7 ms·
Why Can't the United States Build a High-Speed Rail System?
- coldtea 12y agoBecause the citizens have been indoctrinated to not believe in public works and public goods. Hence everything has to be privatized, and if something gives little or no incentive for profit, it should not exist (like municipal fiber or proper universal health care). With the big exception of the army and the police of course, where it's handy that the multitide of common citizens fund the resource-grabbing and property protection of the few.
- bydo 12y agoThe highways didn't build themselves either, you know.
- bitwize 12y agoAnd they're also shit compared to other countries due to poor maintenance.
- coldtea 12y agoHighways are shit? I'm from Europe, but have drove lots in the US, and the US interstate system is one of the best in the world. Definitely not "shit". What do you compare it to? The Auto-bahn in Germany? That's like 1/100 the length. Heck, even Route 66 is mighty fine compared to other places, and that's not even officially supported anymore, nor the main road.
- bitwize 12y agoAll I know is that weeks after the 2011 earthquake/tsunami in Japan, a section of major highway that was destroyed was completely rebuilt and supporting full vehicular traffic. Meanwhile back in Connecticut, the construction on I-84 never, EVER seems to finish and there's always jams and slowdowns because of it.
- jerf 12y ago"Because the citizens have been indoctrinated to not believe in public works and public goods." Really? By whom? Where? Trust in government hasn't collapsed due to a sudden lack of people advocating government solutions for everything in the past 50 years. In a nutshell, it's collapsed due to government not being able to deliver on a great deal of what it promises. It's simply irrational for the public to pretend that the government has some sort of spotless track record over the past 50 years. Given how many of those failed promises have been infrastructure projects themselves, it would bode poorly for trying to fix this distrust with yet another one. And remember, if you're inclined to start making excuses for why the public may not trust the government, you simply end up explaining why the public doesn't trust the government, it doesn't make the mistrust go away. Consider that a list of problems to be attacked before the government has the moral capital to spend again on such infrastructure projects. (One rather potent way of looking at the government's trust problems is its repeated willingness by government officials to spend that trust without putting a lot of effort into depositing into that account.)
- coldtea 12y ago>Really? By whom? Where? By the prevalent public discourse ever since the 50's at least. >* In a nutshell, it's collapsed due to government not being able to deliver on a great deal of what it promises.* Seems to be able to deliver just fine in Germany or Denmark for example. It might no be infallible, but then is there any private entity that is? >And remember, if you're inclined to start making excuses for why the public may not trust the government, you simply end up explaining why the public doesn't trust the government, it doesn't make the mistrust go away. If you change "making excuses" to "finding the causes", then it's actually the very first step to "making the mistrust go away".
- jedmeyers 12y agoHow can you believe in the public works if as a result you get a 6.5 billion bridge that has to be fixed less than a year after being built and is highly likely to fall apart after the next major earthquake? And what was the cost of that healthcare.gov website?
- holograham 12y agoA couple of points the author misses IMO: 1. High speed rail is an order of magnitude more expensive than interstate highways. The cost effectiveness of the mass moving people via train vs. via highways (buses, carpool lanes included) is still an active debate. 2. The author cites that many folks use interstate highways daily. That may be true but that vast majority of those commutes are 50 miles or less. High speed rail only becomes cost and time effective over much longer distances. Which fraction of the population need to frequently travel to cities greater than 50 miles away? It's a small subset of the population (and skewed towards wealthier citizens). Roads are much more democratic -- they are available to anyone with a car. 3. While his argument about traffic is correct... where is most of the traffic on interstate highways? Answer: around major cities. The traffic is mostly local commuter traffic that high speed rail would not solve.
- enjo 12y agoWell put. In live in Denver, high-speed rail doesn't mean much to me. Plane travel is simply faster for almost any trip I'd want to make.
- alwaysdoit 12y agoPlanes are going to become very expensive in the next 30-40 years, unless we come up with a cheap alternative to the energy density of petroleum. One advantage of trains is that they don't have to carry their fuel.
- melling 12y agoI live in the middle of Nebraska. I don't need it either. I live in the middle of Nevada. I don't need it either. I live in the middle of North Dakota . I don't need it either. I'm just messing with you. Do people ever stop and think before adding noise to the conversation? You seriously don't have a point.
