4 ms·
NASA should promote spaceflight and bolster technology innovations by offering tremendously huge prizes for companies that can overcome major obstacles, like lo
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
NASA should promote spaceflight and bolster technology innovations by offering tremendously huge prizes for companies that can overcome major obstacles, like lowering cost-to-orbit by a factor of a hundred.
They shouldn't be the space police, or the space bureaucracy, or the space experts.
If we were to reduce cost-to-orbit by a factor of a hundred, then you could launch satellites for a couple of hundred thousand dollars. You could have deep space telescopes for the cost of a new luxury airliner. It changes everything.
Whereas if we keep doing these one-off missions where we do this huge development effort and make no major breakthroughs, everything stays expensive for a very long time.
- voidmain 17y agoIf you could lower cost-to-orbit by a factor of a hundred, you wouldn't need a NASA prize to make money! Prizes can be a good idea, but not for things so spectacularly easy to monetize.
- SamAtt 17y agoI'm not sure I see the incentive here. Follow my logic. A prize is valuable because it's something you couldn't afford yourself. If I offered $1 prize people probably wouldn't be too psyched about it because a dollar is something they could spare out of their own pocket. The whole point of this article is that NASA doesn't have enough money to overcome the hurdles you refer to. So it stands to reason that companies would have to spend more to overcome the hurdles than the prizes themself would be worth. Which is why I don't see how prizes would have any positive impact.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoBy offering a prize, a large organization can "pay ahead" the cost of developing, testing, and implementing a new technology. Look at it this way: let's assume it would cost the government $20 Billion to reduce cost-to-orbit by three-fold, say through the use of hybrid-magnetic launchers or some such. But that $20 Billion would take 20 years and dozens of missions. Instead the agency could offer a $10 Billion prize for any company that had three successive launches at one-third the cost in the next three years. Each year after that the prize would increase by $1 Billion. Now, instead of one technology, pursued by one agency, you have a dozen possible solutions pursued by a dozen organizations. At some point the prize money is paid out -- arguably much earlier than 20 years but who knows? It's definitely not going to cost any more money, and now you've decreased cost-to-orbit of every other mission you ever want to have. That means for every mission you have after the goal is reached, you've reduced launch costs by two-thirds. Forever. In addition, you're likely to end up with 3 or 4 technologies that all can reduce cost-to-orbit, all that are viable. That's why reducing cost-to-orbit is such a critical goal. It's this huge productivity multiplier. Yes, you spend more now, but it makes all the other decisions easier (eventually). You quickly reach a point where lots of entities have the funds to do multiple missions using lots of new technologies -- a much better situation than continuing to pay more and more money for less and less return.
- rbanffy 17y agoI think prizes are not the way to go - the amounts of money would need to be staggering. Offering guaranteed fixed-price contracts like they plan to do with SpaceX is seemingly the best way to go. NASA still has to resupply the ISS, move crews and cargo and put spacecraft in orbit. By making companies bid on tasks they need done they will induce the development of the technologies required and ultimately lower their own (and our) costs.
- fatdog789 17y agoIt only costs a few hundred thousand dollars to launch a few satellites. Deep space telescopes do cost less than a luxury airliner. (The Dreamliner and Airbus Monsterplane both cost in excess of $250M/per -- and that doesn't include customizations). We have NASA to thank for that -- without a government agency willing to shell out hundreds of billions of dollars on research, this sort of stuff would cost hundreds of millions of dollars per launch. NASA also isn't the space police. It is the space bureaucracy, and the space experts agency, primarily because the private sector didn't care enough about space to do any of this stuff itself. NASA exists because of the failure of the private sector. But prizes are a good idea -- it's more than time for the private sector to get into the game.
- wlievens 17y agoWhile you're right, you're talking about the past 40 years. I think the post parent is talking about the next 40 years.