantra about programmer time, when working on software intended for a large number of users, is as absurd as someone in the car industry saying "engineer time is expensive, but fuel is cheap". Processors may be getting limited by the laws of physics but I don't think many programmers have reached the limits of their brainpower yet. :-)
- oldmanjay 12y agoI have to assume that you ignore the absolute explosion in usefulness achieved in the last two decades for this "wasteful" software. there are too many misconceptions and strawmen in your post to write a full rebuttal, so instead I'll just thank you for the (unintentional) laughs.
- Chronic29 12y agoYou won't be laughing in 6 years when you can't afford 512 GB of RAM per chrome tab
- collyw 12y ago>The exponential growth that started many decades ago has promoted a culture of extreme waste. In fairness, I look back at what I was working on ten years ago, and I am currently writing my companies database and web front end, on my own, thanks to the layers of abstractions (scripting language, web framework, improvements in database technology). This database is able to do more than what a team of 5 could accomplish ten years ago. You can't deny that sort of efficiency is not beneficial to many (most?) organisations.
- claudius 12y agoIt depends. For in-house software, I can fully understand that wasting a few developer hours less may well be enough to justify buying beefier CPUs for the couple of users who need them. On the other hand, if thousands of people need better CPUs to load imgur comments (e.g.) instantaneously instead of forcing the browser to a grinding halt for a task that should be essentially trivial, things may look different.
- nightski 12y agoAh yes, the old 640K ought to be enough for anybody.
- listic 12y ago> I can't really imagine much use for an even faster CPU Come on, do you really want to admit that you have such poor imagination? Surely there should be uses for ever more processing power. The question should be rather - how can we get this processing power economically.
- gizmo686 12y agoI think gaming is still the big issue. I have an i7-4800MQ and frequently do large compiles. At first, my computer became almost unusable during compiles, which I attributed to the CPU being hogged by the compiler. I recently switched to doing my builds on an external hard-drive and no longer notice any performance difference when I am compiling. I don't remember the last time I have seen my CPU running near 100% (other than by a process that shouldn't be doing anything and is probably in a while(true) type loop that would eat up any amount of speed), but I do remember plenty of times when my computer was slow, and my hdd led was solid every time. EDIT: I suppose this does suggest a use for extra CPU: harddrive compression
- ownagefool 12y agoThis would be because, given the workload, your external drive isn't quick enough to keep up with the CPU while your internal is? You could obviously use something like nice / ionice if you don't want to kludge an external drive about, but to me it seems like an inherit problem with our systems that we can make them unusable just by doing something like a compile.
- ehsanu1 12y agoMy guess is that you were swapping. In addition to slowness, this explains how switching to an external hard drive for the files you're compiling would help, since it would reduce contention on a single hard drive. Next time it happens, check if you're out of memory and using a lot of swap space/virtual memory. If so, you just need more RAM. Also, the best upgrade for any computer these days is an SSD, an HDD being the slowest part of modern computers.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 12y agoI can leave happily with a core2duo. The bottlenecks are memory and hdd (ssd fixing 80% of that). Except for HD, games and non-mainstream tasks (compiling large software, video transcoding) that is. People are right, it's a systemic issue now, we need to rearchitect things and avoid inefficiencies (lock free research, persistent data structure, programming paradigms [go, erlang...]). I may be wrong but unless you're using gentoo (and even then) your software will never use hardware to its fullest. The main reason I want a recent processor : power consumption. Having a 5W fanless piece of silicon is the main advantage over my old one.