- mahyarm 12y agoIt's for medium range trips, where avoiding all the airport & airplane BS will make it a shorter trip. For example, SF to LA in 2.5hrs / 350 miles
- jaxytee 12y agoSpeaking of the northeast corridor specifically, there is a crap ton of bureaucracy inhibiting the construction of a high speed line. Think of all of the state/municipal level governments and unions that have to be satisfied before any deal is struck. This would essentially mix NYC, Jersey, Philly, Baltimore, and D.C. politics into one huge pile of WTF. We couldn't even get a riverfront project going in Philadelphia because not enough (of the powers that be) palms were greased. Only way this could be possible is if some benevolent Palpatine-esqe dictator comes along and makes shit happen.
- smackfu 12y agoEh, I think the biggest problem is just right-of-way issues. It's easiest to build high-speed rail if you are starting from scratch, instead of trying to work around an active commuter rail line and an existing Amtrak service. But obtaining the necessary right-of-way to do a new build in the Northeast would be extremely expensive.
- miahi 12y agoThe problem European countries have with the high-speed trains is that they are not as cheap as normal (slow) trains, and by introducing the high-speed ones they retired many cheap ones - that were slower but still got you there. This reduced the number of travelers, forcing even higher prices to cover the expenses - so they are now not very far from plane tickets.
- ghaff 12y agoThis is somewhat true in the US as well even for not-so-high-speed trains. Acela is priced to compete with air. It's about 2x the price of the Northeast Regional Amtrak trains even though it only shaves maybe 25%-35% (1-1.5 hours for Boston to NY) off the time . And, actually, for longer routes (e.g. Boston to Chicago), even regular trains are only competitive with planes at best--and if you want a sleeper car for a 20 hour trip you can be looking at $1,000 one way.
- ojbyrne 12y agoMy (now out of date) experience is that high speed trains are significantly more expensive than direct flights in Europe. I did a quick search and it looks like FRA to AMS return is about $400 by train, $164 by plane.
- _delirium 12y agoCross-border yes. The European railway network isn't very integrated yet (though the EU has some initiatives underway), so cross-border ticketing is generally bad: inconvenient and expensive. Only Deutsche Bahn's bahn.de even has a semblance of an international online ticketing system, and it's far from complete. International tickets also have a habit of ending up charging you full fare, which (like with full-fare plane tickets) is way too high. Within individual countries is where rail has the most market-share in Europe, and advance-ticket purchases are priced like planes, with steep discounts from full-fare prices, varying with demand. People take high-speed trains on routes like Barcelona–Madrid and Lyon-Paris, and without the German ICE network. And many people do prefer the train on those routes: the Barcelona–Madrid air shuttle lost half of its passengers after the AVE line to Barcelona opened.
- Shivetya 12y agoThe US got into air transportation with much more enthusiasm than Europe and this combined with our love affair with the automobile pretty much negated a need or desire for trains. For the longest time traveling between countries in Europe could be met with restriction or such, the distances most traveled were not that great. In the US, it wasn't uncommon to travel hundreds if not a thousand miles on the big family vacation and you had three ways to get there. High Speed rail might have some applications in some congested corridors, most likely only in the North East, but for the rest - air travel isn't that expensive.
- hackuser 12y ago> air travel isn't that expensive I would argue that air travel has become very expensive. I hardly can get a ticket, even for hour-long flights, for less than $400. Most Americans cannot afford that (take your two kids, and its $1600). Combine it with the increased price of gas, and many Americans cannot afford to travel outside their hometowns. We need better public transit.
- seanflyon 12y agoIt's easy to find flights from SF to LA (1 hour and 20 minuets each way) for $150 round trip. $400+ for an hour long flight seems like an outlier.
- ghaff 12y agoThere's always Greyhound. I honestly don't mean that facetiously. If air is too expensive and driving is too expensive, there are always buses-- though I doubt they'd be cheaper for a a family of 4 than driving,
- cpursley 12y agoholograham is correct. The USA does not need a high-speed rail system. The interstate system and airport network is sufficient. Between high trafficked short-distance corridors? Fine. What the USA needs is modern commuter rail supported by a network of private short-trip mini-buses. This would have the most significant impact for lowest cost.
