5 ms·
Maria Trisler is often dismissed early from her shifts at a McDonald’s in Peoria, Ill., when the computers say sales are slow. The same sometimes happens to Ms.
by vacri 12y ago
Maria Trisler is often dismissed early from her shifts at a McDonald’s in Peoria, Ill., when the computers say sales are slow. The same sometimes happens to Ms. Navarro at Starbucks.
This is just a plain evil tactic, moving the cost of bad capacity planning from management, who made the decision, to the employee.
- pc86 12y agoIt's easy to blame it on bad capacity planning, but some times it really is just irregularly slow (or busy). When I waited tables it wasn't at all unheard of for the manager to ask if someone wanted to leave if it was abnormally slow. If there were no volunteers (or if everyone was indifferent) they almost always picked someone to go home. Same goes for it being extremely busy and calling someone who is off and asking if they wanted to come in to make some extra money.
- nostromo 12y agoMy significant other used to work as a Starbucks store manager in New York City. He would always comment that the weather played a huge role in how busy they were, particularly a sudden downpour. Planning around such ephemeral things is quite a challenge.
- lthornberry 12y agoEven if it's not bad planning, the business is the more appropriate party to bear the risk of unexpected slow times than the employee. The employee has already reserved the time in her schedule because she's been told that she will be working then. Even if it turns out her works is not needed, she should be paid for those hours.
- jaxn 12y agoExcept that there are plenty of people who are willing to work for these terms. I own several retail stores. Labor is by far the largest manageable cost and whether or not we make any profit is often a direct result of managing our labor cost. Re: being the one who should bear the risk, I am also the one who bears the responsibility to make sure they have a job tomorrow. If we don't make money then there is no job. Of course, the alternative is that we could raise prices so that we don't have to be ruthlessly efficient. But then, the market doesn't tend to like that.
- ejstronge 12y agoI appreciate your position as a business owner but I take issue with your assertion that it's okay to dismiss workers because 'there are plenty of people who are willing to work for' those terms. There are also other practices that people might be allowed to perform but which are prohibited - consider, for example, young children working for businesses outside the home. I don't think the willingness of labor is a reasonable metric to gauge the fairness of a business practice. In general, I think it's the government's responsibility to make sure that pro-business positions (even understandable ones like what you're mentioning) don't unfairly hurt workers - to be fair, 'flexible' hours have been mentioned by the Obama administration multiple times this summer.
- jaxn 12y agoThe option isn't between a job with irregular hours and a job with regular hours. The option is between a job with irregular hours and no job. With all of the talk about raising the minimum wage drastically (small increments are fine), or something like requiring a certain minimum shift length, it will push small business owners towards non-human workers faster (automation and robots).
- kazagistar 12y agoThat sounds really good. The only possible way that would be bad is if we insist on keeping society in a state where not having a job is not an acceptable state. But why would we insist on everyone working, once we can automate most of what people do?
- mindcrime 12y agoIn general, I think it's the government's responsibility to make sure that pro-business positions (even understandable ones like what you're mentioning) don't unfairly hurt workers And a lot of us think the government should have nothing to do with regulating based on some vague notion of "fairness". As long as no one is being compelled to take any action, or make any choice, through coercive violence/force, the government - IMO - ought to stay out of it.
- vacri 12y agoNot to mention that if you do have an unusually busy shift and you're run off your feet, management doesn't generally say "hey everyone, here's a cut from the takings because today was good". I have heard it happen very occasionally in small places, but it certainly doesn't happen at McDonalds.
- mgkimsal 12y agoin the fast food places i worked, i can count on one hand the times we were able to call people in to work to handle an extra busy shift. By the time you got ahold of someone, and they could actually get to the building, the rush was almost always over. mgt/owners would almost never even try to get more people in - they'd just muddle through.
- cmdrfred 12y agoI worked at applebees for a little over a month. I was out to dinner with my girlfriend at the time and we had just ordered food, I got a phone call demanding that I come in. I refused, the week after they only put me on the schedule for 3 hours. I have no pity for these types of people.
- makomk 12y agoHere in the UK, there are people who've been forced to miss their friends' weddings and their own holiday trips due to the same tactics by employers, despite having booked the time off well in advance. Yet our business lobbying organisations have the gall to claim that the zero-hour contracts which make this possible are good for employees because they offer the employees flexibility.
- cmdrfred 12y agoI just luckly made my way into IT (A lifetime dream of mine) but previously I worked at a plastics factory(QC tech). They would demand you work overtime with 24 hours notice. They get orders 2 - 3 weeks in advance at minimum. After a while you have to consider that this might be intentional, its hard to set up a job interview when you have to change your schedule with 24 hours notice. So its not just fast food that does this, though it's new to me that this happens in the UK.
- vacri 12y agoWell, you say 'abnormally/irregularly slow' and 'not unheard of', but the article quote says 'often', which suggests it's frequent practice (along with the general tone of the article). Scheduling is quite open to abuse from dodgy managers - for example, I had a friend who worked at a supermarket that rostered him on for 3.75 hours, then 30 minutes later, rostered him on for another 3.75 hours. This 'split shift' meant that they didn't have to give him the mandatory paid 30 minute lunch break for an 8-hour shift. Same goes for it being extremely busy and calling someone who is off and asking if they wanted to come in to make some extra money. This sounds like a balance, but it really isn't. "Would you agree to do more work" is not the opposite of "I'm reneging on our agreement for your current work" - the latter is unilateral. Hospitality sucks. When I was in my early 20s, more than half the people I knew worked in hospitality. Now I'm 40, only one still remains in hospitality. It's an abusive industry that people get out of if they can - in general, it's short hours, odd shifts, bad pay, crap managers with little or no training, and no job security. Screw defending the practices of that industry.
- pc86 12y ago> I had a friend who worked at a supermarket that rostered him on for 3.75 hours, then 30 minutes later, rostered him on for another 3.75 hours. This 'split shift' meant that they didn't have to give him the mandatory paid 30 minute lunch break for an 8-hour shift. Except they gave him 30 minutes between shifts? It sounds like all they did was schedule his lunch shift rather than letting him do it himself. My guess is that 30 minute break was at an inconvenient/non-rush time?