3 ms·
I wish them luck but the reporter makes it sound like they think merely providing a better education than 90% of students anywhere get will make them competitiv
by barry-cotter 12y ago
I wish them luck but the reporter makes it sound like they think merely providing a better education than 90% of students anywhere get will make them competitive with the super-elite. What HYPS and the tech equivalent like Cal Tech or CMU have over the merely excellent schools like Rice or Duke is not the quality of undergraduate or graduate education. It's the stamp of approval from getting in, the one that puts "Winner!" on your cv, that makes getting into McKinsey or Goldman a commonplace rather than an outstanding achievement in itself.
I'm more optimistic as it's a for profit, so it has real motivation to grow without end, unlike a "real" liberal arts school but if the main selling point of your rivals is the selection effect and yours is the treatment effect you will never, ever reach their prestige.
All that said, this is awesome. It makes me substantially more optimistic that tertiary education might actually start applying psychological research. Minerva doesn't need to beat Harvard to change Harvard.
- zodiac 12y agoIt is mentioned in the article - "One possibility is that Minerva will fail because a college degree, for all the high-minded talk of liberal education— of lighting fires and raising thoughtful citizens—is really just a credential, or an entry point to an old-boys network that gets you your first job and your first lunch with the machers at your alumni club." and I also remember an article about Minerva a few years back where they said they were aware of this effect.
- nmrm2 12y agoOne of the problems with existing for-profits is that because of the lack of tenure and unwillingness to match industry salaries, they have trouble recruiting and retaining high-quality faculty. Especially in STEM, where non-research teaching faculty accept well below-average salaries in exchange for tenure. If its deans are teaching (not typically the case, but then 4 deans for a student body in the double digits isn't typical either), then Minerva seems to have solved this problem.