- cpursley 12y agoAnd rail can be maglev, monorail, hyperloop - whatever is the most economical. As long as terminals are supported by frequent ground transit to fill the gap.
- gerbal 12y agoCommuter rail is also a much smaller, cheaper target to reach for. And it would have a much greater impact on the quality of life in urban and suburban areas. However, the barriers to commuter rail in much of the country are stupid and entrenched. In Raliegh, NC, the main barrier to commuter rail is a county commissioner who believes in some absurd conspiracy theories [1]. [1] http://www.carolinajournal.com/exclusives/display_exclusive.html?id=9165 http://www.carolinajournal.com/exclusives/display_exclusive....
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoThe U.S. is largely built out already. So look at Japan. Japan is 152,000 ish square miles. The United States is 3,717,000 sq miles that are already crisscrossed with Interstates, plus a great deal of air travel infrastructure, plus low-speed rail. It may not be obvious, but rail crashed in the U.S. More than once. There were worthless railroad stock certificates in many attics. These now have actual numismatic value. Then it crashed again after Eisenhower built the Interstate. China is 3,704,000 sq. miles but doesn't have Interstates to the same extent that the U.S. does. The U.S. does pretty well with low speed rail for freight and to a lesser extent, passenger service. But the infrastructure in the U.S. is based on 50 year old technology. China should be able to do much better and by doing so, the U.S. should develop a twinge of envy and possibly emulate them, if it makes sense. The U.S. should ( IMO ) do a lot more "moon shot" things but it didn't work out. I watched this in real time after the moon landing. The shuttle was cool and all, but it was nothing compared to what could have been. We said "BTDT" and went to the disco. When it comes down to it, the U.S. is a lot about granite countertops and not much else. I will not say why I think that is. But the geometry of the way the U.S. is laid out means that you can spend a great deal on air transport before you get to break even with high-speed rail.
- icehawk219 12y agoI completely agree with you but also feel like the big problem is people tend to state it as a case of "why the country, as a whole, needs high speed rail" and as you point out the vast majority of country really doesn't. Or at least doesn't think they do. We'd benefit greatly if we instead looked at it as a case of "why [state/city] should have high speed rail". High speed rail from NYC to LA, while it may be cool and might be a nice big engineering challenge, really just doesn't appeal to most people. But if I, in central NJ, could take a train into Manhattan in under 2 hours, that would actually be incredibly useful and I'd love to be able to. Right now the time and cost of me taking a train from here to DC is prohibitively high compared to driving or taking a flight. These regional cases are where high speed (or at least higher speed) rail would really shine in my opinion.
- adestefan 12y ago
- buckbova 12y ago> California's high-speed rail progress—its proposed San Francisco-to-Los Angeles line remains the only truly fast train project in the country—is the exception that proves the rule; that state's size makes it no example for the rest of the nation. California's rail plan is a lie and a joke. It won't end up being "high speed" rail. It's a waste of taxpayer money. It's another way for politicians to line the pockets of their contributors. Rail line won't meet target travel time. http://articles.latimes.com/2014/mar/27/local/la-me-bullet-train-hearing-20140328 http://articles.latimes.com/2014/mar/27/local/la-me-bullet-t... It will cost more than proposed to the voters. http://californiawatch.org/dailyreport/cost-high-speed-rail-project-balloons-12325 http://californiawatch.org/dailyreport/cost-high-speed-rail-... http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_22929875/california-high-speed-rail-costs-soar-again-this http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_22929875/california-high-speed...
- brandonmenc 12y agoThe electric, self-driving cars we will certainly have in less time than this rail system could be built will be using existing infrastructure - the highway system - to transport us, congestion-free and at higher speeds, to absolutely any city on the map - whether they have a train station or not. Why waste money on a rail system when the whole country is going to look like the car scenes in Minority Report in a couple decades?
