9 ms·
San Francisco Office Rents Seen Topping Manhattan in 2015
- kirinan 12y agoThis only makes sense. The amount of multi-million dollar seed rounds has increased and people want the best office space to attract employees. The more competition in the market for the best office space, the more people can charge and then boom you get what you have now : hyper inflation in costs. I actually wonder how long until people start looking at the north bay like San Rafael for office space just to save on cash. I know people are already targeting Oakland.
- seanmccann 12y agoNorth Bay is one of the least assessable places in the Bay Area (to SF, PA, SJ). Oakland has a lot of "room" to grow.
- lsc 12y ago>This time is probably different, the company said. Chuckle.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoIt's not really surprising given the growth of tech and the lack of growth in finance. That plus the sheer volume of office space available in NYC compared to SF (NYC has about 4x the total office space of SF). Of course, NYC's overall infrastructure for tech companies is horrible compared to SF.
- comrh 12y ago> Of course, NYC's overall infrastructure for tech companies is horrible compared to SF. What makes it horrible out of curiosity?
- bigdubs 12y agoWell, as an NYC based startup I can speak to a at least one thing; TWC Business/Commercial internet is garbage. Plain and simple. We're lucky enough to have FIOS in our building and that has been pretty decent, it still goes out quite a bit.
- Retric 12y agoAs soon as you move past the low end of cable / FIOS Internet speeds NY has awesome commercial network bandwidth. Think OC 192 and beyond. You can often make a deal with another company in your building to add bandwidth or redundancy. Also, http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multihoming http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multihoming FIOS and cable Internet or even just DSL is a good option if you need a little more stability or bandwidth.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoFiOS isn't available in many areas of the city (I can't get it at home where I do most of my work). TWC is incredibly unreliable (daily outtages of a few minutes, monthly/bimonthly outtages of a full day or so). I have no other alternative other than slow/unreliable DSL or exceedingly overpriced (per GB) mobile hotspots.
- potatolicious 12y agoFiOS is actually "available" in most parts of the city - i.e., there's a Verizon FiOS line running right in the street in front of your apartment. The main problem are buildings and landlords. Many landlords and supers receive kickbacks from TWC to prevent Verizon from accessing the building and delivering the last-100-feet service. The best way to improve the state of internet in NYC is for the city to start busting landlord heads.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoIt's not available where I am. Not on my block. Or the next one. Or the next one. Verizon has no ETA on when it will be and hasn't been installing any new fiber in my neighborhood in a long time. It has nothing to do with my building owner. The owner-occupied single and two family properties on my block (or the next one, or the next one, etc) can't get it either.
- forca 12y agoNYC is actually seeing an uptick in companies abandoning the insanity of Silicon Valley and the West coast and moving to NYC and places east. And, what with NY state's recent incentives to start a company there, I would rather be based in NYC than SF Bay. IMO, NYC has a much better overall culture than SF and proximity. There is also the echo chamber of the SF tech area, which I abhor. I have, over the years, toyed with -- and still do -- the notion of moving to Brooklyn or perhaps further out into Long Island. Love the place. Home of the best pizza outside of Naples to be sure.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoI've lived in NYC for years and am investigating a move to SF now. NYC has always been a pretty bad place for anything tech except financial services companies. The incentives and initiatives are always around everything except software. And most of the VCs I've spoke with here are more geared toward physical businesses, financial services companies, biotech, etc... not pure software plays.
- capkutay 12y agoIt's hard not to be excited for the development going on in the Transbay area of San Francisco[0]. Including the tower built by Norman Foster[1]. 0: http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2014/04/04/mapping_big_changes_for_rincon_hill_and_the_transbay_area.php#reader_comments http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2014/04/04/mapping_big_changes... 1: http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2014/07/23/norman_foster_vies_for_second_tallest_with_sparkly_soma_tower.php http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2014/07/23/norman_foster_vies_...
- itg 12y agoIt would be nice if the city allowed more skyscrapers to be built.
- debt 12y agoMany people here in SF have been saying this is the direction we've been heading for quite a bit(if it hasn't happened already): SF becomes Manhattan, the surround Bay Area become the boroughs.
- Punoxysm 12y agoNeeds better transit for that to happen.
- hack_edu 12y agoGood luck boring subways, tunnels, and right-of-ways through mountains, sand dunes, and silt! Buses are the only reasonable answer and much more modular to adjust to changing demands as years go by. A traffic system that programmatically prioritizes for public transportation, along with traffic citations issued by camera and automation (sorry) is what we need.
