3 ms·
I've written simple scheduling software. The only consideration taken by this scheduling software were worker preferences: management doesn't care who covers
by bryanlarsen 12y ago
I've written simple scheduling software. The only consideration taken by this scheduling software were worker preferences: management doesn't care who covers the shifts, just that they're covered. So it took into account "fairness", day of week preferences, scheduled holidays, et cetera.
By those measures, the software does a lot better than humans. However, there's something to be said about the predictability of the old human schedules. The humans generally just figured out a 2 week schedule and repeated it; filling in holes created by scheduling conflicts with those workers they knew were usually eager to pick up more work.
IOW, you may previously have worked every 2nd Tuesday. If you couldn't work on a particular Tuesday, you just didn't work. Now you're much more likely to get a solid 2 shifts a month (presuming that's what you asked for), most will be on days you marked as preferred, some days may be on some you marked as available and none on days you marked as not available.
Now obviously I could have added a metric to guide the system towards more 'regular' schedules. But it would still compensate for those other considerations, and would still look somewhat random. It's usually pretty easy to tell the difference between a computer-generated and a human-generated schedule, and many people still prefer the human generated ones, even if it is less 'fair' by almost any measure.
Given how crazy a schedule generated solely by worker preferences is, I shudder to consider schedules driven solely by management preference...
- waps 12y agoWhat really helps is if the employees can 1) go online and see their "proposed" schedule months out, ideally with decent export options 2) can trade shifts, ideally online in some app (and have contact info for their colleagues) 3) have a schedule printer in the office 4) can report in ill on the app 5) and of course, manager needs to be hands-off from the schedule (you can of course, build this into the software by making sure it has a "how many urgent changes" counter for managers, so their bosses can see how finicky they are) Especially you shouldn't build in the ability to give monetary incentives for work. That'll cause a race to the bottom on part of the employees.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoYes, my scheduling software has those, or equivalents. iCalendar export, a way to email everybody if you get sick, et cetera. It works on the honour system: anybody with a login can schedule anybody else for a particular shift. The presumption is that the other party has agreed to the change, and that assumption hasn't been violated for the 5 years they've used the software. If that presumption ever gets violated I suppose I may be asked to put in more verification, but I suspect that the response likely would be to remove the offender from the group. In retrospect, that's perhaps all I should have built. But the schedule optimization part was the "fun" part. The rest is pretty standard CRUD + email webapp.
- rayiner 12y agoI think the issue is more with how the software enables crazy dehumanizing things like demand scheduling.