- rayiner 12y agoI don't really think that's the future. The most comfortable commute I ever had was the Metro North into Manhattan from Westchester. Can't beat having a bathroom on your commute. Can't beat the physics of rail having lower friction than car tires (especially at higher speeds). In a place like Manhattan, I see self driving cars as a replacement for taxis, not trains. Outside of Manhattan, well who cares about those places?
- brandonmenc 12y agoThere's a bathroom every half-hour on a highway commute.
- rayiner 12y agoThere's a bathroom on the train in a train commute. And other people. And space to get up and stretch your legs.
- brandonmenc 12y agoRest stops have all of these features. So do busses. And planes. Trains don't have a monopoly on this.
- ghaff 12y agoIt's hard to say given that 1.) We're talking decades from now and 2.) We would have to make a lot of assumptions about things like how widespread self-driving car availability would affect congestion. What I can say is that driving from my house in Massachusetts to Manhattan today is both cheaper and faster than taking the Acela by the time you count getting to the train station and getting to my hotel on the other end. I still usually take the train as it's more pleasant--at least if it's just me. If I had a driver (AI or otherwise), probably not.
- smackfu 12y agoNot a fan of the essay style where you dismiss a bunch of possible reasons with single sentences, then spend paragraphs talking about the one part you want to talk about. It overly simplifies issues.
- tormeh 12y agoWell, the business model is hard to get right. It's faster than plane and car on medium distances, but capital costs are enormous compared to either. As far as I know HSR can only be directly profitable with insane population density (Japan). I believe it can be a net economic win for society in general, but a certain kind of government and populace is required to consider that kind of argument.
- hackuser 12y ago> Well, the business model is hard to get right. It's faster than plane and car on medium distances, but capital costs are enormous compared to either. Consider the climate impact costs. Part of the problem is that airlines and car owners externalize a significant cost, making those modes of transportation seem relatively less expensive. In reality, everyone else covers those costs.
- tim333 12y agoOff topic but the graph of trust in the government in Washington descending from 73% to 19% is striking. Now there's a system that looks like it could do with disrupting or fixing or something like that.
- ojbyrne 12y agoI think the problem is not national will, but cost. In my experience (in Korea, and Europe) is that high speed rail is heavily subsidized, but still not competitive with air travel.
- cdoxsey 12y ago> we have a political system in which the federal government, having devolved virtually all decision-making power to states That's definitely not true. Just look at the ACA. > California's high-speed rail progress—its proposed San Francisco-to-Los Angeles line remains the only truly fast train project in the country—is the exception that proves the rule; that state's size makes it no example for the rest of the nation. Yeah let's just pretend that California's train to nowhere is an example other states should emulate. We can't build high speed trains because: (1) the government is corrupt, incompetent and beholden to interest groups and (2) the public doesn't really want them. The best example of public transportation the US has is probably NYC and it really isn't all that great. It's dirty, slow, unreliable, crowded and surprisingly expensive. (at 100$/mo owning a car in almost any other city in the US is cheaper)
- wclax04 12y agoThe NYC public transportation isn't that slow. At least not in my experiences (living here the past 6 years). Are other cities public transportation better? I haven't found any that are close to as convenient as NYC.
- rscharles 12y agoYes, but not in the US. I've used the subway in LA (yes, they have a subway if you can call it that), Washington D.C., and NYC. Go visit Tokyo if you really want to see what you're missing out on. US public transport is a sad joke.
- smackfu 12y agoI don't think you can run a subway like Japan anywhere except Japan. Different culture.
- nayefc 12y agoNYC system is not slow, nor unreliable. Yes, dirty-ish but I'd trade some hygiene for reliability, 24/7 access and speed. It's also not expensive especially if you work in the city and get a pre-tax unlimited card. It also costs way more than $100/month to own a card in NYC.
- Aloha 12y agoThere are really only 3 or 4 viable high speed rail corridors in the US: Northeast Corridor (Boston - Washington DC) LA - SF Chicago - NYC and possibly Seattle - Portland Beyond that, the traffic densities present are not enough to justify high speed rail - not to mention, even nonstop at 200 mph from LA/SF/Seattle to Chicago (or any eastern point) is a minimum of 10 hours in transit, versus 3ish to fly.