- potatolicious 12y agoBART is already built through the very same ground. MUNI already has multiple tunnels through the "mountains" in the middle of SF. BART even runs directly through artificial landfill without issue. The seismic activity of California certainly exposes more challenges, but there's no good reason why underground transport is impossible in SF. Bus Rapid Transit is a cheap way to look like you're doing something about transit in a growing city when in reality you're just kicking the problem down the line.
- sliverstorm 12y agoBART isn't really "underground" though, right? I was pretty sure for 99% of its track it never goes deeper into the ground than an underpass.
- potatolicious 12y agoOutside of SF yeah, a lot of BART is elevated or separated at-grade, but in the city proper it's definitely legitimately underground. Which is the same as NYC - subways in the central bits, elevated/at-grade rail as you get further out and land less scarce.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y ago> "At the heart of high-tech’s growth is strong demand for products and services from consumers," Los Angeles-based CBRE said in its report. "As long as high-tech companies align themselves with this demand, the unrealistic growth and valuation expectations that defined the dot-com bubble should be avoided." "Demand" must be the new "eyeballs." There's no question that there is strong demand from consumers for high-tech products and services. The question is how many startups are capable of offering those products and services profitably. Right now, much of the rent money in the Bay Area is coming from investors, not cash flow.
- mlinksva 12y ago> Right now, much of the rent money in the Bay Area is coming from investors, not cash flow. Do you know what the ratio is? Was in 2000? Is in NYC or elsewhere? How to calculate? Investment divided by revenue of startups, or divided by city or metro gross product? Investment in current period, or cumulative with some decay factor? Is there an index that gets at this that I don't know about?
- jpkeisala 12y agoSlightly off topic, it would be interesting to see how the rents compare to Hong Kong, Tokyo, London etc...
- ktothemc 12y agoI think I've written about this a lot. Prop M from 1986 capped the amount of office space that could be added per year. The city has only run into the hard cap a couple of times in its history. http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/22/the-pressures-driving-adaptive-re-use-and-silicon-valleys-strange-reverse-commute/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/22/the-pressures-driving-adapt...
- tokenadult 12y agoLast week patio11 had an interesting comment on residential rents in San Francisco compared to rents in Tokyo.[1] "Can I throw one into the list? The median cost of a one-bedroom apartment in San Francisco gets you approximately two bedrooms in Tokyo... in a semi-luxury apartment, in the most desirable neighborhoods. . . . "Still though, given that I have had lifelong impressions of Tokyo as being the most expensive place to live anywhere, I was pretty gobsmacked when I started doing the math." [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8142684#up_8142803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8142684#up_8142803
- driverdan 12y agoSerious question for other startup founders: why would you put your company in the bay area or even the state of CA? It has never been easier to build a tech company, especially a SaaS-type business with no physical inventory. You could home your company in a cheaper, more business friendly city like Austin (disclaimer: I live in Austin). The tax savings alone would cover the costs of going to SF once a week. Quality of life is just as high (or higher, depending on your interests) in many other cities. Edit: Seems people are missing the fact that you could literally fly to SF once a week for networking / meetings / events and it would still be cheaper to live somewhere else. You don't have to miss out on being a part of the network.
- vonklaus 12y agoThe chance of great collisions and fortuitous opportunities are hogher in the area. The people who know how to build great companies are in that area. Top rngineering talent, top venture capital, and great people with ops backgrounds live in that area. Like ben horowitz says, if you conpete with a bay area company in the same space, they have a large advantage
- Chronic29 12y agoAustin, and the people from Austin, try so hard to make Austin a tech hub. In reality, Seattle is more "Austin" than Austin, it is a larger tech hub, and is much closer to SF.
- seanmccann 12y agoYou're right, if you want to build a lifestyle SaaS type business, you probably don't need to be here. Folks here have bigger ambitions and want to change the world. Some do, most don't. Lot's are just delusionary. Changing the world is nearly impossible, but that possibility is sharply increased when living in close proximity to money and talent. You only live once, why not try?
- driverdan 12y agoWho said anything about building a lifestyle business? > Changing the world is nearly impossible, but that possibility is sharply increased when living in close proximity to money and talent. You only live once, why not try? Talent is available everywhere and for far less than the bay area. Why not live somewhere else and raise funding from CA?
- fred_durst 12y agoI think it's funny how the same NIMBY policies that all the techno-libertarians hate so much, are the same policies that made San Francisco a more desirable place to live for said techno-libertarians than San Jose and the East Bay. Personally, I hate NIMBYs but I also hate SF.