3 ms·
Interesting to compare this article to the earlier one on Turing. For the Turing article, the gist was that Gordon Brown forgave the harsh and inhumane treatme
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Interesting to compare this article to the earlier one on Turing.
For the Turing article, the gist was that Gordon Brown forgave the harsh and inhumane treatment of Turing that happened a long time ago. Nobody around today was directly involved and this -- like it or not - is more symbolism than substance.
For this article, the gist is that fat people are fat because of genetics. There are lots of fat people around today. Billions are spent on trying to make fat people thin, and millions die from the results of being fat. It's a current and immanent threat to our fellow citizens.
For the Turing article, most of the comments were along the lines of "way to go!" and "it's about time!" -- very encouraging that something was being done.
For the fatso article, most of the comments (so far) are along the lines of "Those damn fat people, they should just stop eating so much!" -- very discouraging that anything besides blaming behavior (which amounts to blaming the fat person) amounted to much. I believe one commenter said it was "just giving fat people an excuse to stay fat" (it was subsequently deleted)
I'm sure you guys will tell me that my comparison is all wrong, but I find some interesting parallels nonetheless.
- sp332 17y agoThe comparison is wrong because the gays didn't want to be "cured". Fat people spend billions to "cure" themselves. If fat people were content to be fat, there wouldn't be so many people saying "well just don't eat so much!".
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoSo these commenters are being helpful? I don't see where the motives of the people involved as the object of the story come into it. The point I was making was the motives of the people commenting right here on the article. We have two situations: one in the past where nothing can really be done and one in the present where we have this catastrophe. For the thing in the past, commenters are generally very happy and enthused that a symbolic step was taken. For the thing in the present, commenters are angry that fat people have brought this on themselves, and seem immune to any idea that there's anything involved except a morality play in which fat people are the guilty, ie, nothing should be done except shaming the people involved. To put a fine point on it: people are very moral. Don't let anybody fool you. There are groups which are okay to trash and groups that are not. Distant, symbolic action is preferred over immediate threats. Modern righteousness generally consists of making yourself feel superior to other folks, whether it is tormentors of Turing or the fatso sitting in the cube next to you (and I speak as a fat person, for whatever that's worth) Now I'm probably smoking crack, but that's my thesis, in case you missed it.
- jongraehl 17y agoI agree that people are blind to contemporary stupidity and self-congratulatory about past stupidity they have overcome. People love visiting museums that make them appreciate how far we've come in overcoming racism, genocide, and medieval torture (well, scratch that last one, we have to fight the War on Terruh after all). Nonetheless, I think the Turing spectacle is valuable because public shows of support will influence fence-sitters to emulate us in support of awesome gay people.