- com2kid 12y ago> Beyond that, the traffic densities present are not enough to justify high speed rail Remember that building transit infrastructure will also create new traffic! As an example, park and rides an hour out from Seattle are packed full of cars every day. Busses are then packed full of people every day heading into the city from as much as 40 miles out. IMHO what would be more interesting would be Vancouver BC --> Bellingham --> Midway to Seattle --> Seattle --> Tacoma --> Portland Of course going across the boarder makes this impractical. :(
- mahyarm 12y agoSo you mean the Amtrak Cascades Route? http://www.amtrak.com/cascades-train http://www.amtrak.com/cascades-train
- com2kid 12y agoBump that up by a few hundred miles per hour and it'd be worthwhile. :) 80MPH doesn't save that much time!
- brightsize 12y agoWhat would be interesting to me would be a Seattle<->Spokane HS line. Maybe it could run along the Empire Builder route? The cities are separated by around 280 miles using I-90 and flights take around an hour tarmac-to-tarmac. If you flew tomorrow the flight would cost around $200 RT. But you have to fly via Seatac which isn't exactly convenient if you're going to the city. The Amtrak station is right downtown in both cities. Such a connection could bring some much-needed economic development to Spokane, and might even turn it into a bedroom community of Seattle for some people - the economics might work out considering that a $1M house in Seattle might run you $200K here.
- malchow 12y agoIt could be that the US's high-risk/high-reward/failure-positive ethic means that elastic transportation routings are more economically valuable than fixed-segment trains. A train is 10% better than a jet from SF to LA. A train is much worse than a jet for SF to NY. All other pairings -- or so one might argue -- are so much lesser in density that the elasticity of roads is vastly preferable.
- hackuser 12y ago> A train is 10% better than a jet from SF to LA. A train is much worse than a jet for SF to NY. All other pairings -- or so one might argue -- are so much lesser in density that the elasticity of roads is vastly preferable. I think there are many other possibilities, and also many people live in cities of hundreds of thousands, all over America, and they'd like to travel too. * The NE corridor, from DC to Boston, of course. Maybe south to NC * Chicago - Indianapolis - Cincinnati - Columbus - Pittsburgh - Cleveland - Detroit (- Toronto) (That would include a spur or two, of course.) And what about people in Green Bay and Grand Rapids? * The Florida cities, maybe up to Atlanta or West to New Orleans * Texas cities
- JackFr 12y agoArticle seems kind of ludicrous. It weirdly blames Federalism, ignores the airlines, the auto industry and the rail freight business, all which would stand to lose if public transportation dollars and regulation moved to significant passenger rail investment.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agotl;dr: Basically, it's because the population density is too low. High speed rail is great for population centers that are 300 miles apart, but not so great for ones that are 1500 miles apart. The competition there is primarily the airplane, and the time difference grows with distance. So does the cost difference. (You only need an airport in each city, no matter how far apart they are, but you need a mile of railroad for each mile of distance.) The problem, then, is that the US doesn't have enough population centers that are big enough and close enough to each other. The northeast corridor (from Boston to Washington DC) is really the only one that fits.
- fowkswe 12y agoThe US has been bought and manipulated by the automobile and oil industries. From early on when GM and others bought the street car networks and shut them down, to lobbying the Eisenhower interstate network in place, this country has been and continues to be built around the idea that everyone should be required to use a car to participate in all aspects of their lives. In order for an intercity rail network to work, it needs to link dense urban cores that also have useful transit systems. A train between Omaha and Kansas City does no good if you get off the train then face a 14 mile journey through the suburbs to your destination. 2 things need to happen before a rail network makes sense: 1. Urban infill. I know Denver has a policy for this in place, I'm sure others do too. But sooo many city cores have huge tracts of land that are derelict, or unused. New development should be incentivized to make use of this land. 2. Growth boundary regulation. Portland is the best example of this. With out this you get the exurbs and sprawl (sorry to point out Kansas City again, but it is one of the worst offenders here) which demand a car to traverse.
- hackuser 12y agoPer an engineer in the train industry [1], an essential requirement is effective mass transit in the cities where the high-speed rail stops. Without that, passengers can't reach the inter-city trains easily enough. [1] The kind of engineer who designs trains (and related systems), not the kind who drives them.