4 ms·
I don't know about practical, but purely from a theoretical point of view I'm getting a "this is happening" vibe. People can whine and theorize about it as much
by Havoc 12y ago
I don't know about practical, but purely from a theoretical point of view I'm getting a "this is happening" vibe. People can whine and theorize about it as much as they like but I don't see a path that leads to anything other than basic income happening...at least in 1st world countries.
- mahyarm 12y agoI doubt it. You see it mentioned frequently enough in HN-esque circles, but I've never heard it mentioned once outside of it.
- scotty79 12y agoNever? 126,000 Swiss people formally requested a referendum about it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Switzerland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Switzerland
- Havoc 12y ago>I doubt it. Well what else are we going to do with the millions of people that will literally become unemployable due to automation?
- mahyarm 12y agoIt's definitely a solution, but I would posit it's more well known among the intellectual set than the general populace as a popular idea. You don't need to have a large core group to bring it up in a swiss election, and on the surface it's pretty easy to market to the typical person. 'Free money, hell yes!' is pretty easy to sell, or for the welfare recipient 'Welfare money without dealing with demeaning bureaucrats, hell yes!'
- Havoc 12y ago>I would posit it's more well known among the intellectual set than the general populace as a popular idea. I agree. It does not have wide spread acceptance. Or even wide spread awareness. What I'm saying though (and I think we agree here) is that this is happening...whether the public likes it or not...we as humanity are barreling towards this..social factors will force basic income into existence one way or the other. Thats why I'm saying "This is happen". Oh and this is coming from someone who will be excluded from any basic income criteria...
- lutusp 12y agoThe problem with "basic income" is that by definition it's not merit-tested -- it is a guaranteed base income regardless of the recipient's activities and efforts. You need to understand that this is politically a very controversial idea, and not just with conservatives.
- streptomycin 12y agoWhy is that aspect very controversial? It's not like Warren Buffett would suddenly not be paying tons of taxes. $1k/month is dwarfed by the taxes he pays.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Why is that aspect very controversial? Because people are often afraid enough of the "wrong people" getting things they don't deserve that they are willing to accept the right people not getting things they do deserve to prevent it. ("deserve" here being relative to the value system of the person whose opinion is at issue, to be clear.)
- scotty79 12y agoIt's controversial because when something is merit-tested you can hire lot's of people to test merits, those people are your new votes because you gave them jobs. Also those are jobs with opportunities because merits are malleable so with a small gratification to your local civil servant that makes him very happy you can make it even if you shouldn't be eligible. Basic income will be very politically unpopular not because of some conservative rules but because if you enact it suddenly million civil servants that evaluated "merits" will you their jobs and will not vote for you again ever.