7 ms·
How “Legal” Are Seed Libraries?
- tlrobinson 12y agoSo what's the BitTorrent equivalent of a seed library? (no pun intended, but amusingly apropos)
- themartorana 12y agoUnfortunately, black-market trading, lack of information and transparency, secrecy due to fear of overbearing authority - basically the way drug sales work.
- simcop2387 12y agoMaybe gardening clubs where people exchange them, but the club "prohibits" it for legal reasons.
- wmil 12y agoThe equivalent would be a registry of people who will send you seeds if you send them a self addressed stamped envelope. Next season you'd be expected to donate back your extra seeds.
- asd 12y agoI've used round robin seed exchanges. There is one box that can have up to a hundred or more varieties of seeds. This gets sent to you via USPS, etc. You take what you can use and put something in that you'd like to share. When you're all finished, you seal up the box and send it to the address that is next on the round robin exchange list. You can acquire many different varieties of seed in this manner. http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/roundrobin/ http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/roundrobin/
- justincormack 12y agoIn the UK there is the Heritage Seed Library where people exchange rare seeds (possibly illegally, its unclear) http://old.gardenorganic.org.uk/hsl/ http://old.gardenorganic.org.uk/hsl/
- flavor8 12y agor/seedswap on reddit.
- 1qaz2wsx3edc 12y agoRisky click of the day...
- nickthemagicman 12y agoWTF?! Didn't realize this was even a thing. Honestly reeks of agribusiness lobbying. Seeds are a fundamental requirment for human existence and should be free to sell, save, use, give away. Next thing you know water will cost $15.00 a gallon and only be sold through authorized sources like Monsanto and Coca-cola for "QUALITY CONTROL" purposes.
- freehunter 12y agoTo me it didn't sound like lobbying, but laws that didn't take into account that people might give away seeds for free. It's a good law for knowing that the seeds you buy are good quality, but poor for centralized community seed exchanges, which are a pretty new thing. In the past you would just go to your neighbor and get some seeds (which is still legal).
- Myrth 12y agoI think he talks not about laws themselves but overzealous unreasonable enforcement, that is a result of lobbying
- Zikes 12y agoIf your neighbor's seeds are from Monsanto I don't think it's legal.
- njharman 12y agoLobbyists often write the laws http://www.npr.org/blogs/itsallpolitics/2013/11/11/243973620/when-lobbyists-literally-write-the-bill http://www.npr.org/blogs/itsallpolitics/2013/11/11/243973620... Google for many more examples.
- netcan 12y agoBut it would have made it illegal for you neighbour to sell you some seeds. This is actually a good, simple example of a common side effect of regulating many industries. The quality or safety requirements seem reasonable and often just good practice to existing operators. For new operators, especially those doing things differently (like running a free library) it can be a serious hurdle.
- conradfr 12y agoThere is the same problem in Europe, I think it has even already been posted in HN. I guess it's the same lobby that got success on both sides of the Atlantic. http://www.saveourseeds.org/en/dossiers/eu-seed-regulation.html http://www.saveourseeds.org/en/dossiers/eu-seed-regulation.h... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_Kokopelli http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_Kokopelli
- Tyrant505 12y agoDumb question.. How long are seeds able to be preserved without a (reup?)
- Retric 12y agoIn theory thousands of years. http://www.non-hybrid-seeds.com/VAULTlongtermseedstoragesystem.html http://www.non-hybrid-seeds.com/VAULTlongtermseedstoragesyst... In practice you lose more over time so it greatly depends on how many you start with. However, you could encode the DNA in another format which effectively means unlimited shelf life assuming you a reasonably close species to work with. http://genetics.thetech.org/original_news/news129 http://genetics.thetech.org/original_news/news129
- snark42 12y agoI would assume you can tissue culture a seed well past when it's unlikely germinate as well.
- whyenot 12y agoProbably not. Seeds are live plants enclosed in several layers of protection to make them transportable and to avoid drying out. There are two reasons seeds don't germinate: (1) they are viable (still alive), but it's difficult to break dormancy -- to "wake up" the plant inside the seed and get it to start growing, and (2) the plant tissue inside the seed has died. Seeds that have been stored a long time usually don't germinate because of (2). Tissue culture requires tissue that is alive. The live embryo is removed from the seed and placed on sterile media containing nutrients and hormones. The exact composition varies depend on the plant species / cultivar you are working with. Tissue culture is useful as a last resort for breaking seed dormancy, but if the problem is that the plant tissue inside the seed has died, it will be no help.
- smsm42 12y agoAnother format would actually be a problem - finding a format that would be readable in 10K years is a huge challenge, since all current languages, semantic systems, etc. may be completely forgotten by then. Check out this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Interference_Task_Force http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Interference_Task_Force about trying to solve how to say "dangerous radiation" so people in distant future would understand. Not trivial task at all.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIs regulated standards for foods pushed to the logical position from a bureaucratic standpoint, but mindbogglingly insane position from a biological one, that all inputs to the system must be on the official list of defined things, otherwise the entire process of insisting that we know what is going on falls down.
- sharemywin 12y agoHere's Ohio's laws I don't have access to me email to login at work: http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/907 http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/907
- smsm42 12y agoI think this is crazy that people are prohibited from giving away things that belong to them - and to avoid opening a can of worms, we're not even talking about drugs or something like that - because of bunch of government busybodies worrying about imaginary dangers that never happened like terrorists putting I don't even know what in the seeds. I wonder what if they would one day discover that there are millions of people on internet giving away code which is then being used in most critical infrastructure projects. By their logic, they should ban all open-source projects until they undergo rigorous (and hugely expensive) compliance testing. And cyber-terrorism is a real threat too! So I hope they don't read HN, would not want to give them any ideas...
- mindcrime 12y agoSo I hope they don't read HN, would not want to give them any ideas... Seriously, don't give the nanny-state, collectivist, big-gov, we-need-more-regulations crowd any more ammunition or ideas! That crowd of kooks do enough harm on their own, no need to help them.
- tomphoolery 12y agoThe fact that this is at all illegal is a testament to the shitty situation in the United States with regards to both intellectual property and food production. I'm ashamed of my country, and my state, because of this.
- Houshalter 12y agoHas anyone commenting actually read the article? Giving away seeds isn't actually illegal. This is overzealous law enforcement and hopefully won't stand up in court. The regulations for selling seeds may be unreasonable, but they are at least understandable.
- driverdan 12y ago> Agri-terrorism is a very, very real scenario No it's not, especially in this scenario. Anyone who espouses this BS should be removed from their position.
- noonespecial 12y ago"After the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture cracked down on a community seed library, hundreds of seed libraries in the U.S. are suddenly wondering if they are breaking the law" Sadly, the answer to this question these days is nearly always yes, no matter what you are doing. You are pretty much one overzealous act of selective enforcement away from federal crime. 3 felonies a day and all that yap. Do remember that sensationalist stories aside, its exceedingly unlikely to happen to you. Not that we shouldn't try to fix it, but its not worth worrying about to the point that it alters your daily life with paranoia.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoCan someone explain to me how you commit agri-terrorism with unregulated seeds? What is the government's argument for this?