5 ms·
To me it didn't sound like lobbying, but laws that didn't take into account that people might give away seeds for free. It's a good law for knowing that the see
by freehunter 12y ago
To me it didn't sound like lobbying, but laws that didn't take into account that people might give away seeds for free. It's a good law for knowing that the seeds you buy are good quality, but poor for centralized community seed exchanges, which are a pretty new thing. In the past you would just go to your neighbor and get some seeds (which is still legal).
- Myrth 12y agoI think he talks not about laws themselves but overzealous unreasonable enforcement, that is a result of lobbying
- Zikes 12y agoIf your neighbor's seeds are from Monsanto I don't think it's legal.
- njharman 12y agoLobbyists often write the laws http://www.npr.org/blogs/itsallpolitics/2013/11/11/243973620/when-lobbyists-literally-write-the-bill http://www.npr.org/blogs/itsallpolitics/2013/11/11/243973620... Google for many more examples.
- netcan 12y agoBut it would have made it illegal for you neighbour to sell you some seeds. This is actually a good, simple example of a common side effect of regulating many industries. The quality or safety requirements seem reasonable and often just good practice to existing operators. For new operators, especially those doing things differently (like running a free library) it can be a serious hurdle.
- seanflyon 12y agoLaws that increase the barrier of entry to a particular market benefit the existing businesses in that market.
- freehunter 12y agoStill doesn't mean the law was written with the express purpose of keeping seed trades down.
- seanflyon 12y agoCorrect. This law sounds like it was written by lobbyists, but it may not have been.
- mmanfrin 12y agoIt's not legal to get seeds from your neighbor if your neighbor is using seeds with any patented genes (a la Monsanto Soy beans). In fact, if seeds from your neighbor's field are blown over by the wind to your field, and you harvest those, you can be sued for patent infringement. Monsanto has done this and won. They even (in)famously hired Academi (nee Xe nee Blackwater) to find 'patent violators'.
- freehunter 12y ago>Monsanto has done this and won. Well that's just not true. http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top-five-myths-of-genetically-modified-seeds-busted http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top-fi...
- thaumasiotes 12y agoAccording to your link, seeds from Schmeiser's neighbor's field were blown into his field by the wind, he harvested them, and was successfully sued for patent infringement. So everything your parent comment stated was correct. There is an element omitted, which was that he harvested those seeds (in accordance with his established business practice of keeping seeds from his field) in the knowledge that they were Roundup resistant, since he had sprayed his field with Roundup to see what would happen, and what happened was some of his wheat lived. Roundup isn't patented or controlled in any way. So what would happen if I took up the hobby of growing a few patches of wheat every year and spraying them with Roundup? Over time, the magic of selection should produce Roundup-resistant wheat, which would be free of any Monsanto influence. Would I be violating Monsanto's IP? If you think I wouldn't be violating Monsanto's IP by growing, and selecting, my own Roundup-resistant wheat, take note that Schmeiser didn't do anything I didn't describe myself doing in the thought experiment.
- freehunter 12y agoHe wasn't sued because the seeds blew into his yard. He was sued because he collected the seeds and grew nothing but those seeds, even knowing what they were. >Schmeiser didn't do anything I didn't describe Yes he did. He didn't develop his own Roundup resistant seeds, he grabbed them from Mansanto plants. >the magic of selection It doesn't work like that. What you would end up with is years of nothing but dead plants until you get bored and forget about it. I don't want to defend Mansanto, but you're being ridiculous. This argument is repeated over and over and it's just not true.