4 ms·
It is in revealing things like this that make me question Snowden. While both points are interesting and maybe a little troubling, they are certainly not whist
by slg 12y ago
It is in revealing things like this that make me question Snowden. While both points are interesting and maybe a little troubling, they are certainly not whistleblowing in the name of protecting the rights of American citizens. He has moved from simply exposing the breadth of the domestic spying apparatus to exposing the tactics the United States uses in legitimate espionage operations. Isn't trying to compromise the communication network of a country like Syria the exact thing the NSA is supposed to be doing? And what positive value comes from Snowden releasing something like that?
- djb_hackernews 12y ago> Isn't trying to compromise the communication network of a country like Syria the exact thing the NSA is supposed to be doing? No
- scrollaway 12y ago> Isn't trying to compromise the communication network of a country like Syria the exact thing the NSA is supposed to be doing? What is wrong with you; what the hell do you have against Syria? What if this was France? The UK? Germany? This was a mistake that happened while "attempting to bug Syria". Knowing the NSA, they bug almost every country out there — so yes, this could have happened to any of the ones I've listed. Internet is a public service, one as essential as water and electricity. How do you call a country that disrupts another country's public services? In my book, I call it an act of war. So you tell me, slg, is it the NSA's job to randomly decide to declare war against other countries?
- devindotcom 12y agoGetting intelligence out of a country in the middle of a civil war, in a powderkeg of a region, seems pretty critical to me. We also have spies and malware installed all over the world, and the world is doing its best to spy on and infiltrate us. This is the reality of espionage, intelligence, and counter-intelligence.
- scrollaway 12y agoThis school playground logic of "it's ok because they started it" sickens me. OK. I get it; espionage is a reality and only espionage can deal with it. But for god sake there's people in here commenting that Snowden is a traitor because he leaked information that didn't directly concern the american people. Really, now. Compare those two situations: "A group of hackers have targeted Syrian ISPs and, in an attempt to wiretap the nation, have brought down internet services in the entire country" <- Scum of the earth! How dare they! People have likely died as a result of this; in the midst of a civil war, too! "The NSA has targeted Syrian ISPs and, in an attempt to wiretap the nation, has brought down internet services in the entire country" <- Well it's OK because other countries are doing it too. Also, by revealing this, you are an unpatriotic traitor and have endangered the american people." I call BS. Some people here either lack the most basic critical thinking skills, or are NSA shills.
- slg 12y agoNo one is saying that it is ok because they started it. We are saying that we believe international espionage is a requirement for a country like the US and this operation seemed to be a standard and worthwhile one that happened to be a spectacular failure. You are free to disagree, but I don't think any serious politician in the US would. Revealing something like this doesn't seem to advance Snowden's initial goals and makes it incredibly hard to gain any political support in the US. So my initial question stands, what positive value comes from Snowden releasing something like that?
- tedks 12y agoNo serious politician would support universal health care, basic income, or full human rights for LGBT people, but that doesn't make those causes any less right. What positive value comes from Snowden releasing the atrocities of the American government? Well, some people have a moral compass more developed than "espionage is a reality and the American government should be able to do as much of it as it wants, in any country, at any time, with any consequences." Try to be on the right side of history. This is your chance to do that. Maybe you were alive in the 60s or even the 20s, but if you weren't, you're here now, and you can be a part of the struggles we fight today and tomorrow.
- josu 12y agoInternet is no longer just a public service, it's a Human Right http://www.wired.com/2011/06/internet-a-human-right/ http://www.wired.com/2011/06/internet-a-human-right/
- jackbravo 12y agoThere are good replies to this question in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8173019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8173019 I don't think spying and disrupting communications on a country you are not at war at, and that is going through a civil war (putting the lives of innocent people on the edge), is the type of things the NSA should be doing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- foxhedgehog 12y agoThe vast majority of the documents that Snowden took are related not to NSA snooping, but to military order of battle (http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/terence-p-jeffrey/dia-director-snowden-potentially-put-lives-us-troops-risk-dni-lives http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/terence-p-jeffrey/dia-di...). The only entities that would have an interest in that kind of information would be foreign governments. I'm not sure what positive value would result from that kind of leak.
- scintill76 12y agoWhy do you trust the DIA? I know that objectively, we can't really take Snowden's word either, but isn't it going to be in the government's interest to say things like this to paint him as a traitor?