3 ms·
Making new instruments is pretty hard stuff. One thing that I've noticed lots of new instruments seem to flake on is making the instruments really, truly expres
by bane 12y ago
Making new instruments is pretty hard stuff. One thing that I've noticed lots of new instruments seem to flake on is making the instruments really, truly expressive. At a simple level, most new instrument ideas I've seen seem to basically be a trigger sound on/off and if you're lucky some kind of volume control and if you're really lucky a pitch bend -- all tied into some kind of synth.
But most real instruments offer a tremendous amount of rich flexibility in performance. I grew up playing the violin and one of the reasons you don't really hear good synth approximations of a string instrument is because on a real instrument there are thousands of subtly different ways of playing a given note. Subtle differences in attack, bowing, bow position, string position, pressure of your fingers on the strings, incredibly slight intonation changes, and on and on and on. I can say with some confidence that no two notes played on a violin will ever be exactly the same.
The example of the Continuum instrument is probably the most advanced I've ever seen, and even then there's all kinds of flaws in the sound, bits that sound noticeably synthy -- and I can think of a few performance issues that this instrument can't easily replicate. That's not to say some other kind of sound wouldn't be amazing (I was more impressed with the out and out synth sound than the string sound). They've tackled an impressive number of challenges.
This makes learning these kinds of instruments very hard, but it also means that they can be performed at incredibly advanced virtuoso levels.
This article does a good job at highlighting some of the major efforts to produce expressive instruments. It's pretty exciting to me that technology has started to reach a point that really expressive instruments, capable of virtuoso level live performances have started to show up. My personal favorite is the Eigenharp, but it also has a little bit too much of a one-man-band aspect to it what with the mouthpiece and all.
One point that the article makes however is that these instruments are still remarkably rare to see. I think one of the problems is that they are hideously expensive for the most part. There's no entry level cheapo middle-school music student version they can bang around on the bus like when you're learning an acoustic instrument. I think my first violin cost $150, and I got $100 of that back when I traded it in for a better instrument.
Musicians, being notoriously poor, often simply can't afford one of these things and thus can't build mastery on them from a very young age.
Some examples:
Continuum - $3400 - $5300
Eigenharp - $4000 - $8260 (pico version is $800)
Seaboard - $2000 - $9000
Linnstrument - not sure, but looks like between $1000-2000
Still, as a musician, I find all of these far more interesting than something like Imogen Heap's MIT medialab-like (of which I disliked everything I ever saw coming form there) wearable instrument tech.
- abruzzi 12y agoPart of this is the complexity of the interface (I.e. Piano keyboard vs. violin, etc.) need to be matched by complexity in controllable modulation a in the synthesis engine. The history of musical synthesis was a piling on of complexity up to about the late 90s then there was stagnation (or to a degree even reversion.). Part of this was simply the ability for users to reasonably build sounds with some of the more complex synth engines, but I think a lot of instruments (at the time they were mostly sample playback subtractive synthesis) couldn't build the complex nuance of sound from a natural system. In the mid 90s Yamaha came out with a synth called the VL1. It was hugely expensive and used physical modeling waveguide synthesis. It modeled a vibrating column of air in a wind instrument, and to program it you needed special software to design the construction and shape of the instrument (this was radical because all synthesis at the time was about controlling the sound.) It was actually possible to create instruments that couldn't play in tune, or wouldn't even make a sound. This instrument really responded well to complex inputs and was especially sought after by EWI wind players (the original was a keyboard instrument, but required a breath controller to play most sounds since the sounds were designed to require constant energy going into the system to make sound.). But it turned out to be exceptionally difficult to make musically useful sounds, and unlike most pro synths of the time, you couldn't program the models until some years later yamaha released their internal sound design software. Since then most commercial synths have either been multipurpose sample subtractive, or virtual analog that simulate the old analog synths from the 70s.
- bane 12y agoYeah, looking at the Continuum demo, it looks like thousands of hours went into trying to build up a virtual string instrument sound. Somebody has to splice the samples and build up all the velocity levels and all that. I'm definitely not disparaging it as a ton of work. But I think it also gives us some ideas about the limitations of our models of how sound is actually made. Along the way we've ended up producing some truly unique and interesting sound models which have given birth to any number of entire musical genres. I think part of the problem is also build some kind of control interface which can even detect the elements of a nuanced performance. Take something as straightforward as an electronic drum head. You've got velocity, edge to middle playback area, different parts of the stick of hand, the side of the drum (not just the head). Different stick head materials. You can stop a ringing drum or cymbal, or disrupt the vibration in subtle ways. For something that just seems like it's "onImpactPlaybackSample()" it's not anywhere near that simple.